>> Greetings, all.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 45 lines]
>
> PB
>>> Greetings, all.
>>>
[quoted text clipped - 66 lines]
>
> Mike
Thanks for the prompt reply.
I am able to use a soldering iron. The traces and pads look far enough
apart that the risk of bridging a solder joint seems minimal. So
another question might be is the fix worth the effort, or, while I have
the area exposed, is a new Acura part the better route for reliability?
In which case I would still re-flow the solder joints on the old one
retaining it as a ready spare.
Did the part manufacturing process address the defect and are new parts
likely to be free of the problem?
Thanks once again,
PB (but really Mike, too)
Michael Pardee - 24 Jun 2006 17:17 GMT
> I am able to use a soldering iron. The traces and pads look far enough
> apart that the risk of bridging a solder joint seems minimal. So another
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> PB (but really Mike, too)
The repair is a piece of cake for anybody who has soldered PC boards or
other semi-delicate parts. This problem is not unique to Honda products. It
comes from the bad practice of using solder as the strength part to mount
components - especially heavy components like relays - to circuit boards in
high-vibration environments. I doubt the current ones cement the parts down
before soldering them, which is what is needed to relieve the stress on the
weak and fairly brittle solder connections. But I suppose a decade of life
is what they consider acceptable.
Resoldering is a perfectly acceptable choice, especially if you use some
cement to support the parts on the circuit board while you are at it.
Mike
Jim Yanik - 24 Jun 2006 18:54 GMT
>>>> Greetings, all.
>>>>
[quoted text clipped - 77 lines]
> have the area exposed, is a new Acura part the better route for
> reliability?
I resoldered mine (94 Integra GSR) about 5 years ago,not a problem since.
The relay is on the left side of the driver's footwell,up under the trim
panel.I removed it to get easier access.
> In which case I would still re-flow the solder joints on the old one
> retaining it as a ready spare.
>
> Did the part manufacturing process address the defect and are new
> parts likely to be free of the problem?
Who knows?
It's doubtful that the relay maker even knows about the MR solder joint
problem or that they could do anything to correct it.

Signature
Jim Yanik
jyanik
at
kua.net
My son says the relay is bolted to the side (he described it as actually
being bolted to the kick panel, but that doesn't seem right) above the
clutch pedal.
Mike