 |
 | Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us |
 | Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network |
Car Forum / BMW Cars / March 2007The new 5-Series vs. Pontiac
Got my latest Car & Driver magazine yesterday. The April '07 issue with the picture of the 911 and the (butt-ugly) Audi R8 on the cover. Was paging through it and looking over the pages covering new models soon to come out. On page 35 there is a story, with pictures, of the Aussie-derived Pontiac G8 which, other than the silly hood scoops and over-done Pontiac nose, appears to be a very nice car. At the bottom of Page 36 there is a small photo of a car that I first took to be some Pontiac mid-size car with a nose slightly mis-matched from the rest of the car. Pause. It's not. It's the 2008 5-Series. I challenge anyone to look at that picture and not think they are looking at a Pontiac sedan. BMW has lost its way as far as styling is concerned...unless you are a big fan of the Pontiac look. Actually, the Pontiacs are starting to look more tasteful than the BMW's that GM uses for inspiration, clearly. I'm going to have to keep the 330i longer than I had originally thought. - GRL > Got my latest Car & Driver magazine yesterday. The April '07 issue with > the picture of the 911 and the (butt-ugly) Audi R8 on the cover. Was [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] > > - GRL Hey, when you turn your styling over to the guy that designed the horrible Pontiac Aztec, what do you expect? >> Got my latest Car & Driver magazine yesterday. The April '07 issue with >> the picture of the 911 and the (butt-ugly) Audi R8 on the cover. Was [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] >Hey, when you turn your styling over to the guy that designed the horrible >Pontiac Aztec, what do you expect? The Aztec is just about the ugliest vehicle I have ever seen in the 50 years I have been paying attention to autos. Do you mean Bangle designed it? >>> Got my latest Car & Driver magazine yesterday. The April '07 issue with >>> the picture of the 911 and the (butt-ugly) Audi R8 on the cover. Was [quoted text clipped - 30 lines] > years > I have been paying attention to autos. Do you mean Bangle designed it? Yep. That was his job prior to BMW. >>>>Got my latest Car & Driver magazine yesterday. The April '07 issue with >>>>the picture of the 911 and the (butt-ugly) Audi R8 on the cover. Was [quoted text clipped - 32 lines] > > Yep. That was his job prior to BMW. Bullshit. The Aztec was an experiment in "design by committee" gone wrong. Bangle never worked at Pontiac: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Bangle http://www.dld-conference.com/2006/11/chris_bangle.html http://www.answers.com/topic/chris-bangle Nice try though...  Signature-Fred W Yeah, Bangle's not good, but he's not Aztec-level bad. That had to be a GM committee job or at least some guy working alone who had gone off his meds and was taking placebo by mistake. - nopcbs >>>>>Got my latest Car & Driver magazine yesterday. The April '07 issue with >>>>>the picture of the 911 and the (butt-ugly) Audi R8 on the cover. Was [quoted text clipped - 45 lines] > > Nice try though... > Pause. It's not. It's the 2008 5-Series. > I challenge anyone to look at that picture and not think they are looking at > a Pontiac sedan. I believe that could be 'cause Pontiac found it easy to copy BMW.. not the other way around. > BMW has lost its way as far as styling is concerned...unless you are a big > fan of the Pontiac look. If you consider the kidney grilles - BMW and Pontiac have both used these for a long long time. > Actually, the Pontiacs are starting to look more tasteful than the BMW's > that GM uses for inspiration, clearly. > > I'm going to have to keep the 330i longer than I had originally thought. Good for you. I doubt if it bothers BMW in the least - they don't seem to have any problems selling whatever they decide to make. The keep reporting record sales and record profits - when every other car maker is in the toilet. If they're doing something wrong, they're doing it wrong awfully well. > - GRL What's more interesting is how much the Bangle design has moved across other car lines. Mercedes S-Class - Bangle Butt, Hundai - Bangle Butt and Honda - big time Bangle Butt. Everyone is adopting some form of "flame styling".. Whod'a thunk it? As you say, the Pontiac split-grill look is VERY old (early 60's at least) and I think you are wrong about that being a BMW-copy. By the way, BMW does not consider that "twin kidney" term to be what they want you to think of. More like nostrils. Heck, what creature runs around with their kidneys way out in front? Well, actually, they do have trouble selling some cars. The Z3 sold poorly. As did the Coupe. As did the Bangle-ized 7-Series. Mostly, you are right, though. Most of what they make sells very well, but the same can be said (in spades) of Toyotas. If your point is just to make money, that is great success both counts. If the point is also to make memorable and handsome cars, that is a different matter and BMW is largely failing of late. I expect more of BMW. I think other hard-core BMW-heads feel the same. The people who just want a fashion statement with a Roundel on it probably don't, and there are plenty of them to buy anything BMW sells. - nopcbs >> Pause. It's not. It's the 2008 5-Series. > [quoted text clipped - 30 lines] > > Whod'a thunk it? > The Z3 sold poorly. Compared to? Tom K. >> The Z3 sold poorly. > >Compared to? Seriously - the Z4 hasn't sold *nearly* as well. Of course, that's great for those of us that like them - some great deals to be had! epbrown -- How can you know where I'm at if you haven't been where I been? Can you see where I'm coming from? "How I Could Just Kill A Man" Cypress Hill >> Well, actually, they do have trouble selling some cars. The Z3 sold >> poorly. > As did the Coupe. As did the Bangle-ized 7-Series. Actually, the E36/7 Z3 and E36/8 Z3 Coupe sold almost 300,000 units during its 7 year production, that far exceeded BMW expectation. Similarly, the E65/E66 7 Series is the most successful 7 Series ever, accounting for over 160,000 units during the first 3 years and outperformed the E38 7 series' best year by 14%! Moreover, looking at all the copycat "Bangle-butts" on various Lexus/Toyota, Acura/Honda, Mercedes, etc., and it appears Bangle's "vision" is more popular than ever!!!! > Moreover, looking at all the copycat "Bangle-butts" on various Lexus/Toyota, > Acura/Honda, Mercedes, etc., and it appears Bangle's "vision" is more > popular than ever!!!! So is "American Idol" ... -- C.R. Krieger (Not fooled by popularity) >> Moreover, looking at all the copycat "Bangle-butts" on various >> Lexus/Toyota, [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > C.R. Krieger > (Not fooled by popularity) When American composer, Charles Ives, was awarded a $500.00 Pulitzer Prize for his Symphony # 3 some 40 years after it was written, he remarked that "Prizes are the badge of mediocrity." Tom K. >>> Moreover, looking at all the copycat "Bangle-butts" on various >>> Lexus/Toyota, [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > for his Symphony # 3 some 40 years after it was written, he remarked that > "Prizes are the badge of mediocrity." Perhaps written 40 years earlier, but first performed in 1946, and awarded the Pulitzer for Music the year after, in 1947. 60 years after that a Pulitzer consultant remarked, "Some people are just naturally grouchy." Alan Brooks Webmaster for The Pulitzer Prizes '69 1600, '74 2002tii, '80 320i, '89 325i, '91 325iX |
Reply to this Message |
 Sign In
 Join
 My Latest Posts My Monitored Threads My Blog My Photo Gallery My Profile My Homepage Start New Thread Enable EMail Alerts Rate this Thread
|
©2008 Advenet LLC Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.