Yes, the newer BMWs have this (automatics and manuals). It only does this
for a few seconds, then releases, so you can still roll back.
> >I have a question about the last line in the blurb... does it mean that
>>when you are on a hill and you car has a manual tran, that the car will
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> --- AntiSpam/harvest ---
> Remove X's to send email to me.
> Yes, the newer BMWs have this (automatics and manuals). It only does this
> for a few seconds, then releases, so you can still roll back.
Why would you want or need this on an automatic? The engine idling
already holds the car from rolling back on most hills and, well, you do
have a spare foot down there doing nothing...

Signature
-Fred W
Dori A Schmetterling - 17 Nov 2005 01:41 GMT
Not necessarily. On my (other famous German brand) car, model 2001, the car
rolls back on a hill despite the auto gearbox. Was very disconcerting at
first since my old 1993 model (from same famous brand) does not do this.
I am told this rollback is quite common now (and is not a fault).
DAS

Signature
For direct contact replace nospam with schmetterling
---
[...]
> Why would you want or need this on an automatic? The engine idling
> already holds the car from rolling back on most hills and, well, you do
> have a spare foot down there doing nothing...
330xi@canada - 17 Nov 2005 02:38 GMT
the anti rollback feature does work for manual and auto trans.
and it only uses the brake pad not clutch, the point is to save the
stress on the clutch not ad to it.
> Not necessarily. On my (other famous German brand) car, model 2001, the
> car rolls back on a hill despite the auto gearbox. Was very disconcerting
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>> already holds the car from rolling back on most hills and, well, you do
>> have a spare foot down there doing nothing...
Paul Martin - 17 Nov 2005 08:06 GMT
I drive a manual E46 and I can hill-start so I don't care!
But I would say it would work on slopes which are even too steep for the
engine to hold on idle. Maybe.
>> Yes, the newer BMWs have this (automatics and manuals). It only does this
>> for a few seconds, then releases, so you can still roll back.
>
> Why would you want or need this on an automatic? The engine idling
> already holds the car from rolling back on most hills and, well, you do
> have a spare foot down there doing nothing...
In my 6-speed it only works if the clutch pedal is pressed down. So
rolling back can be easily done by letting off the brake while out of
gear - just don't push the clutch pedal.
>>Subaru had this years back "Hill Holder Clutch". I would hope BMW has
>>tied it
>>into the clutch, otherwise, if your engine dies, you'd not be able to move
>>back
>>into a parking spot or back into your driveway, if the driveway is
>>downhill....