Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
HomeAnnouncements
Discussion Groups
By Brand
BMWChevroletDodgeFordGMHondaLexusMercedes-BenzNissanPeugeotToyotaVolkswagenOther Brands
By Topic
4x4 CarsRVsDrivingMaintenance & RepairCar AudioCollectible Cars
Country Specific
Australian ForumsUK Forums
ArticlesAuto InsuranceBuyingCars & TechnologyMaintenanceMiscellaneousSafety
DMV Resources
Related Topics
MotorcyclesBoatsMore Topics ...

Car Forum / BMW Cars / February 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Cross-threaded lug-bolt hole - HELP!

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
wanka - 03 Feb 2006 14:32 GMT
2004 E46 330Cic

I have managed to cross-thread one of the lug-bolt holes.  Yeah, I'm an
idiot, what can I say?  I realized my mistake the instant it happened,
so it's probably less than a whole turn that's cross-threaded.

I'm not sure how easy it is (or even if it's possible)to approach the
hole from the back and re-tap the thread but that would be my preference
if it's doable.  Any other options or advice please?

Jon
Mike G - 03 Feb 2006 19:41 GMT
> 2004 E46 330Cic
>
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> hole from the back and re-tap the thread but that would be my preference
> if it's doable.  Any other options or advice please?

I'm not familiar with the E46 in particular, but I'd be surprised if there
is enough clearance to tap the hub from the rear without removing it first.
Though you might just succeed if you canibalise the tap. Even to the extent
of cutting it down to just a small stub, with a pair of flats for a spanner.

If you're very careful though, making sure the tap is absolutely square.
(use a small square or something fabricated to constantly check) you may be
able to pick the original thread up from the front.
That would be my first option.

Failing all those, a final option, without hub removal, would be to drill it
out and fit a 'Helicoil' thread insert. Make sure it is a genuine Armstrong
Helicoil. Not one of the many thread inserts made by other Co's, that IMO
are just nowhere near as good.
Mike.
R. Mark Clayton - 03 Feb 2006 21:24 GMT
> 2004 E46 330Cic
>
> I have managed to cross-thread one of the lug-bolt holes.  Yeah, I'm an
> idiot, what can I say?  I realized my mistake the instant it happened,
> so it's probably less than a whole turn that's cross-threaded.

And the rest.

> I'm not sure how easy it is (or even if it's possible)to approach the
> hole from the back and re-tap the thread but that would be my preference
> if it's doable.  Any other options or advice please?
>
> Jon

Get a magnifying glass and have a close look.

Use suitable tools (e.g. wood chisel - sacrificed) to try and put the
original threads back in position.  Remove any that are mashed.

In principle you should then be able to use a tap (or a Hilti bolt the right
size) to refurbish the thread.  As the thread starts gradually on the tap
you should be able to get it started very easily and once going push any
bent squashed bits back into position (albeit a bit weaker).

If the tap jams (e.g. to trapped pieces of loose thread) remove it, remove
any impediments and start again.

Have another look and remove any loose bits of thread etc.

Finally refit your bolt - but line it up properly first this time!

Unless the threaded section is very thin your should be OK.
R. Mark Clayton - 03 Feb 2006 21:25 GMT
> 2004 E46 330Cic
>
> I have managed to cross-thread one of the lug-bolt holes.  Yeah, I'm an
> idiot, what can I say?  I realized my mistake the instant it happened,
> so it's probably less than a whole turn that's cross-threaded.

And the rest.

> I'm not sure how easy it is (or even if it's possible)to approach the
> hole from the back and re-tap the thread but that would be my preference
> if it's doable.  Any other options or advice please?
>
> Jon

Get a magnifying glass and have a close look.

Use suitable tools (e.g. wood chisel - sacrificed) to try and put the
original threads back in position.  Remove any that are mashed.

In principle you should then be able to use a tap (or a Hilti bolt the right
size) to refurbish the thread.  As the thread starts gradually on the tap
you should be able to get it started very easily and once going push any
bent squashed bits back into position (albet a bit weaker).

If the tap jams (e.g. to trapped pieces of loose thread) remove it, remove
any impedements and start again.

Have another look and remove any loose bits of thread etc.

Finally refit your bolt - but line it up properly first this time!

Unless the threaded section is very thin your should be OK.
R. Mark Clayton - 03 Feb 2006 21:25 GMT
> 2004 E46 330Cic
>
> I have managed to cross-thread one of the lug-bolt holes.  Yeah, I'm an
> idiot, what can I say?  I realized my mistake the instant it happened,
> so it's probably less than a whole turn that's cross-threaded.

And the rest.

> I'm not sure how easy it is (or even if it's possible)to approach the
> hole from the back and re-tap the thread but that would be my preference
> if it's doable.  Any other options or advice please?
>
> Jon

Get a magnifying glass and have a close look.

Use suitable tools (e.g. wood chisel - sacrificed) to try and put the
original threads back in position.  Remove any that are mashed.

In principle you should then be able to use a tap (or a Hilti bolt the right
size) to refurbish the thread.  As the thread starts gradually on the tap
you should be able to get it started very easily and once going push any
bent squashed bits back into position (albeit a bit weaker).

If the tap jams (e.g. to trapped pieces of loose thread) remove it, remove
any impediments and start again.

Have another look and remove any loose bits of thread etc.

Finally refit your bolt - but line it up properly first this time!

Unless the threaded section is very thin your should be OK.
Dean Dark - 03 Feb 2006 23:03 GMT
>Use suitable tools (e.g. wood chisel - sacrificed) to try and put the
>original threads back in position.  Remove any that are mashed.
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
>Unless the threaded section is very thin your should be OK.

Why on *earth* you would go to all this trouble to fix a problem that
really should be properly repaired, either with a replacement part or
a properly done Helicoil, beats the brown stuff out of me.  But hey!
Maybe that's just me.

Wood chisels to bend and chop wheel bolt threads back into shape.
<Shakes head>  Recuses self from further discussion.
Signature

Dan.

E28 Guy© - 06 Feb 2006 19:16 GMT
> >Use suitable tools
> >
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> a properly done Helicoil, beats the brown stuff out of me.  But hey!
> Maybe that's just me.

Have you priced a BMW hub assembly lately?  Do you know how much work
it is to get one apart?  The guy fixed it for the princely sum of $5
plus about 15 minutes' work he did himself.  Not all of us are made out
of money and, even if we were, there's no reason *not* to perform such
a simple procedure on our own cars - unless it cuts very deeply into
daytrading time.
--
C.R. Krieger
(Been there; done that)
Fred W - 06 Feb 2006 20:15 GMT
>>>Use suitable tools
>>>
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> C.R. Krieger
> (Been there; done that)

chuckle...

Signature

-Fred W

Dean Dark - 07 Feb 2006 01:47 GMT
(on using wood chisels to chop a mangled wheel bolt thread back into
shape)

>>>Why on *earth* you would go to all this trouble to fix a problem that
>>>really should be properly repaired, either with a replacement part or
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>>
>chuckle...

Yeah, me too.  I read somewhere that you can use an adze to hone
cylinder bores.  Anyone want to try that?
Signature

Dan.

Misterbeets - 07 Feb 2006 01:49 GMT
What specifically is improper about the repair?
Dean Dark - 07 Feb 2006 02:06 GMT
>What specifically is improper about the repair?

Nothing at all, if you think that it's OK to bend damaged wheel bolt
threads back into alignment with wood chisels then fine.  Me?  I'd use
the big ol' screwdriver that I use mostly as a pry bar.  My wood
chisels are too precious to use for something like that.
Signature

Dan.

E28 Guy© - 07 Feb 2006 21:02 GMT
> >What specifically is improper about the repair?
>
> Nothing at all, if you think that it's OK to bend damaged wheel bolt
> threads back into alignment with wood chisels then fine.  Me?  I'd use
> the big ol' screwdriver that I use mostly as a pry bar.  My wood
> chisels are too precious to use for something like that.

Is *that* what your beef was?  In that case, I apologize.  Frankly, as
someone who definitely does *not* get along with wood, I never noticed
that discrepancy in the suggested procedure.  I agree I would probably
not use a wood chisel to do this, except that in my case, it's because
I probably wouldn't be able to *locate* a wood chisel.  However, if I
found the right one (the 1/4" would be almost an ideal size), you'd be
cringing at what happens next ...
--
C.R. Krieger
(Been wrong before)
Dean Dark - 07 Feb 2006 23:03 GMT
>> >What specifically is improper about the repair?
>>
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
>found the right one (the 1/4" would be almost an ideal size), you'd be
>cringing at what happens next ...

Well, not just abusing wood chisels.  I also think that bending and
bodging threads - especially important ones like wheel mounting bolt
holes - is unwise.  I was kind of being sarcastic about my big ol'
screwdriver pry bar.
Signature

Dan.

E28 Guy© - 08 Feb 2006 17:15 GMT
> Well, not just abusing wood chisels.  I also think that bending and
> bodging threads - especially important ones like wheel mounting bolt
> holes - is unwise.  I was kind of being sarcastic about my big ol'
> screwdriver pry bar.

Heck, I just figured your hand-eye coordination was maybe better than
most.

As for the relative importance of wheel bolt holes, I suspect we'd
disagree on that.  For starters, the guy said it was less than a full
turn of the bolt.  That's not much compared to the full four or five
the bolt takes to seat it.  Second, there's a *reason* they use five
bolts on those wheels.  If you've never found a single one loose when
you checked them, then you're either anal retentive about checking them
or you're unusually lucky.  One could easily sneak up on the 'off side'
of your car, remove a wheel bolt, and you'd not notice it until you
looked.
--
C.R. Krieger
(Been there; drove that)
Jeff Strickland - 03 Feb 2006 22:27 GMT
Usually, you can simply use a tap to repair the threads. The tap is tapered,
so it should thread past the screw-up area and become properly aligned so
that the thread cutting portion of the tap can do its thing.

> 2004 E46 330Cic
>
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> Jon
Jack - 04 Feb 2006 02:34 GMT
Front or Rear??
> 2004 E46 330Cic
>
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> Jon
wanka - 04 Feb 2006 21:34 GMT
Thanks very much for the advice given in response to my original post.  
I considered the various suggestions and concluded that the easiest and
cheapest thing to try first was to try to re-tap the damaged threads, so
out I went to get the proper tap (12mm x 1.50)this morning. Cost $5.

Luckily, I was right in my initial impression that very little of the
thread had been damaged once I had done a magnified inspection of the
hole, so I offered-up the tap to the hole and started to turn, applying
firm pressure, and the thread recut easily and quickly.

Lug-bolt reinstalled.

Thanks again for the advice!

Jon
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.