hi guys,
i've owned a '99 323i for roughly 4 months now. i've had no trouble,
really. last week, i got the 'headlamp' warning sign and immediately
after that, i got the 'check engine' sign. i took care of the lamp
(just had to fit it in to the groove properly) and the check engine
sign vanished. now my next problem- it has happened twice so far. i
didn't give it much attention the first time, but today, it scared me.
;-)
last weekend, i started my car and just about a hundred feet from where
i started, i attempted to make a left turn. the car stopped. engine
stopped. no sound. i turned it back on, and it ran smoothly. i thought
it was some silly glitch connected to the lazy front headlight and let
the whole thing drop.
this afternoon, i was taking an exit to join another highway and slowed
down to roughly 30mph and the car simply stopped. the engine stopped. i
was lucky because the road was empty, but i had no idea what was going
on. i took the key out, put it back in and started it again. everything
was fine. for the brief period that the car stopped, a few red warning
signs and yellow warning signs showed up, but i couldn't afford the
time to pay attention to them as i was in a hurry to start the car. i
remember the oil lamp, and battery warning signs definitely came up;
they were red in color. after i started the car, it felt so different.
now, every time i slow down, i think the car has stopped. not just
that, the whole 'feel' of my foot on the gas pedal has changed- it just
doesn't seem like it's got that pickup anymore (no, i'm not just making
it up to elevate the severity of the problem).
i'm terrible at car maintenance in general (don't even know what to
look for- or where to begin, for that matter), i thought i'd post a
message here and see what replies i get. i wanna wait for at least 24
hours before i take it somewhere. and if i were to take it somewhere,
what'd be the best place, er, in my price range? ;-)
right now, there's still the 'check engine' symbol/sign (yellow color).
please give me some input. i wanna know check what you guys have to
say/ask. you can directly email me, too. aagastya@gmail.com. thank you.
-ananth
R. Mark Clayton - 14 Jun 2006 10:54 GMT
snip
> this afternoon, i was taking an exit to join another highway and slowed
> down to roughly 30mph and the car simply stopped. the engine stopped. i
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> remember the oil lamp, and battery warning signs definitely came up;
> they were red in color.
When the engne stops lots of lights come on (same ones that are on before
you start), including oil pressure. It is what was on just before it
stopped that matters.
> after i started the car, it felt so different.
> now, every time i slow down, i think the car has stopped. not just
> that, the whole 'feel' of my foot on the gas pedal has changed- it just
> doesn't seem like it's got that pickup anymore (no, i'm not just making
> it up to elevate the severity of the problem).
Sounds to me like the gearbox has gone into limp home mode, whereby it stays
in third or fourth. It may not be firing on all six as well.
> i'm terrible at car maintenance in general (don't even know what to
> look for- or where to begin, for that matter), i thought i'd post a
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> say/ask. you can directly email me, too. aagastya@gmail.com. thank you.
> -ananth
You need to take it to a repairer who can read the engine diagnostic codes,
as probably the ECU has remembered what went wrong. This means a BMW main
dealer or a specialist repairer with the right equipment. Drive the car as
little as possible in the mean time
aagastya@gmail.com - 14 Jun 2006 11:31 GMT
hi Mark- thanks for responding.
i have an automatic; not a manual. could it still be the same problem?
"limp home mode"?
there were no warning lamps before it happened.
there was another post from about 4 years ago with the same exact
problem; most of the replies said 'oh the same thing happened to me
too', but no one really followed up.
i guess i have to make an appointment today. and yes, i'm about 5 miles
from work, so other than that, i don't plan on using it.
thanks again.
R. Mark Clayton - 14 Jun 2006 15:28 GMT
> hi Mark- thanks for responding.
> i have an automatic; not a manual. could it still be the same problem?
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> from work, so other than that, i don't plan on using it.
> thanks again.
Only automatics do this, a manual goes in the gear you put it in. Limp home
mode is similar to "snow mode" available on 5 speed auto boxes in the 90's
(starts in 3rd to avoid wheelspin), except it stays in 3rd.
The display should say something like "transmission" or on smaller BMW's
there may just be a light (check bulb).
Don't rev the engine too much or you will overheat the torque converter.
aagastya@gmail.com - 15 Jun 2006 00:51 GMT
i wanna follow-up, even if it means i'm replying to my own message.
i made an appointment for monday morning 7am. he said it'd cost 50
bucks to diagnose. but he didn't offer any explanation as to why it
happened (either he didn't know, or as a strategy, they don't talk
about it on the phone).
the car is still under-performing...the pickup has gone down, the rpm
and mpg meters are ridiculous. i actually don't want to wait until
monday, but the next closest bmw shop is about 35 miles away. let's see
what happens.
Jeff Strickland - 15 Jun 2006 01:48 GMT
> hi Mark- thanks for responding.
> i have an automatic; not a manual. could it still be the same problem?
> "limp home mode"?
Yes. The manual hasn't got a limp mode. Actually, I always thought the limp
mode was a function of the motor, but it makes sense that the trans could
limp too.
> there were no warning lamps before it happened.
> there was another post from about 4 years ago with the same exact
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> from work, so other than that, i don't plan on using it.
> thanks again.
aagastya@gmail.com - 21 Jun 2006 13:20 GMT
i promised a follow-up. this might help someone else.
the car stalled, because of an electrical problem. he calls it camshaft
sensor. he had to replace it.
parts: 95
labor: 95
there could also be a mechanical problem and he said that'd cost a lot
more. but that didn't show up.
the check-engine light came up because of one more thing: the
thermostat unit sensor. he replaced the whole thing/unit
parts: 120
labor: 95
i got the full service because we couldn't determine if the full
service had been done at 60K mileage. so i got that.
parts & labor for a full service (which includes a coolant system flush
and brake system flush): 500 approx.
i want to thank everyone who replied (some replied to my personal email
as well).
so, there it is. i hope anyone who reads this realizes that when you
post a problem and ask questions, it'd be nice to post a follow-up
reply that gives the solution as well. no one bloody cares to post
after they have found a solution; it isn't their problem anymore.
that'd help out so many other guys and give a perspective. thanks
anyway. ;-)
Jeff Strickland - 15 Jun 2006 01:45 GMT
> hi guys,
> i've owned a '99 323i for roughly 4 months now. i've had no trouble,
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
> remember the oil lamp, and battery warning signs definitely came up;
> they were red in color.
The lamps that come on during Start-up are normal test lamps for you to look
at and verify that they actually are working. The trouble comes if they
light up after the car has been running, or remain lit after you start it.
If they come on then go out (while starting), there is nothing to worry
about.
after i started the car, it felt so different.
> now, every time i slow down, i think the car has stopped. not just
> that, the whole 'feel' of my foot on the gas pedal has changed- it just
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> say/ask. you can directly email me, too. aagastya@gmail.com. thank you.
> -ananth
The Check light is a key to your troubles. The technician (you can do it
yourself, but you said you lack the skill set) can check the codes that the
computer generates, and take corrective action from there.