Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / Car Audio / January 2005
Newbie Question - why an amp?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
John in NH - 13 Apr 2004 23:06 GMT What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo.
I'm not trolling. :)
Please be gentle, John in NH ~~~
That's nice, but what does this have to do with Rush?
My eBay stuff: http://tinyurl.com/u0fi
Tony Hwang - 14 Apr 2004 00:08 GMT > What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo. > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi Hi, How about looking up the dictioinary for the word amp(lifier) to bigin with? Tony
John in NH - 14 Apr 2004 00:13 GMT >Hi, >How about looking up the dictioinary for the word amp(lifier) >to bigin with? >Tony Priceless.
Anyone with any serious replies - preferably someone who can spell. ~~~
That's nice, but what does this have to do with Rush?
My eBay stuff: http://tinyurl.com/u0fi
MZ - 14 Apr 2004 02:41 GMT Ignore Tony. English is not his first language.
 Signature Mark remove "remove" and "spam" to reply
> >Hi, > >How about looking up the dictioinary for the word amp(lifier) [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi Danny-Boi - 14 Apr 2004 00:21 GMT His response was a good one...I will save you the trouble of having to look it up urself:
am?pli?fy
v. tr. 1. To make larger or more powerful; increase. 2. To add to, as by illustrations; make complete. 3. To exaggerate. 4. To produce amplification of: amplify an electrical signal.
Theres amplify you should be able to figure it out. Danny
> What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo. > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi John in NH - 14 Apr 2004 00:38 GMT >His response was a good one...I will save you the trouble of having to look >it up urself: [quoted text clipped - 22 lines] >> My eBay stuff: >> http://tinyurl.com/u0fi Sigh. . . ~~~
That's nice, but what does this have to do with Rush?
My eBay stuff: http://tinyurl.com/u0fi
John in NH - 14 Apr 2004 00:47 GMT >>His response was a good one...I will save you the trouble of having to look >>it up urself: No, it's a suck answer to a newbie. Does it simply make things louder? Clearer? And if it only makes the signal louder, why would I need an amp when I have a volume knob that does that.
Plus, I asked for someone who could spell.
0 for 2 and I'm outta here. :/
~~~
That's nice, but what does this have to do with Rush?
My eBay stuff: http://tinyurl.com/u0fi
Danny-Boi - 14 Apr 2004 01:02 GMT It's not that I dont kno how to spell I jus shorten words when I am typing on the internet you dumbass.
Here's a site that might answer your audio questions because we obviously arent helping. http://www.bcae1.com/
> >>His response was a good one...I will save you the trouble of having to look > >>it up urself: [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi MZ - 14 Apr 2004 02:45 GMT > It's not that I dont kno how to spell I jus shorten words when I am typing > on the internet you dumbass. Haven't quite mastered the keyboard yet, I see. Are you new to computers?
Danny-Boi - 14 Apr 2004 04:10 GMT You aren't very bright...read what I said, I shorten words when i am typing on the internet because I dont feel like spelling everything out. I work for a computer company so I am sure I kno a helluva lot more about computers than you do.
> > It's not that I dont kno how to spell I jus shorten words when I am typing > > on the internet you dumbass. > > Haven't quite mastered the keyboard yet, I see. Are you new to computers? MZ - 14 Apr 2004 04:13 GMT > You aren't very bright...read what I said, I shorten words when i am typing > on the internet because I dont feel like spelling everything out. It's worth saving a few hundred milliseconds, even at the expense of presenting yourself as an inarticulate boob?
> I work > for a computer company so I am sure I kno a helluva lot more about computers > than you do. Are you the "dude, you're gettin' a Dell" guy?
Danny-Boi - 14 Apr 2004 04:33 GMT Yes it is worth saving that time. Yea I am the "dude, you're getting dell" guy...good one.
> > You aren't very bright...read what I said, I shorten words when i am > typing [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > > Are you the "dude, you're gettin' a Dell" guy? MZ - 14 Apr 2004 04:37 GMT > Yes it is worth saving that time. Yea I am the "dude, you're getting dell" > guy...good one. Just think of all the things you can do now that you've saved 60ms by not having to type the "y" and "o" in front of "ur"! Now you have extra time to, say, argue with someone over the internet about whether or not your job in computers is at Office Max.
> > > You aren't very bright...read what I said, I shorten words when i am > > typing [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > > > > Are you the "dude, you're gettin' a Dell" guy? Danny-Boi - 14 Apr 2004 05:21 GMT I don't see how you are saying where I work at...I could say you work at mcdonalds but i doubt they would hire you. You are more suited to a grammer police or something. I am done arguing with a 10 year old. Latez
> > Yes it is worth saving that time. Yea I am the "dude, you're getting > dell" [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > > > > > > Are you the "dude, you're gettin' a Dell" guy? MZ - 14 Apr 2004 05:22 GMT > You are more suited to a grammer > police or something. I am not!
(PS - it's "grammar")
Danny-Boi - 14 Apr 2004 05:39 GMT Hahahah thats funny that I spelled it wrong. Ending this thread.
> > You are more suited to a grammer > > police or something. > > I am not! > > (PS - it's "grammar") MZ - 14 Apr 2004 06:35 GMT > Hahahah thats funny that I spelled it wrong. Ending this thread. Haven't you said that in your last two posts already?
(guessing this isn't the end of the thread either)
Chad Wahls lt - 14 Apr 2004 14:17 GMT > Yes it is worth saving that time. Yea I am the "dude, you're getting dell" > guy...good one. No he cant be the dell guy, he's the computer support guy on Saturday Night Live!
Damn this is funny, If the hassle of finishing words bugs you, how do you deal with say....... the microwave. One should cook their food all the way.
Chad
rossshan - 05 Jan 2005 05:12 GMT i couldnt help mentioning how fokin stupid the guy who asked the dumdass question and MZ is.2 jac@sses alike
 Signature rossshan CarAudioForum.com - Usenet Gateway w/over one million posts online!
MZ - 05 Jan 2005 20:09 GMT > i couldnt help mentioning how fokin stupid the guy who asked the dumdass > question and MZ is.2 jac@sses alike Learn to quote the text you're replying to, imbecile. Not everyone is using CAF as a portal to rec.audio.car. Some of us actually know how to use a newsreader. So when you say something stupid, it's difficult for me to tear you a new one when it's not even apparent what you're referring to.
(lemme guess...you're a webtv'er too...)
MZ - 05 Jan 2005 20:14 GMT > > i couldnt help mentioning how fokin stupid the guy who asked the dumdass > > question and MZ is.2 jac@sses alike [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > > (lemme guess...you're a webtv'er too...) By the way, every time I click on the link forced upon CAF posters at the bottom of their posts (which supposedly provides the context to which their unquoted replies are addressing), it comes up with "server is busy." What kind of half-assed site is caraudioforum.com running, anyway? Clearly, the site maintainers have the same level of intelligence as the average CAF poster.
Dark1 - 06 Jan 2005 12:10 GMT >> > i couldnt help mentioning how fokin stupid the guy who asked the >> > dumdass [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > site maintainers have the same level of intelligence as the average CAF > poster. it's not about intelligence, it's about money.. buy any web servers lately? hows you bandwidth bill? CAF is certainly not profitable.. and it's owner is to be thanked for providing what he can, not insulted..
MZ - 06 Jan 2005 18:05 GMT > it's not about intelligence, it's about money.. buy any web servers lately? > hows you bandwidth bill? > CAF is certainly not profitable.. and it's owner is to be thanked for > providing what he can, not insulted.. No, he should be insulted for refusing to remove the link to RAC, and what's more, for stealing the RAC FAQ and posting it as his own, even against the wishes of the contributors and maintainer.
rossshan - 07 Jan 2005 02:22 GMT MZ Wrote:
> > > i couldnt help mentioning how fokin stupid the guy who asked th > dumdass [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] > CAF > poster. forgive if i dont know how to whine like a lil biatch,ill just leav that to u science u seem to a pr
-- rosssha CarAudioForum.com - Usenet Gateway w/over one million posts online
MZ - 07 Jan 2005 17:13 GMT > forgive if i dont know how to whine like a lil biatch,ill just leave > that to u science u seem to a pro Ok, now give it a try in english...
Dave - 14 Apr 2004 01:43 GMT Don't you think the question was a little overly "broad", John. There's a bunch of sharp folks in here but you have to give us more to go on. Why are you asking the question?
dave
> >>His response was a good one...I will save you the trouble of having to look > >>it up urself: [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi MZ - 14 Apr 2004 02:44 GMT It's a perfectly reasonable question, and I'm a bit surprised these trolls are hassling you about it.
Essentially, an amplifier increases the amount of power you can deliver to your speakers. As you start to exceed the capabilities of the amplification in a car stereo (which tends to max out at about 15 watts per channel, despite the inflated claims by the manufacturer), distortion skyrockets because your signal is becoming saturated.
At low volume levels, the difference is negligible.
 Signature Mark remove "remove" and "spam" to reply
> >>His response was a good one...I will save you the trouble of having to look > >>it up urself: [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi Scott Johnson - 14 Apr 2004 02:41 GMT 1st, It can make the sound much louder. incase the stock sound isn't loud enough for you or you drive a very noisy vehicle.
2nd, with the added power, the system will have better dynamic range so music that has a loud crash of cymbals will have enough power to reproduce the sound without distorting.
some people only need a little more power than the stock system. maybe they have trouble hearing also and need a little extra to make the music enjoyable to them.
> What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo. > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi Scott Gardner - 14 Apr 2004 06:20 GMT >What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo. > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >My eBay stuff: >http://tinyurl.com/u0fi In addition to the other reasons given, an external amp often becomes necessary when adding more/larger speakers to your system. You could wire a subwoofer into your stock system using a passive crossover, but there's no way the power from the stock head unit will adequately power a large subwoofer.
Also, the passive crossover networks that come with component speakers consume power from the head unit's amp, leaving that much less for the speakers. I'm not talking about the little first-order crossover that separates the mids from the highs on a coaxial speaker, I'm referring more to the larger second- and third-order crossover networks, like the kind you get with MB Quart component sets.
Scott Gardner
Scott Johnson - 14 Apr 2004 22:41 GMT > >What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo. > > [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > there's no way the power from the stock head unit will adequately > power a large subwoofer. that would depend on the car and the listener.
> Also, the passive crossover networks that come with component speakers > consume power from the head unit's amp, leaving that much less for the > speakers. eh? a little.
I'm not talking about the little first-order crossover that
> separates the mids from the highs on a coaxial speaker, I'm referring > more to the larger second- and third-order crossover networks, like > the kind you get with MB Quart component sets. > > Scott Gardner Scott Gardner - 15 Apr 2004 05:24 GMT >> >What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo. >> > [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > >that would depend on the car and the listener. True - everything in this business is subjective, but if you have a stock head unit that only puts out an honest 15W by four channels, I can't see passively connecting a 12- or 15-inch sub along with the rear speakers and being very happy with the results.
>> Also, the passive crossover networks that come with component speakers >> consume power from the head unit's amp, leaving that much less for the >> speakers. > >eh? a little. Only a little, but it's still significant. The term is "insertion loss", and it can consume 10% of the amplifier power (or more), which is significant if we're only talking about a 15 watt-per-channel head unit to begin with. The insertion loss goes up as you add more and more passive components, so a 12db/octave or 18 db/octave passive crossover will consume more power than a 6db/octave crossover. Low-pass filters are the worst offenders, because the inductors used are made up of many turns of wire, and have a measurable DC resistance. This causes them to dissipate power in the form of heat while they're operating. Also, the lower the crossover point, the larger the DC resistance of the inductors will be.
>>I'm not talking about the little first-order crossover that >> separates the mids from the highs on a coaxial speaker, I'm referring >> more to the larger second- and third-order crossover networks, like >> the kind you get with MB Quart component sets. >> >> Scott Gardner Scott Gardner
John in NH - 20 Apr 2004 20:05 GMT MZ and the Scotts,
Thanx for the serious replies. :)
In short, I was getting some clipping when running from just my HU. Research showed that an AMP would help get more juice to the speakers when they needed it, therefore negating the clipping.
Since my initial post, I've installed an AMP and some nice Boston Accoustics and Polks. TREMENDOUS difference!
Take care, John in NH ~~~
If you're not annoyed, you're not paying attention.
My eBay stuff: http://tinyurl.com/u0fi
Peter Klein - 22 Apr 2004 21:30 GMT Adding an amplifier between the head unit and the speakers provides a huge increase in clarity, not louder sound. Louder is controlled by the volume. The output from a cd head unit is usually provided by a couple of integrated circuits. The real thing is usually called "discrete outputs", meaning transistor outputs. Car stereo dealers frown upon "deck power", and knowledgeably suggest an amplifier. Speakers are accoustic motors which run on wattage. If there is enough wattage, everything works fine, but if there is not enough wattage, when the music volume is increased, the sound will distort.. This is the condition preceding "clipping" where there is not enough "fuel" for the speakers, and much of the musical passage is not heard. It is not necessary to have an amplifier with hundreds of watts. Remember, more wattage doesn't mean louder, volume means louder. All aftermarket speakers (coaxial=midrange driver with a tweeter, or 2-way) are stronger built than o.e. ones and are four ohms impedance. All aftermarket head units have four ohm outputs to match the speakers. Very few companies (Bose) provide car builders with four ohm systems so replacing the junk head unit with a today technology CD head unit requires changing the speakers as well for a reliable, good sounding system. P. (car stereo rep for eight years)
> What's the benefit of having an amp hooked up to your car stereo. > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > My eBay stuff: > http://tinyurl.com/u0fi MZ - 23 Apr 2004 00:06 GMT > Adding an amplifier between the head unit and the speakers provides a huge > increase in clarity, not louder sound. Louder is controlled by the volume. I think you got this from Crutchfield.
> The output from a cd head unit is usually provided by a couple of integrated > circuits. The real thing is usually called "discrete outputs", meaning > transistor outputs. Car stereo dealers frown upon "deck power", and > knowledgeably suggest an amplifier. They frown upon deck power because they make more money selling an amp allow with it.
> Speakers are accoustic motors which run > on wattage. If there is enough wattage, everything works fine, but if there > is not enough wattage, when the music volume is increased, the sound will > distort.. This is the condition preceding "clipping" where there is not > enough "fuel" for the speakers, This isn't the condition preceding clipping. It IS clipping. Prior to the onset of clipping, there is virtually no distortion present, regardless of whether it's a McIntosh amp or a Jensen head unit.
> and much of the musical passage is not > heard. It is not necessary to have an amplifier with hundreds of watts. > Remember, more wattage doesn't mean louder, volume means louder. Increased volume can only be obtained by more power. When you turn the volume knob up, you're increasing the input voltage to the amplifier (whether it's in the head unit or an external amplifier), which in turn increases the voltage output of the amplifier (which increases the power delivered to the speakers).
> All > aftermarket speakers (coaxial=midrange driver with a tweeter, or 2-way) are > stronger built than o.e. ones and are four ohms impedance. Not necessarily and not necessarily.
> All aftermarket > head units have four ohm outputs to match the speakers. Very few companies > (Bose) provide car builders with four ohm systems so replacing the junk head > unit with a today technology CD head unit requires changing the speakers as > well for a reliable, good sounding system. P. (car stereo rep for eight > years) Be glad that I was kind. When Les comes across this post...nevermind.
Les - 23 Apr 2004 04:22 GMT "MZ" <zarellam@twcnyremove.rr.comspam> wrote in message
>> today technology CD head unit requires changing the speakers > as > > well for a reliable, good sounding system. P. (car stereo rep for eight > > years)
> Be glad that I was kind. When Les comes across this post...nevermind. Mah, too tired today, 3 17 hour days working on an install and arguing with idiots about clipping and underpowering has taken it out of me. I'm sure our car audio rep for 8 years guy here will give me another chance :)
Les
MZ - 23 Apr 2004 05:23 GMT > Mah, too tired today, 3 17 hour days working on an install and arguing with > idiots about clipping and underpowering has taken it out of me. I'm sure our > car audio rep for 8 years guy here will give me another chance :) You really must be tired. Fresh meat. (unlike spoiled meat, like pug and the captain)
|
|
|