Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / Car Audio / January 2006
Factory audio: 120 watts vs. 160 watts - any real difference?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Desert Trek - 25 Jan 2006 01:57 GMT Hi,
I'm really hung up about sound but don't know a lot about the technicalities.....
I'm looking at purchasing an '06 Honda Accord coupe v6. The auto transmission version of that car has a 120 watt factory unit w/ 6 speakers....
The manual trans version has a 160 watt unit also w/ 6 speakers - although they say "premium audio" for the MT version of the car, whatever "premium" means.
Either way I'm going to put in an aftermarket subwoofer and amp for the sub, mounted in the trunk.
My question is - I am wavering whether to go with the MT or AT version of the car. One of my major deciding factors is the wattage on the factory audio (120 vs. 160).
Is this totally insane or what? I think I'm missing something so feedback would be helpful. I wouldn't mind a stick shift but on the other hand the color I really want is available only in an automatic -- but the automatic version has the lesser power audio unit.
What would you do in similar circumstances? Get the AT version and rip out the factory unit and start over (I don't really want to do that). OR - assuming you like to drive a stick anyway - would you hold out for the better stereo even though you might have to settle for a color you don't like?
thanks for any thoughts!!!!
Dr Nick - 25 Jan 2006 03:05 GMT personally, I can't believe you between and auto and a manual tranny simply because of it's sound system. I'd go with the manual all day (I LOVE manuals, more power, and better mileage, plus MUCH more fun to drive) anyway, I can say from experiance (just bought an 06 accord) I got a 4 cyl. not a 6 cyl, but did get a 5 speed manual, the "120 watt" sound sytem is pretty decent for a factory system. I'm not sure there is much of a difference between teh 2, can you varify? (have you listened to both teh 120 watt and 160 watt system? does one have mroe speakers than the other) one thing on the 120 watt system (the only available for a 4 cyl accord) is the bass is pretty much non existant. I added a 12" subwoofer in the trunk to fix that problem, the system is rpetty damn good for now, I MIGHT add a component set and amp the front later on, but it's good for now. like I said, I think an auto and a manual are night and day differance in a car, I can't imagine chosing one or the other simply because of the audio system. I'd get in both with the same CD and see if you can hear a differance. my 2 cents -Nick
MOSFET - 25 Jan 2006 03:48 GMT > personally, I can't believe you between and auto and a manual tranny > simply because of it's sound system. Sound is VERY important to me. What kind of system I can put in a car (space for subwoofers, amps, etc.) is absolutely the NUMBER ONE decision criteria when purchasing a new car for me. Now, a factory system, that's another matter....
But back to the original question. There's an easy solution here, simply listen to both systems and decide which one sounds best. 120 watts vs. 160 watts is truly not a big difference. I suspect that driver quality and speaker placement will have a bigger impact on the sound quality. Listen to both and decide.
MOSFET
Dr Nick - 25 Jan 2006 05:03 GMT > Sound is VERY important to me. What kind of system I can put in a car > (space for subwoofers, amps, etc.) is absolutely the NUMBER ONE decision > criteria when purchasing a new car for me. Now, a factory system, that's > another matter.... mofset, what I was saying is that a factory system means nothing, I have yet to hear (personally, although I hear the DVD-audio system in the RL is pretty nice) a factory system that is perfect. the one in my accord and the one in my previous nissan maxima were both "decent", just needed some bass so I added a subwoofer.
MOSFET - 25 Jan 2006 05:25 GMT > mofset, what I was saying is that a factory system means nothing, I have > yet to hear (personally, although I hear the DVD-audio system in the RL is > pretty nice) a factory system that is perfect. the one in my accord and > the one in my previous nissan maxima were both "decent", Yes, I totally agree. You're right, I would never make a stock stereo an important buying criteria. I remember I bought a '95 Maxima SE with the Premium Bose system back in '95 (it was new, obviously). At first I was impressed and thought that all I needed was a subwoofer and it would be great. I added a sub, and it was OK, but after time I found it fatiguing on my ears, and it just didn't have the midbass and clarity I was used to (my previous system had used Soundstream amps and Boston Acoustics Pro Series speakers). So I then tried to keep the head unit and replace all the speakers and amps. But that turned out to be impossible as I tried several interface kits but could not get rid of a buzzing sound. Finally, I ended up scrapping even the factory (premium) head and putting in an Alpine.
MOSFET
Austin Becker - 26 Jan 2006 13:26 GMT Had VW installed a sub in the 2000 Jetta's, my sound would have been perfect. It came with the Monsoon sound in it, and although I haven't cared for most of the Monsoon systems I've heard, my components sound outstanding. I am going to be upgrading soon just for the joy of it, but they are awesome.
 Signature - AUSTIN BECKER
> > mofset, what I was saying is that a factory system means nothing, I have > > yet to hear (personally, although I hear the DVD-audio system in the RL is [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > > MOSFET Tony F - 25 Jan 2006 05:34 GMT "What would you do in similar circumstances? Get the AT version and rip out the factory unit and start over (I don't really want to do that). OR - assuming you like to drive a stick anyway - would you hold out for the better stereo even though you might have to settle for a color you don't like?"
In this particular case, get the transmission you want...period. This should be your major decision. Color would be runner up. Auto vs. manual? Hmmm. All depends on the driver and the car. In this case, Honda has consistently been noticed for having some of the smoothest manual shifters in the industry (like in the V6 coupe). So this is a decision YOU the driver has to make. If you like shifting, get a manual. If you simply like pushing down on the gas and steering the car, get an auto. (I think you'll notice only a very small difference in gas mileage between the two)
As far as the stereo goes, I can't see that a much of a difference between a Honda 120-watt 6 speaker system vs. a Honda160-watt 6 speaker "premium" system. But you'll have to hear them to know for sure. Honestly, I'd just concentrate on getting the car you want and leaving the stereo out of the equation altogether. Now, if the stereo differences varied greatly, let's say a 120-watt 6 speaker system vs. a 360-watt 12-speaker system, then maybe it'd be more of deciding factor. But then again, who knows without listening?
Bottom line? If you have to ask, then you probably won't miss anything by choosing the AT with the 120-watt non-premium stereo.
Tony
 Signature 2001 Nissan Maxima SE Anniversary Edition Clarion DRZ9255 Head Unit, Phoenix Gold ZX475ti, ZX450 and Xenon X1200.1 Amplifiers, Dynaudio System 360 Tri-Amped In Front and Focal 130HCs For Rear Fill, Image Dynamics IDMAX10 D4 v.3 Sub
2001 Chevy S10 ZR2 Pioneer DEH-P9600MP Head Unit, Phoenix Gold Ti500.4 Amp, Focal 165HC Speakers & Image Dynamics ID8 D4 v.3 Sub
Desert Trek - 25 Jan 2006 15:16 GMT hey, thanks all for your comments. I agree the trans is the key question here but thought maybe I was missing something. All in all a stupid question.
just fyi - I decided to go with the MT. I do like the add'l flexibility with a stick and want to get the most out of that engine. . . .
thanks again, DT
> Hi, > [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > thanks for any thoughts!!!! MOSFET - 25 Jan 2006 17:51 GMT . All in all a stupid
> question. Don't worry, that was not a stupid question. We all asked some pretty basic questions when starting out (no one was born knowing everything about car audio).
The only stupid question is the one not asked.
MOSFET
Desert Trek - 26 Jan 2006 15:57 GMT thanks! I pick the car up Saturday - Accord v6 Coupe, manual trans - can't wait! First thing Monday it's going in the shop for a subwoofer and amp
>. All in all a stupid >> question. [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > > MOSFET
|
|
|