Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / Driving / May 2005
Crazy idea?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
223rem - 28 May 2005 21:48 GMT I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least give them something entertaining and instructive to do. I want them to be more like my girlfriends' cat, that cool cat who killed those bunnies and birds.
I am considering the idea of buying several small rodents from the pet store and releasing them in the house. I'm very curious to see how the kittens will react. Will they give chase? I sure hope so.
Anway, am I crazy? Cruel? More importantly, will the kitties benefit from this 'war game'? What kind of rodent should I buy?
Thanks :)
Furious George - 28 May 2005 22:29 GMT > I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least > give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > Anway, am I crazy? Cruel? More importantly, will the > kitties benefit from this 'war game'? What kind of rodent should I buy? Most people don't have to buy rodents. Lower the housekeeping bar just a little bit and you'll get them for free. But if you have to buy them, make sure you get at least one boy and one girl. That way you're cats get more practice.
> Thanks :) Dave - 29 May 2005 00:03 GMT > I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least > give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > > Thanks :) You can't teach them to hunt, but your girlfriend's cat could. That is, IF your girlfriend's cat is a real hunter. Cats learn to hunt from other cats, usually "mother", if the mother is a good hunter. But for this to work you'd have to adopt your girlfriend's cat for a few weeks (or she could adopt your kittens for a few weeks). After the kittens have grown attached to the older cat, then they might learn to hunt. I don't know what they'd learn from releasing rodents in the house though. To get a real education, all three cats would have to spend time together outside. When the kittens start bringing home dead animals for you, you'll know that the older cat did a good job of teaching them. -Dave
Paul - 29 May 2005 05:28 GMT On Sat, 28 May 2005 20:48:15 GMT, 223rem , said the following in rec.autos.driving...
> Anway, am I crazy? Dunno, I don't know you that well... ;-)
> Cruel? Not IMO.
> What kind of rodent should I buy? Some pet stores sell small rodents (mice primairly) for people who own snakes and certain other animals that like such things. If they ask any questions, simply tell them you have a pet Boa that is hungry....
> Thanks :) Scott en Aztlán - 29 May 2005 17:45 GMT >I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least >give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] >to see how the kittens will react. Will they give chase? I >sure hope so. Of course they will. But unless mommy taught the what to do once they catch the prey, they will just let it go. Then catch it again. Then let it go. Ad Nauseum.
If you want cats with the killer instinct, you probably need to adopt some kittens who were born in a barn.
 Signature Life is short - drive fast! http://www.geocities.com/scottenaztlan/
L Sternn - 29 May 2005 22:50 GMT >>I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least >>give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] >If you want cats with the killer instinct, you probably need to adopt >some kittens who were born in a barn. Nah - I think you just need hungry cats.
My cat had been shot and was surviving on water accumulated from sprinklers when I found her, and even though she doesn't need to, she can take care of herself and kill whatever prey presents itself handily.
The reason domesticated cats aren't good hunters is because they don't need to be, not because their mama never taught them.
Scott en Aztlán - 30 May 2005 01:36 GMT >>>I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least >>>give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > >Nah - I think you just need hungry cats. My cat hunts bugs. She catches them, she plays with them, but she never kills them nor eats them. I always attributed it to lack of training. :)
 Signature Life is short - drive fast! http://www.geocities.com/scottenaztlan/
L Sternn - 30 May 2005 03:32 GMT >>>>I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least >>>>give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] >never kills them nor eats them. I always attributed it to lack of >training. :) Well, mine never got much training, except possibly some in avoiding pellet guns as she had been shot by one when I found her, but she still manages to kill bugs. She'd probably kill birds too, except they're not allowed indoors and she's not allowed out.
Joe Canuck - 30 May 2005 12:26 GMT >>>>I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least >>>>give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > never kills them nor eats them. I always attributed it to lack of > training. :) Oh boy, Scottie is in the cats newsgroup stirrin' the pot.
A while back he was in rec.bicycles.misc stirrin' the pot, even had photographic "evidence" to support his "case".
Scottie = newsgroup troll
Scott en Aztlán - 30 May 2005 17:09 GMT >>>>>I'd like to teach my two rather wimpy kittens to hunt, or at least >>>>>give them something entertaining and instructive to do. [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] > >Oh boy, Scottie is in the cats newsgroup stirrin' the pot. I challenge you to point to ONE off-topic post I have made to any cat newsgroup. Someone asked a question about feline behavior, and I redirected it to a place where many experts hang out. That's hardly the inflammatory behavior you allege. In fact, the only one stirring any pots is you.
>Scottie = newsgroup troll Pot. Kettle. *PLONK!*
 Signature Life is short - drive fast! http://www.geocities.com/scottenaztlan/
friesian@zoocrewphoto.com - 31 May 2005 02:14 GMT > The reason domesticated cats aren't good hunters is because they don't > need to be, not because their mama never taught them. Actually, most cats have to be shown how to kill. Some do learn by accident. Most cats will play with rodents, but most do not actually kill them.
And it isn't about whether they need to or not. Chase was adopted as a kitten, but was outside before we got him. Both parents were barn cats. He has been indoor only since then. But he knows where to go up into the ceiling to find a nest of rats. And several times a year, he brings out the babies, one a night. He does like to play with them, so sometimes they are still alive, but he does kill them if given enough time. And he will eat them. One time, I found just the head. My other cats will play with one and show interest, but they don't hunt as seriously, nor do they actually know what to do with one if they get it.
We have had many cats over the years and two have chosen to hunt, kill, and sometimes eat their prey. And these are indoor only cats. They certainly had no need to hunt, and haven't since they were kittens. They simply had more drive to do so.
Just as some breeds of dogs are known for high prey drive while others are not. My neighbor used to have a husky, and while that dog was well fed and had no need to hunt, he would go after anything that moved. She made a point of checking her yard for cats and squirrels before letting her dog out in her own yard. And once while on a leash, the dog saw a cat before she did. She was injured in her struggle to get her dog off that cat. She loved her dog, but she said she would never get another one. It was too much stress worrying about the other animals.
I would think that barn cats would naturally be better hunters simply because the instinct has to be strong to survive, so they pass it along. But even so, they would need to be shown. Maynard was half barncat, and he never killed anything. Chase them, yes. It was kinda funny last year when Chase brought in a live one and released it on my bed. Normally, I would not think that funny at all. but Maynard (at age 18) jumped up in excitement and almost got it. You could see the look on his face (ooh! live toy). He was like a kitten again.
All that said, I don't know why anybody would want to teach their cat to hunt if it is an indoor cat. I certainly wouldn't buy rodents just to use them as bait. That seems cruel.
Philip - 31 May 2005 02:39 GMT snip
> All that said, I don't know why anybody would want to teach their cat > to hunt if it is an indoor cat. I certainly wouldn't buy rodents just > to use them as bait. That seems cruel. If I lived in a rat infested tenement, owning a hunt-to-kill housecat would be high on my list!
bigbadbarry - 31 May 2005 03:05 GMT "Philip" > If I lived in a rat infested tenement, owning a hunt-to-kill housecat would
> be high on my list! Thaaat's right, take no prisoners.
-- Barry
... Women and cats are both black at night. - Bosnia ...
L Sternn - 31 May 2005 03:40 GMT >snip >> All that said, I don't know why anybody would want to teach their cat [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] >If I lived in a rat infested tenement, owning a hunt-to-kill housecat would >be high on my list! Rat poison and traps would be higher on mine
Philip - 31 May 2005 06:02 GMT >> snip >>> All that said, I don't know why anybody would want to teach their [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > Rat poison and traps would be higher on mine Rat poison / traps don't purr. A house mousing cat is MUCH more fun to photograph too!
Scott en Aztlán - 31 May 2005 15:19 GMT >>snip >>> All that said, I don't know why anybody would want to teach their cat [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > >Rat poison and traps would be higher on mine I had a bad experience with rat poison once. My dog managed to drag one out from behind the stove and gobbled it right up. YUM!!
Fortunately we realized what happened in time and got her to the 24/7 vet med clinic at the University. She threw it all up and got through the experience with no apparent ill effects.
Now, you might say this was all my fault, since I did place the poison in a place where the dog could get at it. You do have a point, but we put it into a place where we thought it was out of her reach; we were surprised by her resourcefulness. :-/
 Signature Life is short - drive fast! http://www.geocities.com/scottenaztlan/
|
|
|