Up until a week ago, I had never had a torque convertor go bad.
This relates to one of several Geo Metro ATs I have.
No advance warning of a problem. Drove at highway and traffic speeds for 60
miles or so and pulled into a parking space. Returned an hour later, tried
to back out and had significant slippage. Same in all forward ranges.
Checked fluid levels and they were normal. I could feel it shift into each
gear but not enough power to get up to highway speed.
Went home and got my dolley and towed it home.
Figured I might have a blocked filter screen, so I drained the fluid and
dropped the pan and screen. Not trash on the magnet or in the screen.
Cleaned everthing and closed it up/refilled. Still the same slippage.
Pulled the engine and tranny out and inspected the torgue converter before
swapping ATs with a spare I had. When I shook or "swished" the convertor
around to get the impellor to move, I could hear a noisy bearing sound. Did
the same with the replacement convertor, nothing like the old one. The sound
was like loose bearings in a race. This was, of course, with the tranny
fluid still in both convertors.
Replacement/rebuilt convertors are to expensive to replace, just on
principal on these cheap little cars. However, used convertors and readily
available.
How can you tell if a convertor is really bad before putting it in?? No way
to take it apart. Can I put a shaft into the hub and spin it up to see if
there is bearing noise, etc. ??
If they are selling rebuilt convertors, they must cut them open to replace
the bearings. To be honest, I've never seen the inside of a torque convertor
and all the home shop manuals fail to show a cutaway of them.
Just curious.
Steve
Steve - 10 Oct 2006 20:05 GMT
> Up until a week ago, I had never had a torque convertor go bad.
>
[quoted text clipped - 34 lines]
>
> Steve
Its rarely bearings that fail in a TC, its usually the "sprag" or
overrunning clutch on the stator or the lockup clutch. There are
actually two shafts (at least) that poke into the TC from the
transmission side and engage it- the ouput or turbine shaft (which as
its name implies is driven by the turbine section inside the convertor,
which in turn is driven by fluid impelled by the impeller side of the
convertor). The other shaft is the reaction shaft, and in most auto
trans designs its actually rigidly mounted to the case and doesn't
rotate. What it does is provide a fixed reference for the stator to act
against through its overrunning clutch. Under certain conditions, the
stator is held locked rigidly aginst the reaction shaft, and in other
conditions it rotates freely (the other direction from the direction it
tries to spin when its being locked). The stator being still or rotating
changes the torque multiplication factor of the convertor. A broken
overrunning clutch on the stator that allows the stator to spin backward
will cause an incredibly "loose" convertor that barely will get the car
moving, but once up to highway speed it will be fairly normal.
Conversely, a seized stator clutch will be fairly normal at "breakaway"
from a stop, but will cause the engine to feel like its dragging at
higher speeds.
Convertors are indeed rebuilt by cutting them open around the
circumfereence where the original assembly weld bead is. As far as I
know, it is ALWAYS standard practice to replace the convertor when
rebuilding a transmission, unless the transmission has some other
identifiable failure at very low mileage such as a broken band or burned
clutch. The torque convertor on most modern (post-1975) cars has a
lockup clutch which wears about the same rate as the rest of the
transmission clutches and bands, so it should always be replaced as part
of a rebuild. Its false economy to rebuild a transmission and not
replace the TC.
The only way to FULLY diagnose a convertor is to run it in the car or
open it in a shop capable of rebuilding it (with all the equipment that
entails). You can kinda tell if the OR clutch is working by engaging the
splines that the reaction shaft would engage and seeing if it will only
turn one direction, but a person can't apply the same amount of torque
as an engine so its not a very good test. You can't really test the
lockup clutch on the bench, either, as the convertor has to be
pressurized and de-pressurized to switch the clutch on or off.