I've just rebuilt my suv engine, replaced rings, polished all pistons, machined heads
and polished all ports. all new hoses, radiator, all sensors. engine runs really good
and quiet.
put initially castrol 20w-50 and have read I should replace at 50 miles, then 500 and
then every 3000 miles
many older mechanics tell me to keep engine with castrol 20w-50 or similar and *not*
to go synthetic but won't tell me any real reason as to why
any comments?
N8N - 29 Nov 2006 19:04 GMT
> I've just rebuilt my suv engine, replaced rings, polished all pistons, machined heads
> and polished all ports. all new hoses, radiator, all sensors. engine runs really good
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> any comments?
yes...
1) is 20W50 the mfgrs. recommended oil for this engine? If not, did
you build the engine with looser clearances that would indicate going
to a heavier oil? If not, i'd stick with the mfgrs. recommended
weight, (although if that is a 5W20 I would seriously consider using a
5W or 10W30 - 20 weight oil just seems to thin for good protection to
me. I know, I don't really have anything to back that up, but a 30
weight is as thick as most newer engines are designed for, with a few
exceptions.)
2) No reason not to go to synthetic, but I'd wait until the engine has
some miles on it. How many really depends on how long it takes for it
to feel broken in. If it uses oil at first and at some point stops
using any oil at all, after that point I'd feel safe switching to a
synthetic.
good luck,
nate
Steve - 29 Nov 2006 20:25 GMT
> I've just rebuilt my suv engine, replaced rings, polished all pistons,
> machined heads and polished all ports. all new hoses, radiator, all
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> any comments?
Somewhere in the dark ages past, word got around that if you used
synthetic oil from the start it would be SOOOO slippery that the rings
would never properly seat and you'd have a chronic oil burner.
It might or might not have been true, to some degree. But the Corvette,
Viper, and a number of other cars come from the factory with Mobil 1. I
switched my freshly built Mopar 440 to Mobil 1 at 1000 miles. I did the
initial fire-up on Castrol 10w30 (20w50 is for worn-out engines, not new
ones- WAY too thick!). Did the cam break-in run for 20 minutes, changed
the oil and filter to get all the break-in lubes and any leftover grits
out. Then ran for 100 miles on 10w30, changed oil and filter again. Then
at 1k miles, I switched it to Mobil 1 10w30. So far its got about 15,000
miles on it, oil consumption has dropped to nil (or as close to nil as
you can get with a big-bore v8), and its running fine.
N8N - 29 Nov 2006 20:56 GMT
> > I've just rebuilt my suv engine, replaced rings, polished all pistons,
> > machined heads and polished all ports. all new hoses, radiator, all
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> synthetic oil from the start it would be SOOOO slippery that the rings
> would never properly seat and you'd have a chronic oil burner.
I'd still tend to err on the side of caution with a home-rebuilt
engine, which is what I assume we're talking about here.
nate
AZ Nomad - 29 Nov 2006 21:42 GMT
>I've just rebuilt my suv engine, replaced rings, polished all pistons, machined heads
>and polished all ports. all new hoses, radiator, all sensors. engine runs really good
>and quiet.
>put initially castrol 20w-50 and have read I should replace at 50 miles, then 500 and
>then every 3000 miles
>many older mechanics tell me to keep engine with castrol 20w-50 or similar and *not*
>to go synthetic but won't tell me any real reason as to why
>any comments?
There's no good reason. Until conventional oil breaks down, its properties
are the same as synth. The only reason for using dino oil is the cost
of filling and tossing synth. Use cheap dino for 50, 500, and 3000, and then
switch to synth every 10-20K.