Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
HomeAnnouncements
Discussion Groups
By Brand
BMWChevroletDodgeFordGMHondaLexusMercedes-BenzNissanPeugeotToyotaVolkswagenOther Brands
By Topic
4x4 CarsRVsDrivingMaintenance & RepairCar AudioCollectible Cars
Country Specific
Australian ForumsUK Forums
ArticlesAuto InsuranceBuyingCars & TechnologyMaintenanceMiscellaneousSafety
DMV Resources
Related Topics
MotorcyclesBoatsMore Topics ...

Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / Maintenance and Repair / February 2007

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

question for plumbing gurus

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Nate Nagel - 22 Feb 2007 01:18 GMT
What is the max. pressure that is advisable to run through a hose that
is clamped to a steel line with an Oetiker clamp?  Assume that the steel
line is appx. 3/8" in diameter and I'm using good, high-temp, high
pressure rubber hose.

There's a reason I'm asking; however, I'd rather get an answer before
explaining myself to avoid prejudicing responses.

thanks,

nate

Signature

replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel

Scott Buchanan - 22 Feb 2007 05:18 GMT
Does the steel have barbs or a bulge at the end? Is it the type of Oetiker
that wraps around 360 degrees or the type with two ears?

> What is the max. pressure that is advisable to run through a hose that
> is clamped to a steel line with an Oetiker clamp?  Assume that the steel
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
> http://members.cox.net/njnagel
« Paul » - 22 Feb 2007 05:24 GMT
> What is the max. pressure that is advisable to run through a hose that
> is clamped to a steel line with an Oetiker clamp?  Assume that the steel
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> nate

There are so many variables Nate that a good answer is difficult.

Is the steel line ribbed, bulged, or flared or have any other way
keeping the hose in place?
What is the fluid?  WAter, air, oil, etc.
Temperature changes?  Expansion, contraction
Reinforced hose?  Nylon, steel, etc.
Vibration?
How many layers? Radial, bias, etc.
What is the hose really made of?  Buna S, etc.
How much hose is jammed onto the pipe?  Several inches?
Are the Oetiker clamps the kind that are ear crimped or the other kind?

I would figure it would hold a few psi long term on a smooth pipe if
there is no vibration, nasty fluid, etc.
If the pipe is flared or barbed, then it should hold at least the
recommend max working pressure of the hose.  Good quality air hose is
good for around 150 psi max working pressure.  Same for SOME very good
fuel hose.
N8N - 22 Feb 2007 15:29 GMT
> > What is the max. pressure that is advisable to run through a hose that
> > is clamped to a steel line with an Oetiker clamp?  Assume that the steel
[quoted text clipped - 27 lines]
> good for around 150 psi max working pressure.  Same for SOME very good
> fuel hose.

OK, well I guess I will have to post specifics then.

I own an '88 Porsche 944.  It's nothing special, it's just my car.
Right now it's basically my girlfriend's occasional driver, as I have
a company provided vehicle.  I just took it to a very well recommended
race shop for some repair work, simply because it is difficult to find
a good mechanic that can work on a Porsche, I'm not sure why this is
but it is.  Anyway, he has done a preliminary once-over of the car and
one of his "punch list" items was to replace a section of rubber
hose.  This is a line from the fuel tank to the fuel pressure damper
on the engine, unfortunately from the factory it is one solid piece
from the rear of the car all the way to the front.  The hose section
is swaged onto the steel line.  The hose began leaking shortly after I
purchased the car, this was actually discovered by a different
mechanic who I took the car to for a timing belt replacement.  That
mechanic cut the swaged collars off and replaced the rubber with a
piece of standard high pressure fuel injection hose, double clamped at
each end.  He basically said that this was not a good fix, that I
should keep an eye on it, etc. and I have - this was three years ago
and it is still working fine, although at some point I was going to
replace it because he used worm clamps and I would prefer to have
smooth fuel injection type clamps on there.

This new mechanic is basically telling me that in his opinion any
repair of that fuel line is substandard work and he recommends
replacement of the entire part.  "fortunately" in his words Porsche
has superceded the old one piece line with a multi-piece line, but
"proper" replacement involves ordering all the new factory Porsche
parts and replacing everything from the tank forward, which would
necessitate dropping part of the rear suspension.  This would be
several hundred dollars worth of parts and close to $1K in labor (at
his shop.)

I don't mind spending money to make a car safe, but when we're talking
about a significant percentage of the car's value, I am tempted to
look for more economical alternatives.  I've found this kit after a
web search:

http://www.lindseyracing.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=CTGY&Store_Code=LR&Ca
tegory_Code=944FUELLLINES


also this one

http://www.rennbay.com/hitemp-blue-racing-fuel-lines-base-kit-p-61.html?osCsid=e
5059a300ab3c353b5bfedc3537fdee2


I've been sent some better pics of the Rennbay kit and it appears to
be 3/8" diameter Aeroquip hose.

The only issue I have with both of these kits is their method of
connecting to the hard steel line.  The Rennbay kit uses a standard
high pressure FI screw-and-nut hose clamp, and i'm curious if it
provides enough compression to really crank down on the Aeroquip
hose.  The Lindsey kit uses a compression fitting to attach to the
steel line, which I also don't like.  I had two thoughts:

1) buy the Rennbay kit and use an Oetiker clamp (or two?) instead of
the screw and nut clamp.

2) buy the Lindsey kit and instead of using the compression fitting,
actually cut back the steel line and flare the tubing for an AN tube
nut and use an AN fitting from the hard steel line to the hose.

The steel tubing, after cutting off the factory swaged crimp collar
and removing the factory hose, does have a pronounced barb formed in
it to retain the hose.

Again, I'm not trying to be cheap, but at an estimated cost of $1200 I
figure if I can fix it correctly with one of the methods above, even
if I have to buy some AN plumbing tools, I'll come out ahead by
investigating alternatives. (and then I'd have AN plumbing tools.)

Unfortunately, a leak at the connection where the hose connects to the
hard line would be a serious issue, as that would basically mean that
high pressure fuel would be spraying directly on the exhaust header
(yes, they are tubular stainless not cast iron - so they are probably
even hotter than normal exhaust manifolds.)  So much for that vaunted
Kraut engineering... I guess they didn't learn anything from the
shitty fuel line design of the 914.  So you can see if I am going to
do something non-factory, I want to make absolutely certain that I am
doing the right thing.

I believe the mechanic has a valid point that the current setup is
less than desirable; however, economically it probably makes financial
sense to just drive the car until it burns to the ground rather than
pay him $1200 to fix it...

nate
Brent P - 22 Feb 2007 15:59 GMT

> http://www.lindseyracing.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=CTGY&Store_Code=LR&Ca
tegory_Code=944FUELLLINES

>
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> actually cut back the steel line and flare the tubing for an AN tube
> nut and use an AN fitting from the hard steel line to the hose.

Now this may seem like a silly idea... Could the steel line be double
flared on car like a brake line after a brake line fitting is slid on to
it and then an adapter used to go from the brake line fitting to whatever
you need for a proper fuel injection hose? (provided such an adapter
exists or you could have one machined)
N8N - 22 Feb 2007 16:35 GMT
On Feb 22, 10:59 am, tetraethylleadREMOVET...@yahoo.com (Brent P)
wrote:
> In article <1172158199.904745.215...@j27g2000cwj.googlegroups.com>, N8N wrote:
> >http://www.lindseyracing.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=CTGY&Store...
[quoted text clipped - 27 lines]
>
> - Show quoted text -

That's exactly what I was thinking, except rather than using a 45
degree double flare I was thinking of using a 37 degree AN flare
(because the Lindsey kit uses AN hose and fittings are readily
available.)  However I have my suspicions that a good hose with an
Oetiker clamp would be perfectly acceptable and less work.

nate
Brent P - 22 Feb 2007 17:14 GMT
>> > 2) buy the Lindsey kit and instead of using the compression fitting,
>> > actually cut back the steel line and flare the tubing for an AN tube
>> > nut and use an AN fitting from the hard steel line to the hose.

>> Now this may seem like a silly idea... Could the steel line be double
>> flared on car like a brake line after a brake line fitting is slid on to
>> it and then an adapter used to go from the brake line fitting to whatever
>> you need for a proper fuel injection hose? (provided such an adapter
>> exists or you could have one machined)- Hide quoted text -

> That's exactly what I was thinking, except rather than using a 45
> degree double flare I was thinking of using a 37 degree AN flare
> (because the Lindsey kit uses AN hose and fittings are readily
> available.)  However I have my suspicions that a good hose with an
> Oetiker clamp would be perfectly acceptable and less work.

For whatever reason it didn't register that what you were thinking was
that close except for the special flare tool. If adapters exist you could
avoid the extra tool though.

Just googling around, it seems oetiker clamps are acceptable for fuel
injection system fuel line.

http://www.eggenfellneraircraft.com/FluidSystems.htm
Scott Buchanan - 22 Feb 2007 17:43 GMT
I'd trust that for carburetor pressure but not for fuel injection pressure.
For that I'd recommend using a Ferrell and compression nut fitting to attach
to the steel, then attach a barbed fitting to that for the rubber. Use the
type of Oetiker that wraps around 360 degrees. I've had too many leaks with
the other type that have the two ears. These fittings will add weight so
make sure that it is properly supported.

> On Feb 22, 10:59 am, tetraethylleadREMOVET...@yahoo.com (Brent P)
> wrote:
[quoted text clipped - 38 lines]
>
> nate
spamTHISbrp@yahoo.com - 22 Feb 2007 17:51 GMT
> On Feb 22, 10:59 am, tetraethylleadREMOVET...@yahoo.com (Brent P)
> wrote:
[quoted text clipped - 38 lines]
>
> nate

Just doing the 1st step of a brake-line style double-flare yields
quite a good 'barb' at the end of a steel line.

Running steel line with maybe  just short sections of FI rated hose
would be the best cheap fix.

The hot-rodders use braided-stainless covered FI hose, as well.

Dave
Nate Nagel - 22 Feb 2007 21:23 GMT
>>On Feb 22, 10:59 am, tetraethylleadREMOVET...@yahoo.com (Brent P)
>>wrote:
[quoted text clipped - 42 lines]
> Just doing the 1st step of a brake-line style double-flare yields
> quite a good 'barb' at the end of a steel line.

Right, that's about what's there now.

nate

> Running steel line with maybe  just short sections of FI rated hose
> would be the best cheap fix.
>
> The hot-rodders use braided-stainless covered FI hose, as well.
>
> Dave

Signature

replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel

« Paul » - 24 Feb 2007 00:43 GMT
> > > What is the max. pressure that is advisable to run through a hose that
> > > is clamped to a steel line with an Oetiker clamp?  Assume that the steel
[quoted text clipped - 114 lines]
>
> nate

I like your idea #2.  Flare the line _if possible_.
Put the nut on first!
There could be problem though - steel tends to get brittle in the
presence of hydrogen.  You may be able to flare the pipe considering
its age.  Still, it is worth a try.
If that does not work, then you clamp a hose onto the steel pipe -
assuming there is some sort of bulge to keep the hose on.
You may want to reconsider the type of clamp because they are designed
to expand somewhat.  Hopefully they will not expand enough to slide over
the pipe bulge.
Nate Nagel - 24 Feb 2007 02:24 GMT
>>>>What is the max. pressure that is advisable to run through a hose that
>>>>is clamped to a steel line with an Oetiker clamp?  Assume that the steel
[quoted text clipped - 125 lines]
> to expand somewhat.  Hopefully they will not expand enough to slide over
> the pipe bulge.

I can make a bulge with a double flare tool if it comes to that...

'nother problem with the flare idea.  I was given a pointer to this:

http://www.pauertuning.com/fuel%20lines.htm

which appears to be similar to the Lindsey kit but I've been told that
this guy actually originated the kit.  I've exchanged a few emails with
him already and he seems like a good guy to deal with.  He's telling me
that the hard lines are 10mm feed and 8mm return; therefore it's iffy if
an AN flaring tool's anvil would grip it properly.  (I should have
anticipated that they would be metric; I'm so used to working on
Studebakers that I forgot that Porsches use these weird sizes for
things.)  I do however have a metric bubble flare tool and have found
adapters for bubble flare to AN-6 in the Aircraft Spruce catalog.  I
have not, however, seen any female thread tube nuts for metric fittings,
which is kind of key to this whole plan...  Vic at Pauer seems to think
that the compression fittings are fine, and certainly in theory they
ought to work... maybe I should just use them, but put some red Loctite
on the threads just for insurance that they won't vibrate loose?

The good news is, however, I've found an Aeroquip distributor that is -
sh.t you not - less than three miles from my house.  This makes me very,
very happy and yet worries me because this could easily become an
obsession (well, since I have to make a new fuel line for the
Studebaker, I might as well make that all AN as well, y'see, and some
braided stainless brake hoses might be nice...)  I will definitely be
checking this place out tomorrow morning.

nate

Signature

replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel

Brent P - 24 Feb 2007 02:50 GMT
> 'nother problem with the flare idea.  I was given a pointer to this:
>
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
> braided stainless brake hoses might be nice...)  I will definitely be
> checking this place out tomorrow morning.

On the torqueless wonder car I had a rust pinhole leak in a 10mm steel
section of power steering line. It was a line that would be a pain to
replace and the leak was near an end and accessible for the most part. I
adapted 3/8th in metric brake line to the task. Of course the 10mm stock
fitting slid over the brake line replacement bit just fine. Took the
3/8ths fitting to work and the hole was inlarged to 10mm on the lathe.
Slid that over the 10mm line flared it with the brake flaring tool for
3/8ths. Used a union to connect it to the brake line. Worked perfectly.
Anyway.. to the point the flare on the 10mm steel line turned out fine
with some minor defect but that was due limited space I had to work in. I
couldn't square the flaring tool exactly perfect because of it. But it did
grip the 10mm line fine as I recall.

3/8ths is less than a half mm smaller than 10mm, I would think that the
clamping range for the OD on a flaring tool should have at least that much
adjustibility. It also makes for little float for the part that goes
inside the tube, but it may only take a bit of tape around it to make up
the .5mm. Even as is, the worst is probably a couple attempts to make a
good flare.
« Paul » - 24 Feb 2007 17:18 GMT
> I can make a bulge with a double flare tool if it comes to that...
>
[quoted text clipped - 26 lines]
>
> nate

We use aircraft stainless hoses on our hydraulic and diesel equipment.
Great stuff.
Nate Nagel - 24 Feb 2007 19:32 GMT
>>>>> What is the max. pressure that is advisable to run through a hose that
>>>>> is clamped to a steel line with an Oetiker clamp?  Assume that the
[quoted text clipped - 157 lines]
>
> nate

Update:  I checked out the store I mentioned in my post above this AM.
It looked promising from the street, but when I walked in I found that
the only person manning the store was an attractive female about ten
years younger than I.  I have to admit that that didn't give me a whole
lot of hope.  Well, I just asked where the AN adapter fittings were, and
she handed me an Aeroquip catalog and pointed me toward all the fittings
which were neatly arranged in plastic bins by part number.  After about
ten minutes of poking around I couldn't find anything that looked like
it would work, so I came back to the counter and explained to her
exactly what I was trying to do.  Not only did she catch right on to the
whole concept, but she apologized that they probably *didn't* stock a
metric fitting that would work for me, CALLED THE OWNER OF THE STORE,
who immediately called back and spoke to me about what I was doing,
apologized that he was OUT OF TOWN and promised to start looking for
what I needed on Monday and would call me as soon as he'd found something.

Dayam.  I didn't know places like that still existed.  I feel like I owe
the girl an apology for my initial impression, even though I certainly
didn't let on.

The store is Hi-Performance Hardware, on Washington Blvd. in Arlington,
VA.  Good peoples.

nate

Signature

replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel

 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.