
Signature
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
Can these starter motors run for long periods of time at low power
inputs?
I'm just considering these motors for use in a small electric vehicle.
With a motor speed controller, these starter motors won't be running
at its maximum capacity.
> In article <2f21d255-258c-4666-a971-8cea382dc...@d27g2000prf.googlegroups.com>,
>
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> --
> "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
Scott Dorsey - 05 Dec 2007 13:31 GMT
>Can these starter motors run for long periods of time at low power
>inputs?
Maybe, but I wouldn't. They don't have bearings designed for continuous
duty. If you are careful and watch the winding temperature you might be
able to get away with it, though.
>I'm just considering these motors for use in a small electric vehicle.
>
>With a motor speed controller, these starter motors won't be running
>at its maximum capacity.
Remember these are the cheapest, crappiest motor designs possible. Because
the car manufacturers can get away with that. I wouldn't use them for
anything I cared about, even if it were intermittent duty.
--scott

Signature
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
Steve B. - 05 Dec 2007 15:14 GMT
>Can these starter motors run for long periods of time at low power
>inputs?
>I'm just considering these motors for use in a small electric vehicle.
>
>With a motor speed controller, these starter motors won't be running
>at its maximum capacity.
Starter motors typically have no or very poor cooling. They are
designed to only run for a few seconds at a time so cooling isn't an
issue for them in normal service.
Starter motors also aren't designed to spin for all that long (short
service life). The bearings are cheesy at best.
If this is just a fun type project they might work good enough to play
with. If that were the case I would pick something popular like a
Chevy 350 starter so that you could just go grab new ones at the
junkyard when they cook themselves.
Steve B.
Steve - 07 Dec 2007 15:20 GMT
> Can these starter motors run for long periods of time at low power
> inputs?
No. They have very limited heat dissipation capacity- no airflow through
the case, no cooling fan, no external finning. They're meant for
intermittent use only.
> I'm just considering these motors for use in a small electric vehicle.
Not a good idea.
> With a motor speed controller, these starter motors won't be running
> at its maximum capacity.
But they would still be incapable of dissipating much heat. You need a
motor with cooling capability- starter motors are made to be sealed
against dirt, grit, and wet and since they're expected to operate for a
maximum of 15 seconds at a time, cooling is sacrificed for compactness
and being sealed.