> You should check the inner and outer tie rods for looseness, bounce the van
> to see if the struts/shocks are weak,
Ayep...
> struts are not a dyer job, caution and
> and a strut /spring tool are required.
Nonsense.
True, a set of coil-spring compressers is needed (Cheap and easy to get
- Last set I bought was under $20, and the local autozone has 'em on
hand as part of their "loan-a-tool" thing.)
Also true that it does take some reasonable care. ("Don't undo the nut
holding the upper spring plate to the strut until the spring compressers
are solidly engaged and the spring is compressed" is the biggest item)
Not true that it isn't a DIYer job - struts are no biggie for anyone who
has the smarts to be able to change a set of spark plugs. Typically
either three or four bolts on top, and two on the bottom are what's
holding it in place, and removing/replacing the old cartridge usually
means unscrewing a collar after the spring and upper plate are off the
strut. Not at all complex, and difficult, at best, to screw up without
it being too obvious to overlook.
The one critical item other than not letting the top strut-spring plate
loose before the spring is unloaded is to check and see if your
particular vehicle messes with camber by turning the upper mount plate -
Some do (My Mazda adjusts camber in 0.5 degree steps based on which way
the little stamped-in arrow on the mount-plate points) and some don't.
If the Windstar does (and I have no idea whether or not that's the
case), you need to make sure you put the mount-plate back in exactly the
same way you found it, or you'll blow your alignment all to hell.
> Check for ball joint looseness. These
> are all basic checks before any work or alignment is done.
Here you raise a good point - From the symptoms we've heard from the OP
so far, (sloppy steering, especially) I'd be suspecting either bad ball
joints, tie-rod ends, pittman arm, and/or idler arm before I'd suspect
the struts. Not that struts can't cause all the described symptoms, but
it seems to me that it's more likely to be something in the "connect the
steering box to the wheels" hardware. Then again, he DID say it has 130K
on it, so it might well be time for struts, too.
(Personally, I dealt with mine by "shotgunning" everything in the front
end - Mainly because it all needed it to some extent, and I had
everything needed on-hand to do a complete "replace everything that
moves, plus some stuff that doesn't" operation. Since I was in as deep
as I was already - looking at an absolute minimum of ball joints and tie
rod ends - it just made sense to do the whole job once, rather than
having to redo parts of it half a dozen times as the old stuff failed
under the changed stresses that come with only putting some new parts
into an old, "worn in" system.)
> > Hey,
> >
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> Newsgroups
> ----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =----

Signature
Don Bruder - dakidd@sonic.net - New Email policy in effect as of Feb. 21, 2004.
Short form: I'm trashing EVERY E-mail that doesn't contain a password in the
subject unless it comes from a "whitelisted" (pre-approved by me) address.
See <http://www.sonic.net/~dakidd/main/contact.html> for full details.
Shep - 16 Sep 2005 03:59 GMT
Without knowing the skill level of the poster ,you expect someone to
recommend tackling this job, what backround does he have what tools and so
one, that was the focus of my reply.
>> You should check the inner and outer tie rods for looseness, bounce the
>> van
[quoted text clipped - 72 lines]
>> ----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption
>> =----
* - 16 Sep 2005 16:44 GMT
Don Bruder <dakidd@sonic.net> wrote in article
<uPnWe.13823$p%3.59783@typhoon.sonic.net>...
> True, a set of coil-spring compressers is needed (Cheap and easy to get
> - Last set I bought was under $20, and the local autozone has 'em on
> hand as part of their "loan-a-tool" thing.)
Fact of the matter is those $20, long-bolt "spring compressors" are
dangerous in themselves........you won't find them in professional shops.
If not carefully aligned, they can slip and fall off.....
Some strut springs must be compressed at an angle.....something the $20
"spring compressors" are incapable of doing.
Anybody who uses these on a regular basis - if they're honest - can give
you a horror story of one slipping off and either cocking the spring at a
weird angle, or shooting the spring across the shop.
We never hear the stories because everyone figures it was somnething THEY
did wrong....Truth is their mistake was when they bought these compressors.
Place them in the hands of an inexperienced DIY, and you have a REAL
potential for trouble.
Shep - 16 Sep 2005 17:36 GMT
Amen.
> Don Bruder <dakidd@sonic.net> wrote in article
> <uPnWe.13823$p%3.59783@typhoon.sonic.net>...
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> Place them in the hands of an inexperienced DIY, and you have a REAL
> potential for trouble.
Ted Mittelstaedt - 17 Sep 2005 09:28 GMT
> Anybody who uses these on a regular basis - if they're honest - can give
> you a horror story of one slipping off and either cocking the spring at a
> weird angle, or shooting the spring across the shop.
>
> We never hear the stories because everyone figures it was somnething THEY
> did wrong....Truth is their mistake was when they bought these compressors.
Either that or because they are dead when the compressed spring shot
straight
into their chest.
OTC makes an inexpensive clamshell spring compressor that sells on the net
for under $200, (in addition to their expensive one that costs $700) and
Harbor Freight sells a cheapo Chinese knockoff of this for $40 that works
OK if you replace the bolts in it that are made out of Silly Putty with
decent
Grade 8 stuff.
Ted
Alex Rodriguez - 19 Sep 2005 19:53 GMT
>OTC makes an inexpensive clamshell spring compressor that sells on the net
>for under $200, (in addition to their expensive one that costs $700) and
>Harbor Freight sells a cheapo Chinese knockoff of this for $40 that works
>OK if you replace the bolts in it that are made out of Silly Putty with
>decent
>Grade 8 stuff.
The harbor freight compressor will not work with smaller springs, like on a
Honda Accord. Has anyone had any experience using
http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/Displayitem.taf?itemnumber=47890 ?
It looks like it would be faster to use.
-------------
Alex
Ryan Underwood - 20 Sep 2005 04:13 GMT
>> We never hear the stories because everyone figures it was somnething THEY
>> did wrong....Truth is their mistake was when they bought these
>compressors.
>Either that or because they are dead when the compressed spring shot
>straight
>into their chest.
I agree, it's sort of a wonky job. An independent suspension shop will do it
for $20 per strut if you bring them the old strut assy and the new strut
damper, mount and boot kit. $20 per strut saves a lot of grief IMHO.
Alex Rodriguez - 19 Sep 2005 19:50 GMT
>Fact of the matter is those $20, long-bolt "spring compressors" are
>dangerous in themselves........you won't find them in professional shops.
Danerous, hardly. I've used them with no problems. They are tedious to use
and take more time than more expensive tools, but they are not inherently
dangerous.
>If not carefully aligned, they can slip and fall off.....
They come with safety hooks that you should always use. So that at worst,
they will slip a bit, but not shoot out.
>Some strut springs must be compressed at an angle.....something the $20
>"spring compressors" are incapable of doing.
>Anybody who uses these on a regular basis - if they're honest - can give
>you a horror story of one slipping off and either cocking the spring at a
>weird angle, or shooting the spring across the shop.
slipping and cocking yes, shooting out, never. Slipping is not a big deal.
Just start again.
>We never hear the stories because everyone figures it was somnething THEY
>did wrong....Truth is their mistake was when they bought these compressors.
>Place them in the hands of an inexperienced DIY, and you have a REAL
>potential for trouble.
any tool in the hands of a fool can have disastrous results. You need to make
sure you understand how to properly use the tools before you use them. It is
not rocket science.
--------------
Alex