Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / Maintenance and Repair / November 2005
How often do you replace your fuel pump?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Julie P. - 20 Nov 2005 19:50 GMT I know this one person who work in the city, so he regularly replaces his battery, alternator, and starter every year or so, before they need to be replaced, just so he never breaks down. He says he has to drive through some very dangerous neighborhoods.
I am not worried about those, as I have ways to test those components, and you usually get a warning before they fail.
But I would like to replace my fuel pump before it fails so I am not stranded or faced to do emergency repairs in the middle of winter or some other inconvenient time. So, how often should you do this? Mine is an original one, and has 191,000 miles on it. It is in the fuel tank, and you need a special GM tool to remove it.
And do I really need to drain the fuel before I lower the tank? It only holds 14 gallons max, and I can just drive it until 1or 2 gallons are left before lowering it.
Also, how often should you replace your fuel filters and do an ATF change?
My GM manual is silent on the fuel filter issue, and recommends an ATF change every 100,000 miles, which seems kind of weird. I last did mine at around 130,000 miles.
Thanks, Julie
Pete C. - 20 Nov 2005 16:40 GMT > I know this one person who work in the city, so he regularly replaces his > battery, alternator, and starter every year or so, before they need to be [quoted text clipped - 22 lines] > Thanks, > Julie The fuel pump will fail when the tank is full - guaranteed, just so you have to siphon most of the gas before you replace the pump. I got around 150,000 mi out of the pump in my truck before it failed, with a full 34 gal tank, 1,700 mi from home.
Pete C.
=AB Paul =BB - 20 Nov 2005 20:34 GMT > I know this one person who work in the city, so he regularly replaces his > battery, alternator, and starter every year or so, before they need to be [quoted text clipped - 22 lines] > Thanks, > Julie Whoa! 191,000 miles on the orig fuel pump!!!? That's incredible! Change it now before its too late. Brushes wear out, commutators wear down, bearings wear out. Yes, you can use up all but 2 gallons of gas. Look in the tank for crud after you pull the module. Change fuel filter at the same time. Buy genuine AC OEM parts, not cheap junk.
Julie P. - 20 Nov 2005 22:33 GMT "« Paul »" <"=?x-user-defined?Q?=AB?= Paul =?x-user-defined?Q?=BB?="@houston.rr.com> wrote in message news:4380DE47.9CB1E89F@houston.rr.com...
> Whoa! 191,000 miles on the orig fuel pump!!!? That's incredible! > Change it now before its too late. Will do. Plus one of my fuel lines is leaking. They are totally rusted out. I need to replace about 60" worth of line for all three lines (tank to TBI, TBI to tank, and canister to tank).
> Brushes wear out, commutators wear down, bearings wear out. > Yes, you can use up all but 2 gallons of gas. > Look in the tank for crud after you pull the module. > Change fuel filter at the same time. > Buy genuine AC OEM parts, not cheap junk. I will! I learned the hard way with my starter. Although for some things, like alternators, I don't care, since PepBoys gives you a lifetime warranty, and they are easy to replace.
Julie
Steve - 21 Nov 2005 03:29 GMT « Paul » wrote:
> Whoa! 191,000 miles on the orig fuel pump!!!? My wife's car's fuel pump lasted until about 215k miles. There's not much to go wrong with them, really. But yeah, 200k is a reasonable time to replace one "on principle."
The guy that replaces starters, alternators, etc. though... that's just wasteful. So what if your alternator goes out in a "bad neighborhood?" You turn off the AC, turn off every other extraneous load, and drive to a safe place.
Pete C. - 21 Nov 2005 14:29 GMT > « Paul » wrote: > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > You turn off the AC, turn off every other extraneous load, and drive to > a safe place. First off you have to actually understand what an alternator does and how the vehicle doesn't instantly stop when it fails, then you have to have enough sense to be armed if you are regularly driving through bad neighborhoods.
Pete C.
nanook - 24 Nov 2005 15:50 GMT >« Paul » wrote: > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >You turn off the AC, turn off every other extraneous load, and drive to >a safe place. I was able to manage about 300k from my truck - 89 f/s chevy with v6. i ended up taking the bed off the truck to do it. the biggest 2 hassles was getting the trailer hitch off and propping the bed up.
an impact wrench with an extension was a life saver, the bolts are slightly tapered like seat mounting bolts.
mst - 21 Nov 2005 00:19 GMT > But I would like to replace my fuel pump before it fails so I am not > stranded or faced to do emergency repairs in the middle of winter or some > other inconvenient time. So, how often should you do this? I've never thought about "pro-active" maintenance - I always replace parts when things go rwong, but this could be a good point. I have a GM car that requires, not only to remove the gas tank, but to drop the rear-axle to drop the tank :(
Why GM "engineers" designed that, I'll (and many others) never know. An external pump might be in order!
 Signature remove MYSHOES to email
mst - 21 Nov 2005 00:23 GMT > > But I would like to replace my fuel pump before it fails so I am not > > stranded or faced to do emergency repairs in the middle of winter or some [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > Why GM "engineers" designed that, I'll (and many others) never > know. An external pump might be in order! Damn - I forgot to mention I have ~108,000 miles and have not changed the fuel pump - I dont forsee doing it until it goes bad.
 Signature remove MYSHOES to email
Scott Dorsey - 21 Nov 2005 01:18 GMT >Damn - I forgot to mention I have ~108,000 miles and have not >changed the fuel pump - I dont forsee doing it until it goes bad. I have never proactively changed a fuel pump either. But I have been stranded in an intersection in rush hour in Washington DC by a failed fuel pump... and stranded on an airport taxiway where I had to be towed by a follow-me truck.... and had my engine cut out on the downslope of a mountain....
You know, maybe proactive fuel pump replacement isn't such a bad idea either. --scott
 Signature "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
mst - 21 Nov 2005 01:23 GMT > >Damn - I forgot to mention I have ~108,000 miles and have not > >changed the fuel pump - I dont forsee doing it until it goes bad. > > I have never proactively changed a fuel pump either. But I have been > stranded in an intersection in rush hour in Washington DC Isn't traffic in DC *ALWAYS* rush-hour? :)
 Signature remove MYSHOES to email
N8N - 21 Nov 2005 00:39 GMT > > But I would like to replace my fuel pump before it fails so I am not > > stranded or faced to do emergency repairs in the middle of winter or some [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > Why GM "engineers" designed that, I'll (and many others) never > know. An external pump might be in order! Some more enlightened mfgrs. put a little hatch in the floor so you only have to take out 6-8 screws to access the fuel pump, but sadly this is not universal.
nate
mst - 21 Nov 2005 00:50 GMT > > Why GM "engineers" designed that, I'll (and many others) never > > know. An external pump might be in order! > > Some more enlightened mfgrs. put a little hatch in the floor so you > only have to take out 6-8 screws to access the fuel pump, but sadly > this is not universal. Yea, I dont see GM being "universal" in any regard :) If my Camaro has any "fuel-pump-hatch", it's gonna be behind the rear seats and I SERIOUSLY doubt GM would have spent the money to put one in - heck, they werent smart enough to use an external electric fuel pump!!
 Signature remove MYSHOES to email
Scott Dorsey - 21 Nov 2005 01:19 GMT >Yea, I dont see GM being "universal" in any regard :) If my >Camaro has any "fuel-pump-hatch", it's gonna be behind the >rear seats and I SERIOUSLY doubt GM would have spent the >money to put one in - heck, they werent smart enough to use >an external electric fuel pump!! Ten minutes with a Sawzall and it could have a fuel pump hatch if you want it to. --scott
 Signature "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."
Julie P. - 21 Nov 2005 02:24 GMT >>Yea, I dont see GM being "universal" in any regard :) If my >>Camaro has any "fuel-pump-hatch", it's gonna be behind the [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > want it to. > --scott Very nice idea!! I might do this, really.
Julie
N8N - 21 Nov 2005 16:03 GMT > >>Yea, I dont see GM being "universal" in any regard :) If my > >>Camaro has any "fuel-pump-hatch", it's gonna be behind the [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > > Julie Just make sure you don't cut a nice little square in the top of your fuel tank :(
nate
shiden_kai - 27 Nov 2005 17:21 GMT > Yea, I dont see GM being "universal" in any regard :) If my > Camaro has any "fuel-pump-hatch", it's gonna be behind the > rear seats and I SERIOUSLY doubt GM would have spent the > money to put one in - heck, they werent smart enough to use > an external electric fuel pump!! They didn't put one in. And though I don't recommend it, I know one of the guys in our shop who has a Camaro use a body shop style "nibbler" to create his own "hatch". Certainly was a lot easier then lowering the rear axle.
Ian
mst - 27 Nov 2005 18:08 GMT > > Yea, I dont see GM being "universal" in any regard :) If my > > Camaro has any "fuel-pump-hatch", it's gonna be behind the [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > style "nibbler" to create his own "hatch". Certainly was a lot > easier then lowering the rear axle. When the day comes to replace the fuel-pump, I'll be cutting out a hatch door too :)
 Signature remove MYSHOES to email
Steve - 21 Nov 2005 03:31 GMT >>>But I would like to replace my fuel pump before it fails so I am not >>>stranded or faced to do emergency repairs in the middle of winter or some [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > > nate Yep, wife's 93 Chrysler LH has an access panel in the trunk floor. I changed it's pump with the gas tank completely full. The only vehicle I've had to DROP the tank on was a pickup... and I swear it would have been easier to pull the bed off the frame and get at it that way :-p
|
|
|