I believe the plugs were replaced by the same dealer at ~ 30K miles. So
what can you offer on how often this might happen and how offen the
penetrating oil is successful (what are the odds that the Dodge dealer
gets it out without charging me to replace a head?)?
> I believe the plugs were replaced by the same dealer at ~ 30K miles. So
> what can you offer on how often this might happen and how offen the
> penetrating oil is successful (what are the odds that the Dodge dealer
> gets it out without charging me to replace a head?)?
See the previous remark on heli-coils. And a heli-coil might not even
be necessary.
You take the plug out, using whatever violence is necessary. This
will tear up the threads. Now you put a thread-cleaner through the
hole. In my experience, this will normally end up with threads that
work well enough to get compression, which is all you really need.
If this isn't good enough, you re-thread the hole with a bigger tap,
and put in an insert called a heli-coil. In Nomen Nescio's ideal
world of $150,000 Neons, all aluminum heads would have heli-coils
installed at the factory.
It's really hard to imagine taking out a seized plug causing so much
damage that a heli-coil can't fix it. If the service writer seems to
be uncomfortable with this idea, something is really wrong.

Signature
Joseph J. Pfeiffer, Jr., Ph.D. Phone -- (505) 646-1605
Department of Computer Science FAX -- (505) 646-1002
New Mexico State University http://www.cs.nmsu.edu/~pfeiffer
Matt Whiting - 28 Apr 2005 11:45 GMT
> It's really hard to imagine taking out a seized plug causing so much
> damage that a heli-coil can't fix it. If the service writer seems to
> be uncomfortable with this idea, something is really wrong.
Yes, it may be time to switch to another shop.
Matt
See E mail
> I believe the plugs were replaced by the same dealer at ~ 30K miles. So
> what can you offer on how often this might happen and how offen the
> penetrating oil is successful (what are the odds that the Dodge dealer
> gets it out without charging me to replace a head?)?
!00k platinum plugs in that engine, replaced at that mileage unless there is
a problem, soak the plugs over nite, remove them from a cold engine and they
should pop out, anytime you remove hot steel from hot aluminum metal,
problems like this happen, that goes with changing your engine oil also,
steel drain plug + aluminum pan= damaged threads when hot.
> I believe the plugs were replaced by the same dealer at ~ 30K miles. So
> what can you offer on how often this might happen and how offen the
> penetrating oil is successful (what are the odds that the Dodge dealer
> gets it out without charging me to replace a head?)?
Matt Whiting - 28 Apr 2005 22:38 GMT
> !00k platinum plugs in that engine, replaced at that mileage unless there is
> a problem, soak the plugs over nite, remove them from a cold engine and they
> should pop out, anytime you remove hot steel from hot aluminum metal,
> problems like this happen, that goes with changing your engine oil also,
> steel drain plug + aluminum pan= damaged threads when hot.
Really? I've heard just the opposite. AL expands at a rate higher than
steel. Steel plug inside of aluminum will get looser as the temp goes up.
Matt
KWS - 23 Jun 2005 06:53 GMT
I replaced the original platinum plugs in our '96 T&C at some mileage over
100K. They came out with completely reasonable effort. The plug boots were
more difficult to remove than the plugs. Another interesting fact: even
though some of the gaps were about 2X the factory setting, the car still ran
great. There was no change that I could detect in performance or gas mileage
before and after.
Ken
> !00k platinum plugs in that engine, replaced at that mileage unless there is
> a problem, soak the plugs over nite, remove them from a cold engine and they
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> > penetrating oil is successful (what are the odds that the Dodge dealer
> > gets it out without charging me to replace a head?)?