Car Forum / Chrysler Cars / June 2007
"Car dealers seek workers, even as makers slash jobs"
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Mike - 16 Jun 2007 12:47 GMT Car dealers seek workers, even as makers slash jobs By Adam Terese THE WASHINGTON TIMES www.washtimes.com Published June 16, 2007
The major U.S. automakers are cutting jobs across the country, but auto dealerships are begging for workers. More than 108,000 jobs are open at U.S. dealerships, ranging from mechanics and salesmen to receptionists and bookkeepers, according to a study by Automotive Retailing Today, a coalition of major automobile companies and dealers. "When you think of dealerships, you think of car showrooms; but it's a business like any other business," said Denise Patton-Pace, executive director for ART. All those openings have affected dealerships. The worker shortage has caused employees to work longer hours at Russel Toyota, said Mark Putnam, sales manager at the Catonsville, Md., dealership. The sales department is a bit understaffed at his dealership, since more cars are being sold. He said he may be hiring more salespeople this week. For many dealerships, filling the service department has especially become a "struggle," said Gerard Murphy, president of the Washington Area New Auto Dealers Association. Fewer workers in service and other departments often means less work can be taken on, said Bob Armstrong, business office manager at Patriot Buick-Pontiac-GMC in Williamsburg. To cope with the demand, his dealership has extended its hours by one hour every day. "That has helped smooth out the workload," Mr. Armstrong said. The struggle to hire mechanics partially comes from a need for more skilled mechanics, especially as dealerships expand and car technology becomes more complex, said John Wheaton, vice president of College Park Honda. "It's not just a matter of taking apart an engine anymore," Mr. Wheaton said. "It's getting very complicated." Mr. Murphy said the difficulty in finding service employees could affect customer service if not addressed. But he said automakers have stepped up the quality of automobiles, meaning fewer technical and mechanical problems with vehicles. That increase in quality has resulted in fewer customers in the service department, he added. In recent years, it has become even harder to fill technician positions, said Jesse Toprak, an analyst with Edmunds.com, a publisher of automobile pricing guides. "In terms of technicians, there's a strong growth curve because of a lack of qualified people," said Mr. Toprak, who has been in the auto industry almost 13 years. Reflecting that trend, the study found most available jobs were in the service and sales departments. But sales-department openings are likely being caused by turnover, Mr. Toprak said. Although auto dealerships reported strong new-vehicle sales during 2006, the new-car department saw a 3 percent decrease, according to the National Automobile Dealers Association, a McLean association for new-car and truck dealers. That decrease in new-car sales has created high turnover in sales jobs at dealerships, Mr. Toprak said. Because sales have dropped, it means less profit potential for a salesman. Declining profits on new- car sales make sales careers look less attractive, he added. "It's becoming harder to make a decent living being a car salesman," Mr. Toprak said. To compensate, dealerships are focusing more on back-end profits that come from financing and insurance instead of just front-end profits, or selling the car, he added. So far, those unfilled jobs have not affected customers dramatically, Mr. Murphy said. "It hasn't had a deleterious effect, at least to my knowledge," he said. "It's a potentially huge issue without intervention." This is the second study conducted by Automotive Retailing Today on job openings. The first, in 2006, found an estimated 104,803 job openings. Carter Myers, chairman of the coalition, said he was surprised to see so many jobs available during the 2006 study. But this time around, he expected it. In the new study, the most job openings -- 25,149 -- were in the South Atlantic region, which includes the District of Columbia, Maryland, Virginia and six other states. It is the biggest region in the survey. In all job areas, dealerships are seeing the jobs becoming more computerized and professional, Mr. Myers said. Compared with the past, dealerships are hiring more people with college degrees or college experience. "The Internet has helped us hone the sales process and it's helped the buying process," said Mr. Myers, who has been in the automobile dealership industry for nearly 43 years with Carter Myers Automotive in Charlottesville. "Customers are more educated, so we need to be more educated. It's become a tool for both sides." The study, conducted by Harris Interactive, surveyed 742 franchised new-car dealers about the estimated number of vacant positions at their dealerships from March 28 through April 12 of this year. Mr. Myers said jobs at dealerships will likely continue to be available, especially as the baby boomers start to retire. "That's going to become interesting when it starts in three or four years," he said. "It's a much more complex environment."
Ted Mittelstaedt - 18 Jun 2007 09:23 GMT > Car dealers seek workers, even as makers slash jobs > By Adam Terese [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > The major U.S. automakers are cutting jobs across the country, but > auto dealerships are begging for workers. Absolute rubbish and bull crap.
No business ever had problems finding workers who were willing to compete for them.
Competing for workers means offering more money and benefits than the business down the street.
Where the shortage is, is dealerships who are looking for workers that they can pay peanuts to.
My observation is most businesses are run by managers trained during the 70's and 80's where there was much higher unemployment and they are used to the idea they can fire at will and there will always be someone new clamoring to get the job.
The 90s changed that and it was painful. They thought the recession in 2000-2004 would straighten out the common workers, and put things back to the old high unemployment, choose workers at will. But now unemployment is dropping and these managers and business owners are concerned since they might actually have to raise wages to attract people.
Ted
eveleighsam@hotmail.com - 18 Jun 2007 15:49 GMT > > Car dealers seek workers, even as makers slash jobs > > By Adam Terese [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > Ted I totally agree with the fact that the dealerships would not have a problem finding the labour force they require if they would only come up to the times and realise that they have to pay a decent wage , at least to compare to the other trades . The typical auto tech puts a great deal into the constant advances in the new automotive industry , ie : tools , training ,. The expence of tools alone is usually in the tens of thousands . When the wage is not comparable to other trades it does not bring new people into the trade , without new aprentices , because it takes years of training , in the next few years the dealerships will really see the depth of it . Being from the atlantic canada area I am only aware of our typical wage and ranging from $8 to $19 and the average being $15 or $16 with little or no benifits , it is not a very inviting trade to the younger people. The company I work for and others run near around the clock to keep up with the work load . What will happen is up to them Sink or Float
Sam.
tango - 18 Jun 2007 18:21 GMT >> > Car dealers seek workers, even as makers slash jobs >> > By Adam Terese [quoted text clipped - 56 lines] > > Sam. The average mechanic working at most dealerships has a basic set of hand tools and maybe an assortment of a few extra goodies usually no more than a thousand dollars. Whatever you are smoking must be good stuff. Now if you meant a descent independent shop then you would be correct. Most every profession has the same requirements for competent technicians and the average is about 30% competent, about 30% who get by, and 40% should find another profession. All these well trained auto techs seem to dissappear before they make it to the auto repair shops. Have you tried to find where they dissappear to?
maxpower - 18 Jun 2007 19:32 GMT > >> > Car dealers seek workers, even as makers slash jobs > >> > By Adam Terese [quoted text clipped - 60 lines] > tools and maybe an assortment of a few extra goodies usually no more than > a thousand dollars. Thats funny!! I own 3 air tools valued at over $1000.00 My lap top and my Star Mobile Diagnostic scan tool was $2400.00
> Whatever you are smoking must be good stuff. > Now if you meant a descent independent shop then you would be correct. [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > to the auto repair shops. Have you tried to find where they dissappear > to? philthy - 18 Jun 2007 23:37 GMT hey glenn whay did you buy a mobile scantool did the dealer not get one? or does your shop have 20 techs??
> > >> > Car dealers seek workers, even as makers slash jobs > > >> > By Adam Terese [quoted text clipped - 72 lines] > > to the auto repair shops. Have you tried to find where they dissappear > > to? maxpower - 18 Jun 2007 23:47 GMT > hey glenn whay did you buy a mobile scantool did the dealer not get one? or > does your shop have 20 techs?? [quoted text clipped - 75 lines] > > > to the auto repair shops. Have you tried to find where they dissappear > > > to? We have 2 Star Mobiles and 2 scanners, they have to be signed out each time you use them. They lock them up in the Parts department each day and since I open at 5am it does me no good I like to have my own tools and be able to use them as needed.After purchasing the lap top and Star mobile I had them both hooked up wireless to make it easier to do flashes in the parking lot.
C-BODY@webtv.net - 19 Jun 2007 03:17 GMT This is one of the "under the radar screen" issues more than anything else. And, it's not new either!
To be a successful tech, most usually end up with a roll-around Snap-On Tools tool box (or a similar brand of tool company's box) that can cost upward of $6K by itself. That's BEFORE the tools go in it.
Dealerships do have manufacturer-specified special tools for techinicians to use to do particular repairs. This would include the various scan tools PLUS computers to run them and connect to the factory computers for new "flash" updates and such. But, as mentioned, most of these things are kept under "lock and key" lest they disappear (for one reason or another, including being left in a customer's vehicle when a service advisor might have needed the vehicle to deliver to the customer when the tech was not around).
So, to expedite their repair activities, many techs purchase their own special tools and scan tools and computers so they don't have to rely upon the dealership for these things. Plus, if they go somewhere else or do some work on weekends, they will have what they need to do the jobs off-site from the dealership. Updates can be expensive, but they are not coming that close together any more. In many cases, private shops can purchase similar tools from different sources (operative words would be "OEM quality sources").
Therefore, it would be easy for a tech to sink over $10K in tools and a box to keep them in. Usually on "time pay" to the tool truck's operator.
Compensation might be an issue, but few younger kids want to get their hands dirty or deal with what dealership or private shop techs deal with to make the same or more amounts of money as other jobs might pay. It's been noted that a tech in a larger and higher volume dealership of a luxury import carline might make $70K plus, but I suspect the more real-world figures would be closer to $50K. But it all depends on how many labor hours you run and where the dealership is located.
Labor hours can also depend upon what the manuals say each job should pay. That can be a variable landscape, in many situations, not to mention "warranty" or "customer pay" issues.
By observation, the technician and possibly parts department employees are where the most urgent needs are. Typically, office work and sales people can be found if they are looked for, with all due respect.
Sales people, typically move around a good bit, from dealership to dealership. This "mobility" can hurt themselves if they are looking for a career as such, but as long as they are successful at each place, that's all that really matters. Still, getting an established clientel can take 3-5 years at one location. Once the clientel is established, they can be notified of any changes of dealership by the salesperson. Be that as it may.
In the private sector, there has been much ink about the cost of employee turnover. IF the company has a formalized training program, then a dollar value can be put on these things. Few dealerships have a training program (possibly except for some of the larger ones who have programs for vehicle sales people--read the fine print before you become a salesperson, you might have to pay for your own training), so they don't really see these same turnover costs other than in a little nuisance in getting new employees up to speed on how to (basically) operate in a particular area of the store. Manufacturer training programs are much more numerous now than in the past though, with "incentives" for employees to paricipate and place highly in their testing. You never really "get out of school" in the car business, any more, whether it's sales or service or parts.
By observation, the car business is still a good business to be in . . . except if you happen to be at a "corporate" store instead of a dealership that's owned by the person whose name is on the sign. Even that can be variable, though. Some of the alleged advantages of being part of a "corporate" store, for the employee, sometimes don't really pan out . . . from what former employees of those corporate stores have told me. But, it can be a place to start in the business.
There have been lots of changes in the past 30 years I've been in that business, but one thing has not changed (regardless of how many times people try to reinvent it!) . . . you take care of the customer's needs and thank them for their business (even if it hurts).
Enjoy!
C-BODY
philthy - 21 Jun 2007 01:34 GMT the big thing you missed about techs is now it requires a full education before coming in the trade meaning trade school or a 4 collage degree and for the most part those grads from these sources get grabbed up before they go to the dealer network and they are warned alot on how dealers inner workings are so they shy away from them. now. there is the pay as you train low end employees dealers owners love because they can get away with more as far as no benefits. charge bacs if they are flat rate and a trainee can do the same easy money tune up that a ase pro can do but at half the rate so the dealer sees a higher profit and less cost of sales figures, then the ase techs do the tough warranty work. and get tired of that and leave after a few years of that crap but like you stated less youngsters are not wanting to get their hands dirty resulting in a less dependable tech workforce that will bite them in the a.s in the next 10 years as sh.t really gets to the next generation of advancements on cars and trucks now the scan tools we have at the shop i work at have a gm scantool that is updated on a regular schedule with gm through a local dealer works real good and we have a bdm pro from blue steak the equals the drb3 and fords scan tool now if you have a laptop u can get software from a company that gets into all gm stuff and all ford and d.c including can and will do odb2 for the asian cars and all i can say is you have not seen anything yet
> This is one of the "under the radar screen" issues more than anything > else. And, it's not new either! [quoted text clipped - 79 lines] > > C-BODY Bill Putney - 21 Jun 2007 11:08 GMT > the big thing you missed about techs is now it requires a full education > before coming in the trade meaning trade school or a 4 collage degree and [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > into all gm stuff and all ford and d.c including can and will do odb2 for > the asian cars and all i can say is you have not seen anything yet apparently techs are pretty lazy and or ignorant they dont have to know how to use proper punctuation and capitalization there is not aything wrong with that other than it shows laziness and a disrespect for whoever is going to read what they wrote it also can lead to mistakes on interpretation since the reader doesnt know where one sentence ends and the next begins sometimes where you do sentence breaks can change the meaning and it also requires unnecessary effort and time on the readers part working thru what can though possibly good information otherwise appear to be ignorant mumbo jumbo
Bill Putney (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address with the letter 'x')
maxpower - 21 Jun 2007 18:59 GMT > > the big thing you missed about techs is now it requires a full education > > before coming in the trade meaning trade school or a 4 collage degree and [quoted text clipped - 27 lines] > part working thru what can though possibly good information otherwise > appear to be ignorant mumbo jumbo Play nice Bill or you can sit in the corner
> Bill Putney > (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my > address with the letter 'x') Bill Putney - 22 Jun 2007 00:08 GMT >>>the big thing you missed about techs is now it requires a full education >>>before coming in the trade meaning trade school or a 4 collage degree [quoted text clipped - 65 lines] > > Play nice Bill or you can sit in the corner I sawee. :)
Bill Putney (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my address with the letter 'x')
maxpower - 22 Jun 2007 01:49 GMT > >>>the big thing you missed about techs is now it requires a full education > >>>before coming in the trade meaning trade school or a 4 collage degree [quoted text clipped - 71 lines] > (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my > address with the letter 'x') It ok, no time out needed this time
|
|
|