I rear ended a guy with a new 2006 Dodge Ram 1500. It had a black
bumper (not the chrome one) It was about a 5km/hr bump, that left one
slight indentation in the right corner, about two inches round, and not
deep at all.
He said he went to the dealership and said the cost to fix would be
$2000. I asked if it caused other damage to the truck, and he said no,
just the bumper.
Now, I have a 2005 Dodge 1500 - and was rearended this winter - it
caused 3 large dents as well as scratches all along. It only cost $350
to fix.
Why the descrepancy?
Also, how much would just a new black rear bumper cost?
Thanks
Ace - 15 Apr 2006 07:11 GMT
$50.00 on Ebay right now for a chrome one. Probably a 200 dollar item
at dealer.
Bob AZ
GeekBoy - 15 Apr 2006 07:31 GMT
sh.t ,for $1200 US you can buy a nice lookig custom bumper that is very
strong like those ugly pipes people sometimes attach to their trucks.
> $50.00 on Ebay right now for a chrome one. Probably a 200 dollar item
> at dealer.
>
> Bob AZ
Jerry - 15 Apr 2006 07:36 GMT
Ask him for the estimate on paper.

Signature
Jerry
miles - 15 Apr 2006 11:17 GMT
> I rear ended a guy with a new 2006 Dodge Ram 1500. It had a black
> bumper (not the chrome one) It was about a 5km/hr bump, that left one
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> caused 3 large dents as well as scratches all along. It only cost $350
> to fix.
He needs to show written estimates from the dealer. You can also
contact the dealer yourself and get an estimate in writing. It's the
only way to keep things fair to both parties.
Aceman - 16 Apr 2006 00:26 GMT
> I rear ended a guy with a new 2006 Dodge Ram 1500. It had a black
> bumper (not the chrome one) It was about a 5km/hr bump, that left one
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Thanks
I would have called the police at the time of the accident to get an
official police report. I'm not sure if you did or not, and if you didn't, I
realize you're probably trying to save a possible insurance premium hike,
but from the looks of it, the guy is trying to railroad you with the extra
$$ and would have probably been worth going thru your insurance in the long
run.
Just last month, I was in Philly (center city - and I hate going into Philly
with my Ram), some girl cut my arc while I was making a left on a tight side
street from a one way street with two lanes onto another one way street with
two lanes. Originally as I pulled up to the light in the right lane with my
right turn signal on, I notice a small car parked on the corner with some
girl in the driver seat talking to a passenger. I made a mental note to take
it wide. Light changed and I proceeded and did take it wide. I then heard
this awful scrape on the right side. I looked over and there she was trying
to make the turn. I made sure to get a cop so to make an official police
report and glad I did. She was driving with an expired tag and she got fined
for that.
The passenger was her boyfriend. They were a young couple, early 20's. He
was trying to say it was my fault. I said I wasn't the one that was parked
on the corner,and you need to signal to show your intention to enter a
traffic lane out of a parking spot and not just dart out and try to make a
turn, whether on the corner or not. He tried to argue with me, and I said
there's no need to argue about it and we'll just let the cops sort it out.
Then he asked me to keep the cops out of it and I said NO, now way. I want a
police report because I knew it was her fault. As we exchanged paper work
waiting for the cops, she didn't have the owener/reg card and said she
forgot it at home. I said we'll let the cops sort that out as well. Glad I
did call them...
Ace
miles - 16 Apr 2006 00:56 GMT
> I would have called the police at the time of the accident to get an
> official police report. I'm not sure if you did or not, and if you didn't, I
> realize you're probably trying to save a possible insurance premium hike,
> but from the looks of it, the guy is trying to railroad you with the extra
> $$ and would have probably been worth going thru your insurance in the long
> run.
Here in Arizona the police don't need to be called if damage is under
$1000 and theres no injuries or its on private property such as a
parking lot.
Aceman - 16 Apr 2006 01:12 GMT
> Here in Arizona the police don't need to be called if damage is under
> $1000 and theres no injuries or its on private property such as a
> parking lot.
Hmm, interesting. I guess it doesn't matter, unless that guy pushes the
$2000 thing, but it's too late now. How would you determine if damage is
below a grand anyway at the time of the incident?
Ace
miles - 16 Apr 2006 02:46 GMT
> Hmm, interesting. I guess it doesn't matter, unless that guy pushes the
> $2000 thing, but it's too late now. How would you determine if damage is
> below a grand anyway at the time of the incident?
I've always wondered that too. Anyways, I wouldn't pay it without
written estimates from the dealer and you can get your own estimates.
Aceman - 17 Apr 2006 13:41 GMT
>> Hmm, interesting. I guess it doesn't matter, unless that guy pushes
>> the $2000 thing, but it's too late now. How would you determine if
>> damage is below a grand anyway at the time of the incident?
>
> I've always wondered that too. Anyways, I wouldn't pay it without
> written estimates from the dealer and you can get your own estimates.
Good point.
Ace
Rachel Easson - 16 Apr 2006 03:29 GMT
> I rear ended a guy with a new 2006 Dodge Ram 1500. It had a black
> bumper (not the chrome one) It was about a 5km/hr bump, that left one
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Thanks
I heard it is common practice for insurance companies to request three
written estimates and let the company decide, so that is what I would do
if I were you, and while you are at it, call the dealer -- you can't get
more expensive than that...
or, if yours is really nice, and it is a match, you could do a swap, and
fix yours at your convenience
rach