(I hope this isn't a rude question, but it's a serious one. I don't
want to overpay the US government. That isn't being patriotic. So,
hopefully someone can see the best approach for me to take with the
scenario poised below. I am in a personal information discovery phase
right now and will hire a tax attorney to execute this, but want to
see what third-party opinions have to say as I am naive about the
process, and want to make the smartest move going forward.)
If my C Corporation pays me $2.3M to buy a house, car, other personal
items, is it better to go down a path to have this full amount paid to
me in one lump sum, with me barring the separate personal tax
responsibilities after the transaction, or is it smarter/better to
have the corporation buy these items and sell them to me for $1.00?
(btw & FYI this transaction is considered compensation for the great
work I performed for free over the last 4 years building the company.)
So, OK. Don't get mad at the gifts/or the amount just looking for
sound logical advice on how I can approach this. Any level of detail
would be greatly appreciated, and maybe others will learn too that are
on my track. I simply have no idea how to calculate what my tax
baring responsibilities will be. Thanks so much. Julia
Richard Macdonald - 15 May 2004 16:22 GMT
> (I hope this isn't a rude question, but it's a serious one. I don't
> want to overpay the US government. That isn't being patriotic. So,
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> on my track. I simply have no idea how to calculate what my tax
> baring responsibilities will be. Thanks so much. Julia
Substance rules over form, if the corporation is giving something to
you, it is either a repayment of funds loaned (if any), compensation
for services, or a dividend (distribution of retained earnings).
One option is that if you lent your corporation any monies,
have the corporation repay the debt first. The Corporation
will have income, you will not.
Another is that if you have retained earnings, pay them
out to you as dividends and take advantage of the current
low rate of tax on dividends while it's still here.
Out of current earnings, consider just a regular salary/bonus
payment, sure there are payroll taxes but the payment is a
deduction to the Corporation and income to you, but you
avoid the corporate income tax on that amount. Once you
are over the Soc Sec cap, the benefits really show.
The best thing is sit down with a professional and play
with the numbers to see what combination will result
with the lowest overall tax burden.
Having the corporation buy the stuff and sell it to you for
next to nothing does nothing, as losses to related parties
cannot be deducted, and it will not effect your corporate
tax and at worst can be later ruled to be constructive
dividends and added to your income.
--
Richard A Macdonald, CPA/EA
Dedicated student of Fr Luca Paccioli, Master Juggler.
Gib mir schokolade und niemand wird verletzt!!
MC - 15 May 2004 19:13 GMT
> (I hope this isn't a rude question, but it's a serious one. I don't
> want to overpay the US government. That isn't
Julia - you are smelling pretty spammy today. Why don't you take a hike?
MC
REInvestments - 16 May 2004 00:24 GMT
> (I hope this isn't a rude question, but it's a serious one. I don't
> want to overpay the US government. That isn't being patriotic. So,
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> on my track. I simply have no idea how to calculate what my tax
> baring responsibilities will be. Thanks so much. Julia
If your C Corp sells you 2.3 million dollars worth of stuff in return for
the 4 years of hard work you did,
you are either going to pay for it as a dividend, or as ordinary income. If
you are unlucky,. it will
be disallowed as unfair compensation and end up being taxable to you,
personally, and not
deductible to the corporation.
By the way, you're getting this answer on alt.autos.ferrari on the
internet. So when the audit
comes up you may want to be sure to tell the IRS you were getting your tax
advice
from car people on the internet. On a 2.3 million dollar issue. That will
impress them.
But then I note you'll be hiring a tax attorney "to execute this". Be
sure to ask him for some advice on your
Ferrari. At least you have the sense to consult a professonal BEFORE making
a dumb move.
Remember to share with your tax attorney your internationally published
question so he can take
that fact into consideration when advising you. And get a spell checker.
Grumpily yours,
REInvestments