> There are brushes. I replaced them.
Never said otherwise.
> They do wear down.
Yes they do.
> I replaced them.
No dispute from me.
> Mine wore all of the way to nubs that
> were perhaps 7mm (1/4") long, and resulted in failure of the brush to reach
> the armeture
In an alternator, it's called a "rotor."
The part that the brushes contact on the rotor are the "slip
rings."
> (which, in a generator device is actually a commutator).
Which indeed -do- carry output current.
> I am
> predicting that the OP's brushes are worn to the point where they can stick
> in the channel that holds them, and this causes the contact to be broken;
> which causes the Charge Light to flicker at high speed.
The tie in to the problem only occurring at higher RPM is what
then?
> The carry current to the diode pack that converts the output to DC, and
> perhaps provide regulator services as well.
Nope. The diode pack is connected to the stator, current is built
in the stator as AC, the diodes convert the AC to DC.
The brushes transfer voltage to the rotor making the rotor a
magnet. Spin a magnet (the rotor) near a coil of wire (the
stator) and current is generated.
Some alternators with integral regulators use a diode trio to tap
voltage directly off of the stator to feed the rotor thru one
brush terminal, the other brush terminal is toggled to ground by
the voltage regulator to control output voltage.
(explains any diodes you may have seen connected to the brushes)
> I do not know what you know,
But I know what you know and I know that the brushes in an
alternator carry field current, not output current.
> but I do know what I know, and what I know is
> that I replaced the brushes in the alternator of my '97 Ford F150.
Your dissertation should have ended there.
> You can
> argue with lots of stuff, but you can not argue with what I did to my truck.
I'm not arguing with what you did to your truck, I'm stating that
the brushes you replaced do not carry output current to the
"nether regions" of his truck, your truck or any other Ford
truck.
> I notice you haven't a better idea.
Because I don't disagree that replacing the brushes is a
reasonable first step.
> The OP can test what I suggested by
> simply removing the alternator and taking a couple of screws out of the
> back. I could be wrong, but it will not cost anything to find out. And, if I
> am not wrong, I will save him roughly $175, and all he has to do after
> taking the alternator off of his truck -- a task he has to do anyway -- is
> take out a few screws and swap the part, then put the screws back in.
All well and good but it doesn't change the fact that the brushes
do not carry output current which was the -only- thing I was
correcting you on.
If your ego is such that you can't stand a simple correction and
use the learning experience to your advantage, well, life will
get harder before it gets easier.
> POINT OF ORDER
> I am not the one that said this was a common failure.
Duh! I did.
> I only said I had a
> similar problem as the OP, except I did not notice I had a problem until I
> needed a flatbed truck to get home -- he noticed when he hit the upper
> limits of the tach.
No, you didn't "only said."
You said; "The brushes are spring loaded to press against the
armature of the
alternator and collect the electricity and deliver it to the
nether reaches
of your truck."
Sorry Jeff but that is flat out wrong.
Alternators do not have "armatures."
The brushes only carry field current to the rotor.
The brushes allow the spinning rotor and its windings to become
an electro magnet
> Since I never hit the upper limits of the tach, I did
> not see the impending doom until it was too late. My point is not that the
> alternator is bad, my point is that IF the alternator is bad, it is easily
> fixed by swapping in new brushes instead of replacing the entire alternator
> at a significantly higher cost.
And that's a good point.
I have no problem with your recommended repair, just with a small
error in your theory.
snewman1209@gmail.com - 22 Dec 2007 21:13 GMT
snewman1209@gmail.com - 22 Dec 2007 21:17 GMT
Whoa guys! Seriously though, sorry to cause the bad blood here.....
But seriously, both you guys know your S#%T more than I, and
appreciate all the information.
OP = Org. Poster...... got it! =)
Jeff Strickland - 22 Dec 2007 23:49 GMT
> Whoa guys! Seriously though, sorry to cause the bad blood here.....
>
> But seriously, both you guys know your S#%T more than I, and
> appreciate all the information.
>
> OP = Org. Poster...... got it! =)
Yes, Original Poster.
I don't know precisely what the brushes do that we are talking about. What I
do know is that the alternator produces electricity, and your engine needs
that electricity. The only way I know of to get the electricity out of the
alternator is via the two brushes that I _think_ you will find that you
need.
aarcuda69062 - 23 Dec 2007 00:54 GMT
In article
<af30a7b7-7f5e-4194-8fb8-0a52bfc6f975@d21g2000prf.googlegroups.co
m>,
> Whoa guys! Seriously though, sorry to cause the bad blood here.....
There's no bad blood here.
> But seriously, both you guys know your S#%T more than I, and
> appreciate all the information.
I know my sh.t. Strickland apparently comes from the ilk that
bemoans the lack of trained knowledgeable mechanics but then
recoils when he encounters one.
> OP = Org. Poster...... got it! =)
Jeff Strickland - 23 Dec 2007 01:00 GMT
> In article
> <af30a7b7-7f5e-4194-8fb8-0a52bfc6f975@d21g2000prf.googlegroups.co
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> bemoans the lack of trained knowledgeable mechanics but then
> recoils when he encounters one.
How in the world would you arrive at such a conclusion?
aarcuda69062 - 23 Dec 2007 02:27 GMT
> > In article
> > <af30a7b7-7f5e-4194-8fb8-0a52bfc6f975@d21g2000prf.googlegroups.co
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> How in the world would you arrive at such a conclusion?
To what?
snewman1209@gmail.com - 26 Dec 2007 19:36 GMT
CRUD!!!!!!!!!!!!! I went to Napa this weekend, and they had the
brushes in their computer, but not available in the WHOLE bay area.
WTF?
Then I went to Kragen and they had no idea what I was even talking
about.
Last night, driving relatives homes, my battery light pretty much
stayed on (no flickering anymore) and my radio burnt out, all my dash
lights came on, dome light shut off, and battery guage super low. So
Im guessing the alternator just hit its RIP.
Now I need to ask........ is THIS a job I can do? Its more of a
matter of betting the belt off/on yes? 10-15 mins?
Jeff Strickland - 26 Dec 2007 21:58 GMT
It's an easy fix. Well, it was easy on my F150 with the 4.6L V8. I can't
imagine your Ranger V6 will throw out any huge obsticles.
You said, not available. Do you mean not available, or not in stock? Not in
stock means they can get them in a day or two.
> CRUD!!!!!!!!!!!!! I went to Napa this weekend, and they had the
> brushes in their computer, but not available in the WHOLE bay area.
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Now I need to ask........ is THIS a job I can do? Its more of a
> matter of betting the belt off/on yes? 10-15 mins?
Jeff Strickland - 26 Dec 2007 22:16 GMT
According to Napa Online, the part number you need is ECHF424, and costs
$13.99 (prices vary inside the store).
As I recall, this is the same part I needed for my F150, and is used on both
sizes of the Ranger V6.
> CRUD!!!!!!!!!!!!! I went to Napa this weekend, and they had the
> brushes in their computer, but not available in the WHOLE bay area.
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Now I need to ask........ is THIS a job I can do? Its more of a
> matter of betting the belt off/on yes? 10-15 mins?
snewman1209@gmail.com - 27 Dec 2007 02:43 GMT
On my way back to napa today my truck finally shut down. Lost all
juice.
I towed it home, and went to Napa and just bought a new (reman) alt.
to replace. I dont have good light, so I may take the day off and try
to tackle the mess tomorrow.
So far: disconnected the battery
and thats it! LOL.... Im a little worried that im in over my
head. but maybe not.
Napa told me that once replaced, I should recharge the battery over
night (or whenever I do it) so that I dont fry the new alt., since Im
starting with no juice at all.
F&^( maybe its worth just paying the $$.... but I wouldnt be able to
live with myself.... LOL
Jeff Strickland - 27 Dec 2007 19:35 GMT
While it is off, take the torx screws out from the back. The diode pack will
come off and the brush assembly is part of it. a couple more torx screws and
the brushes come off of the diode pack. In any case, if the brushes are worn
down, this is your problem.
I don't recall which motor you said you have, and I assumed the V6. The
alternator brushes are available for both V6 motors, but not (as far as I
can tell) for the 4.
Bob - 30 Dec 2007 06:40 GMT
> According to Napa Online, the part number you need is ECHF424, and costs
> $13.99 (prices vary inside the store).
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
> > Now I need to ask........ is THIS a job I can do? Its more of a
> > matter of betting the belt off/on yes? 10-15 mins?
Thanks for the tip I just did this today to my 97 F150 5.4L and it
worked fantastically, did have a bit of trouble loosening the
tensioner,( requires 1/2" drive ratchet)- also remember to pull out
the plastic piece holding the brushes in place prior to install. Or
you will get to practice removing alt again!
peace