> Ya' think? Every manufacturer has a competitor just down the street.
>
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
>>
>> Jeff
Sometimes one must conclude you are slower than you appear. Does the term "Intellectual
property," and why copyright laws protect that property, have any meaning to
you? ;)
>> Ya' think? Every manufacturer has a competitor just down the street.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
>
> Jeff
Jeff - 12 Mar 2008 00:22 GMT
> Sometimes one must conclude you are slower than you appear. Does the term "Intellectual
> property," and why copyright laws protect that property, have any meaning to
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
>>
>> Jeff
I am well aware of intellectual property laws. Unless there is a patent
on a particular part, there is no law preventing one manufacturer from
copying another's parts. One would be naive to think that copyright laws
prevent one manufacturer from getting other manufacturer's shop manuals.
I mean, you can go into a dealer and buy one.
Jeff
Shawn - 12 Mar 2008 00:25 GMT
> Sometimes one must conclude you are slower than you appear. Does the term "Intellectual property," and why copyright laws protect
> that property, have any meaning to you? ;)
After all the world's thermonuclear weapons are used all at once, Intellectual property,
copyrights & patents won't have any meaning anymore.
suemishke@gmail.com - 12 Mar 2008 00:27 GMT
> Sometimes one must conclude you are slower than you appear. Does the term "Intellectual
> property," and why copyright laws protect that property, have any meaning to
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
>
> - Show quoted text -
thanks for the ebay suggestion - i'll try it, but was hoping for the
free version!
Jim Warman - 12 Mar 2008 06:08 GMT
The ones offered for sale on E-bay are clearly marked "Not For Resale"...
depends on what your comfort level is...
As an example... one of our yellow service DVDs went missing.... years
covered are 1996 to 2002.... manuals included are workshop, wiring diagrams
and power train/emission controls diagnosis... To replace this DVD.... $3000
CAD..... Anything that Helms is going to charge is going to look like a
bargain....
Once a month, I turn three red service DVDs into frisbees and drink
coasters.... These are the instructions we all receive for these.... some of
us have a higher regard for our integrity...
Tom - 12 Mar 2008 10:47 GMT
plus the ones you buy on fleabay have in their instructions most of the time
that you have to reclock your computer back 2-3 years for their disc to
work.
> The ones offered for sale on E-bay are clearly marked "Not For Resale"...
> depends on what your comfort level is...
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> coasters.... These are the instructions we all receive for these.... some
> of us have a higher regard for our integrity...
Max Power - 12 Mar 2008 23:30 GMT
> plus the ones you buy on fleabay have in their instructions most of the
> time that you have to reclock your computer back 2-3 years for their disc
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>> coasters.... These are the instructions we all receive for these.... some
>> of us have a higher regard for our integrity...
my ebay disk is white, looks pretty cheesy
says technical information system
1999
TRUCK
no flaming hoops are required for install.
Jim Warman - 13 Mar 2008 02:21 GMT
Must be folks burning pirate copies in some manner... In all walks of life,
there are more and more concerns with "pirate" and "counterfeit" products.
Since the early 80s, certain Pacific Rim countries have been exporting goods
that come in packages that look remarkably like brand name packaging....
close enough to fool anything less than a study of the labelling...
Couterfeiting, piracy and the underground economy are costing our society
untold millions (or even billions) of dollars every year....
At some point in time, we must realize that if we are not part of the
solution, then we must be part of.......
Ted Mittelstaedt - 22 Mar 2008 09:59 GMT
> Must be folks burning pirate copies in some manner... In all walks of life,
> there are more and more concerns with "pirate" and "counterfeit" products.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> Couterfeiting, piracy and the underground economy are costing our society
> untold millions (or even billions) of dollars every year....
Yes they are, but pirating service manuals is a bit different. The
manufacturer
has already gotten paid for the R&D that went into creating the manual by
selling the device the manual covers. Unless that is, there's been a change
in
accounting laws and it's now acceptable to remove R&D costs from the
item the R&D was done for, and apply them to service documentation.
And we would see a lot less piracy from those Pacific Rim countries if our
own manufacturers quit outsourcing production to the Pacific Rim. The
real truth is that companies here save millions by handing over all the
instructions
to build their products to manufacturers in China - then scream about losing
millions when at the end of the day when those manufacturers have completed
all their production runs for the company here and simply continue running
the
same assembly line for another 8 hours and churn out another pile of devices
for the counterfiters. In the meantime, all the people who were working on
those lines here are out of a job and collecting welfare here, and the CEO's
of
those same companies here are collecting golden parachutes and windfall
bonuses for all the money they saved by outsourcing.
Economists say how great it is to outsource because then prices for our
consumers here drop - what good is that when the people who would
enjoy those lower prices can't do so because they have no job to do anymore
that pays them anything.
Ted
Shawn - 23 Mar 2008 00:16 GMT
>> Must be folks burning pirate copies in some manner... In all walks of
> life,
[quoted text clipped - 36 lines]
>
> Ted
Ain't that the truth.
Mike hunt - 23 Mar 2008 14:16 GMT
You mean like all those people buying products from foreign manufacturers,
like Japanese vehicles that are either imported of merely assembled in the
US of mostly imported parts, thus causing their OWN employers customers to
get laid off?
Why is it OK for the American consumer to buy from manufacturers who operate
in foreign countries that have lower labor costs, few environmental laws and
fewer government regulations with which to contend but NOT OK for American
manufactures to buy from the foreign manufactures, who operate in foreign
countries that have lower labor costs, few environmental laws and fewer
government regulations with which to contend, in order to compete and remain
in business and at least employ some Americans?
>>> Must be folks burning pirate copies in some manner... In all walks of
>> life,
[quoted text clipped - 49 lines]
>
> Ain't that the truth.
tango - 23 Mar 2008 15:15 GMT
> You mean like all those people buying products from foreign
> manufacturers, like Japanese vehicles that are either imported of
[quoted text clipped - 66 lines]
>>
>> Ain't that the truth.
Mike, you think it might have something to do with these same
manufacturers going to suppliers outside the US back in the 60's and 70's
which started this trend.