Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
HomeAnnouncements
Discussion Groups
By Brand
BMWChevroletDodgeFordGMHondaLexusMercedes-BenzNissanPeugeotToyotaVolkswagenOther Brands
By Topic
4x4 CarsRVsDrivingMaintenance & RepairCar AudioCollectible Cars
Country Specific
Australian ForumsUK Forums
ArticlesAuto InsuranceBuyingCars & TechnologyMaintenanceMiscellaneousSafety
DMV Resources
Related Topics
MotorcyclesBoatsMore Topics ...

Car Forum / GMC Cars / July 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Blinker works, brake light not, same bulbs?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Impy - 16 Jul 2006 17:04 GMT
92 Buick Regal, friend of mine got a ticket yesterday for slowing down
to stop at a red light that turned green for a few seconds maybe before
she noticed. She also received a fix it or else command, even though
she has 2/3 brake lights working.

Thing is, the bulbs are good, they signal, but step on the brake and
they don't light up. So I assume they're on a separate wire. Have to
buy a wire tester I guess and test them. Fuses all look good, just put
new bulbs in and they work when you signal, same bulbs light up when
you step on brakes (or they SHOULD light up but the left side isn't
working).

So, any ideas of what else it could be? Also, is it illegal to have 1/3
of your brake lights not functioning??? She was so upset about this,
she's a responsible driver and was stopping at a red light! I was so
mad, was going to call the police and chew them out, but she didn't
want me to. I don't get giving a 60 dollar ticket to someone who was
stopping at a red light that turned green. I think she should protest
it, but can't afford to miss work, etc.

Anyway, why would the brake light not light up the bulbs but the signal
do light up the same bulbs? Got to be a bad wire?

Thanks
Impy
=AB Paul =BB - 16 Jul 2006 17:17 GMT
> So, any ideas of what else it could be? Also, is it illegal to have 1/3
> of your brake lights not functioning?
>
> Anyway, why would the brake light not light up the bulbs but the signal
> do light up the same bulbs? Got to be a bad wire?

First of all you will have to determine which are the stop light bulbs and which
are the turn signal bulbs.  Are they the same bulbs?  Figure that out and then
post back here.

In Texas, USA, if it came from the factory, then it has to be in good shape and
working.  Different countries have different laws.  In your country, I don't
know.
Impy - 16 Jul 2006 17:22 GMT
USA North Dakota here, and the car is a 92 she's owned for years. Just
to clarify. And they are the same exact bulbs, big honking ones
blinkers and brakes. I'm going to test the wires. Thanks

«» wrote:

> > So, any ideas of what else it could be? Also, is it illegal to have 1/3
> > of your brake lights not functioning?
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> working.  Different countries have different laws.  In your country, I don't
> know.
Harry Face - 16 Jul 2006 17:41 GMT
I think a 92 Regal has  4 bulbs per tail light.

# 1 & 4 are Brake, Tail & Turnsignal.
# 2 & 3 are Tailight.

1 & 4 are double filament bulbs and it is possible for one of the
functions to not work while the other works just fine.

Make sure the thrid brake light in the rear window is working too.

Try using a known bulb that is good in the socket that was giving
trouble.

As far as the ticket goes that was a sharp eyed cop to spot a burned out
bulb. Most of the time here in Chicago they pass you right by if you
have a busted out light, missing front License plate. They even miss the
cars doing 55 in a 30 zone.

Good Luck

harryface
05 Park Avenue
91 Bnneville
Tim - 16 Jul 2006 17:57 GMT
check for corrosion on the sockets and bulbs

USA North Dakota here, and the car is a 92 she's owned for years. Just
to clarify. And they are the same exact bulbs, big honking ones
blinkers and brakes. I'm going to test the wires. Thanks

«» wrote:
> Impy wrote:
>
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> don't
> know.
=AB Paul =BB - 16 Jul 2006 18:51 GMT
> USA North Dakota here, and the car is a 92 she's owned for years. Just
> to clarify. And they are the same exact bulbs, big honking ones
> blinkers and brakes. I'm going to test the wires. Thanks

Since the same wire carries current for both turn signal and brake functions and
the turn signal works, it would be a complete waste of time to test the wire.
More than likely, its a bad turn signal switch.
Edwin Pawlowski - 16 Jul 2006 18:15 GMT
> 92 Buick Regal, friend of mine got a ticket yesterday for slowing down
> to stop at a red light that turned green for a few seconds maybe before
> she noticed. She also received a fix it or else command, even though
> she has 2/3 brake lights working.

Two thirds is not 3/3.

> Thing is, the bulbs are good, they signal, but step on the brake and
> they don't light up. So I assume they're on a separate wire. Have to
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> So, any ideas of what else it could be?

Corrosion in a socket, corrosion at a wire can do strange things.  Are they
dual filament bulbs?  If so, could be one filamnet gone or a filament
crossing the remaining one.  Replacing the bulbs can often correct strange
problems not visible to the eye.

> Also, is it illegal to have 1/3
> of your brake lights not functioning???

Absolultey.  Not only that, if you have more than the minimum lights, the
extras must work also. Ask any truck driver than had one marker light out
and a cop that wanted to be a prick.  Some trailers have double the required
minimum, but all must work.

> She was so upset about this,
> she's a responsible driver and was stopping at a red light! I was so
> mad, was going to call the police and chew them out, but she didn't
> want me to. I don't get giving a 60 dollar ticket to someone who was
> stopping at a red light that turned green. I think she should protest
> it, but can't afford to miss work, etc.

Lot of factors come into play. First, the cop was 100% legal in giving a
ticket for broken equipment.  Should he have given her a break?  Some will
give a warning, verbal or written.  Some did not get laid last night and
will take their frustrations out on anyone.  Can't say what the situation
was as I was not there.

> Anyway, why would the brake light not light up the bulbs but the signal
> do light up the same bulbs? Got to be a bad wire?

Possible,  Wires, sockets, bulbs, switches.  A real PITA to track down.  Had
a similar problem on a truck at work a few weeks back,  Replaced the socket
and all is well.  Good luck.
Mike Hunter - 16 Jul 2006 19:56 GMT
More likely the switch on the foot brake, WBMG

mike

> 92 Buick Regal, friend of mine got a ticket yesterday for slowing down
> to stop at a red light that turned green for a few seconds maybe before
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> Thanks
> Impy
William H. Bowen - 17 Jul 2006 02:39 GMT
Mike,

 I may disagree with you on this one. The fact that the turn signals
on both sides work absolves the wiring from the turn signal switch to
the rear of the car, the bulbs and bulb socket of blame.

 The original poster's writing is a bit unclear on the next issue. If
NONE of the rear lights light when the brake pedal is depressed, I'd
go with your diagnosis. Another possibility would be that the
connector on the brake light switch has come loose or that the wire
from the brake light switch through the harness and connector up to
the turn signal switch is faulty at some point.

 However, if ANY of the lights light up when the brakes are applied,
the brake light switch is absolved of blame.

 My diagnosis (if ANY of the ear lights light when the brakes are
applied) is a bad turn signal switch. There is a set of
normally-closed contacts for each side that, when closed, connect the
brake light switch feed to the rear turn/stop bulbs. The contacts for
one side may be defective.

 Impy, can you clarify which, if any, of the rear lights light when
the brakes are applied (including the high-mounted stop light)? That
way we can narrow things down a bit. There should be 4 tail light lit
- the one directly next to the license plate and the far outer one
(same as the turn signals) on each side, plus the high-mounted stop
light in the rear window (or on the deck lid rack if this car has that
option).

Regards,
 Bill Bowen
 Sacramento, CA

>More likely the switch on the foot brake, WBMG
>
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
>> Thanks
>> Impy
Impy - 17 Jul 2006 02:55 GMT
Surely. Basically, the only lights not working are the two larger bulbs
on the driver's side but ONLY when they are BRAKE lights. They are
indeed the SAME bulbs that signal for turns, and they work FINE when
you are signalling. Therear window brake light works fine too.

I tested the wires and the tester flashed just like the signal and it
is the SAME wire that should carry the current to the same bulb, and
the tester didn't light up just like the brake light didn't light up,
though it flashed when used as signal lights. I tested passenger side
wires too, all fine.

I have already changed the flasher a few weeks ago as she was having
some signalling issues, and it worked fine after that. I believe that
flasher controls the hazards and signal lights. There is a similar
flasher on the passenger side, not sure what it does, but I changed
that too. No go.

So I hope that clarifies things. Weird that the same bulbs and same
wire that signal for some reason don't send an impulse when braking.
All the running lights work, we changed those a few weeks ago too.

It would be super if anyone can help me diagnose this, she really
doesn't have the money to spare if she can help it.

(Oh, and the whole ticket thing I think was a misunderstanding on her
part. It only counts if she doesn't get the lights fixed. So sorry.
Man, I drove for like 2.5 years with a burned out brake light and
finally changed the thing on my car. Felt like a criminal!)

Thanks again
Impy
> Mike,
>
[quoted text clipped - 59 lines]
> >> Thanks
> >> Impy
William H. Bowen - 17 Jul 2006 03:51 GMT
Impy,

 Based on the additional info you've given I'm certain that the turn
signal switch is defective. As I mentioned earlier, there is a set of
normally-closed contacts (one set for each side) that connect the
brake light feed to the turn/stop lamps when the turn signal switch is
not set to the right or left turn position. The contact for one side
or the other opens when you signal a turn, allowing another set of
contacts in the switch to connect the flasher feed to the lights. The
contacts for the left (drivers) side are bad.

 As to the flashers, the flasher by the steering column is for the
regular turn signals - the one on the passenger side is for the 4-way
flashers.

 To replace the turn signal switch you are looking at removing the
steering wheel, the lock plate and some other small parts, the trim
under the steering column, then the switch. I'd get a copy of the
Hayne's Manual for that car (Haynes Book # 8258 - ISBN Number
0-0819-8800-4). Section 8, starting at Page 24, has the lowdown on
what is involved. A couple of special tools shown in the book are
necessary to do this job without damaging the steering column.

Regards,
 Bill Bowen
 Sacramento, CA

>Surely. Basically, the only lights not working are the two larger bulbs
>on the driver's side but ONLY when they are BRAKE lights. They are
[quoted text clipped - 90 lines]
>> >> Thanks
>> >> Impy
jrl - 16 Jul 2006 19:57 GMT
Signal switch for sure.
> 92 Buick Regal, friend of mine got a ticket yesterday for slowing down
> to stop at a red light that turned green for a few seconds maybe before
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> Thanks
> Impy
Mike Marlow - 17 Jul 2006 02:22 GMT
> Signal switch for sure.

I'm not so sure about that.  He says that only one of the two brake lights
on the side in question is not working - the other is.  That fairly well
eliminates the signal switch.

Signature

-Mike-
mmarlowREMOVE@alltel.net

=AB Paul =BB - 17 Jul 2006 02:39 GMT
> > Signal switch for sure.
>
> I'm not so sure about that.  He says that only one of the two brake lights
> on the side in question is not working - the other is.  That fairly well
> eliminates the signal switch.

Switch power is routed through both right and left, front and rear wires
separately.  Power for the rear comes through the blinker module if the switch is
switched.  If the turn sig switch is not switched the power is routed from one of
the brake light switches directly to the rear lights but still going through the
turn sig switch.  A broken switch could still blink the lights but not allow one
or more brake lights to work.
Its hard to explain.  Take one apart and see how it works or find a schematic.
They are all pretty much the same for dual purpose rear lights.
Impy - 17 Jul 2006 02:59 GMT
That wouldn't surprise me. Is that switch pretty easy to swap out do
you happen to know? Or could I just route a wire from the right rear to
the left rear and splice it in to fire up the left side brakes?
Cheaper&easiest  the better at this point.

Thanks again
Impy

«» wrote:

> > > Signal switch for sure.
> >
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Its hard to explain.  Take one apart and see how it works or find a schematic.
> They are all pretty much the same for dual purpose rear lights.
=AB Paul =BB - 17 Jul 2006 03:37 GMT
> That wouldn't surprise me. Is that switch pretty easy to swap out do
> you happen to know? Or could I just route a wire from the right rear to
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> Thanks again
> Impy

Its pretty easy to change out.  I _think_ the switch is $98 from the dealer.  But
if its just a plastic part that is broken, superglue works pretty good on ABS.  Or
a soldering iron to melt the plastic back together again.  Clean it up really well
first.  I fixed mine mine (Pontiac) that way about 3 years ago and it still works
good.  Take off the steering wheel - you should not have air bags on that car -
right?  Take off the column covers.  The switch should come off with a few screws
- I don't think that model has the clip spring, but I could be wrong.  Then,
replace switch.
If it has air bags then take it to a tech - Don't mess with it.
You might try cleaning the switch when it is off the column.  Maybe its gunked up.
Impy - 17 Jul 2006 23:59 GMT
Thanks everyone for your advice. Looks like a trip to the garage for
us. I don't have the necessary tools, and by the time I would acquire
them the expense may be about as much. Plus, hopefully the mechanic
will know what he's doing. But then again, I don't know how much
they'll charge for the job.

Anyway, I really appreciate the people in this group taking the time to
help me out. You are all very kind to do so. I'd be lost without you!
Can only find so much in a google search. Though faqfarm.com is an
interesting site.

Thanks again everyone! This group rocks!

Impy

«» wrote:

> > That wouldn't surprise me. Is that switch pretty easy to swap out do
> > you happen to know? Or could I just route a wire from the right rear to
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> If it has air bags then take it to a tech - Don't mess with it.
> You might try cleaning the switch when it is off the column.  Maybe its gunked up.
Mike Marlow - 17 Jul 2006 03:27 GMT
> > > Signal switch for sure.
> >
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Its hard to explain.  Take one apart and see how it works or find a schematic.
> They are all pretty much the same for dual purpose rear lights.

If I'm not mistaken though, aren't both left rear brake bulbs in parallel
with each other and in series with the directional switch?  In that case if
one left rear brake bulb lights, and the other does not, then it can't be
the switch.

Signature

-Mike-
mmarlowREMOVE@alltel.net

 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.