<putt@webtv.net> wrote in message
> I have 3 newsreaders on my pc and each shows the original post in 'tree'
> form. Maybe whatever reader you use isn't configured correctly? I have
> the original post and directly below it, any answers to the original
> (all 3 readers)
My newsreader is configured to not show read messages. Why have all that
clutter? When a thread is active, I can recall the original question and
things make sense. When someone replies two week later, has clipped all of
the original post, then their reply can sound dumb as there is no context
for it.
I'm in favor or trimming the original post, but a sentence or two makes for
a good reminder of what is going on. Just as this thread has now drifted,
your reply (and now mine) makes no sense when you look at the subject line.
> >This seems to be a particular problem
> > with webtv users, but certainly not
> > limited to them.
>
> That is an 'old saw'....tried and true groan and not material.
Very material - context is lost when text is not quoted.
> First off, don't deem a wtv user as not being 'familiar' with
> newsgroups....at least this user.
Read again - I never said such a thing. My words were pretty straight
forward.
> My response to the original post was an offer of advice to that person.
> He knows what he asked/posted, so I included the pertinent point of his
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
> To view the entire post/thread takes me exactly 6 clicks of my mouse
> wheel....no worries!
Most people do not keep all of the read threads visible in their reader.
It's not at all necessary when the courtesy of quoting text is extended. If
you're the expert usenet user that you profess to be then you'd know that
quoting text is a time honored consideration in newsgroups. You're going a
long way to defend agains such a simple thing.
> Hopefully our advice to this man will help him get his door open!
>
> This response to your 'jab' at wtv users/me should only be taken in the
> good spirits I intend....
But of course. Nothing but the best of spirits. Hell, it's only usenet
afterall, not a Nextel Cup race. Now that would be serious...

Signature
-Mike-
mmarlowREMOVE@alltel.net
putt@webtv.net - 22 Oct 2006 16:22 GMT
>Hell, it's only usenet afterall, not a
> Nextel Cup race. Now that would be
> serious...
Well, of course! I'm getting somewhat elderly these days, but still a
#43 fan. "We" are gonna win again, hopefully/maybe again....someday.
Great to see Wawd back!
I see ya'lls point about 'threads', but I retain my point that I was
talking only to the man who asked the question, not to anyone else who
may come along....
Anyway, I want that mans' door to open!
Dave S(Texas)
Mike Marlow - 22 Oct 2006 17:17 GMT
> >Hell, it's only usenet afterall, not a
> > Nextel Cup race. Now that would be
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> #43 fan. "We" are gonna win again, hopefully/maybe again....someday.
> Great to see Wawd back!
Robbie Gordon is going to sneak up from behind and surprise all of them next
year.
> Anyway, I want that mans' door to open!
When all else fails, there's always the torches...

Signature
-Mike-
mmarlowREMOVE@alltel.net