> We've got a 1985 Honda Accord LX (automatic) and up until Friday night,
> it started first time, every time. We stopped to grab some groceries,
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> the car wouldn't start at all and now there is a high-pitched ringing
> noise when you rock the car side to side.
When you "rock the car side to side"? You mean actually pushing on the car
by hand so it rocks on its suspension? And this makes a ringing noise even
when you're not operating the starter? Hmmm... I think you've mis-stated
yourself.
> We were told that the noise is
> likely from a shattered flywheel.
Maybe a stripped ring gear. Flywheels don't "shatter".
You can remove the ring gear from the flywheel and install a new one.
> After calling around to a number of wreckers and mechanics, we have been
> told two different things: (1) we can replace just the flywheel; (2) we
> need to replace the entire transmission. So, has anyone out there had a
> similar issue? Is it just the starter, or is it the flywheel, or could
> it be something else?
It's *possible* that
1) The ring gear is damaged, or
2) The new starter is improperly aligned with the ring gear, and not
engaging fully.
Either way, it's a bit involved. For the ring gear, the tranny has to come
off. For the starter, the clearance needs to be adjusted, or the starter
replaced.

Signature
TeGGeR?
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/