Car Forum / Honda Cars / April 2005
Honda 97 civic timing belt replacement dilemma
|
|
Thread rating:  |
savijith@gmail.com - 23 Apr 2005 01:30 GMT Hey all,
I have a 97 Hionda civic currently @112000 mileage. However, i have not yet replaced the timing belt for it. My dealer mentions a cost of around $665.00 whereas there's a nearby mechanic shop (i live in Redmond, WA BTW) who is quoting $185 including parts and labor. I am in a dilemma as to whom to go with? Could you please advise whether its worth shelling out that much with the dealer or worth taking a chance with the mechanic.
I am not a very car-tech guy, so any friendly tips are very much appreciated.
Thanks a lot. Savita.
John Ings - 23 Apr 2005 01:50 GMT >I have a 97 Hionda civic currently @112000 mileage. However, i have >not yet replaced the timing belt for it. You're WAY overdue!
>My dealer mentions a cost of >around $665.00 whereas there's a nearby mechanic shop (i live in >Redmond, WA BTW) who is quoting $185 including parts and labor. Dealers usually want too much. On the other hand, that mechanic's bid sounds too low.
Are there any independent shops specializing in Hondas in your area? Or at least specializing in Japanese cars? Check with a local car club, they usually know who can be trusted.
Always use Honda parts.
Randolph - 23 Apr 2005 02:07 GMT > Hey all, > [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > Could you please advise whether its worth shelling out that much with > the dealer or worth taking a chance with the mechanic. I quoted out the timing belt job on my '94 Civic back in 2003. Dealers wanted between $450 and $600 at that time. This is in Northern California. Your dealer sure is in the high end of that, so you might want to check other dealers. Ask the Acura dealerships too, they know Honda engines.
On some cars (like my brother's '87 VW) a timing belt change is easy, no special tools or skills needed, and easy access. For that car $185 at an independent shop would be reasonable. The Civic is a little harder, access is very limited and it takes some skill. I am concerned that your independent shop is not aware of the amount of work involved with a timing belt change on your car, and that they perhaps are not very familiar with Hondas. Around here there are a large number of independent shops specializing in Hondas and Acuras. Quotes from the independents ranged from $372 to $584 in 2003
All the above prices include water pump replacement. Most people suggest changing the water pump together with the timing belt. At least on my engine (D16Z6) replacing the water pump involves all the steps needed to replace the timing belt. Replacing the water pump by itself will cost more than a timing belt change, the incremental cost of doing the water pump now is small. If you don't replace it now, your are making the gamble that it will last until the next timing belt change.
 Signature ======================================================= A very modest collection of Honda tech info can be found at: http://www.geocities.com/ng_randolph
slim - 24 Apr 2005 01:39 GMT > > Hey all, > > [quoted text clipped - 29 lines] > pump now is small. If you don't replace it now, your are making the > gamble that it will last until the next timing belt change. Priced a belt/pump job this year on my 96 Civic...the Dealer wanted $675.
My Mechanic wanted $375 including OEM parts.
Guess who got the job? :-)
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
Kevin McMurtrie - 23 Apr 2005 03:52 GMT > Hey all, > [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > Thanks a lot. > Savita. The $185 quote sounds like a scam. Changing the timing belt correctly on a 97 Cvic is labor intensive. Access is tight, special tools are needed, motor mounts are in the way, and the belt must be installed very carefully to get the tension and alignment right. It takes a mechanic several hours or a DIYer all day. A Honda dealership with a good mechanic will charge about $600 USD for the belt and pump. I've heard of independent mechanics charging $450 - $550 USD.
Tush Smells Bush Kills!!!!!!!!!!! - 26 Apr 2005 02:33 GMT That $185 quote sounds like belt only. Honda dealers here were doing it for $169+tax (coupon price). OEM belts only cost $20, so charging $205 for the work isn't a scam. But I'd make sure they warranty their work and request the old belt back.
slim - 26 Apr 2005 17:15 GMT > That $185 quote sounds like belt only. Honda dealers here were doing it > for $169+tax (coupon price). OEM belts only cost $20, so charging $205 > for the work isn't a scam. But > I'd make sure they warranty their work and request the old belt back. Belt and water pump go for $675 (not including tax) at the dealer here in NYC.
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
SoCalMike - 23 Apr 2005 05:36 GMT > Hey all, > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > Redmond, WA BTW) who is quoting $185 including parts and labor. I am > in a dilemma as to whom to go with? ehhhh... thats kinda on the low side. personally id offer em the whole $185 in labor IF i could give them the parts as well. then id go online to majestic or slhonda and order a timing belt and a water pump. id also buy a couple gallons of the honda premix coolant, and give it all to them. dont expect a warranty, though.
if i was a mechanic, id be thrilled. all the money for labor, OEM parts supplied for free, and coolant too.
as to whether theyd use the stuff? who knows. hopefully. maybe theyd be offended you dont trust their parts source.
or ask em how much it would be if they used original honda parts, and coolant. the parts alone would likely be a bit over $100.
> Could you please advise whether its worth shelling out that much with > the dealer or worth taking a chance with the mechanic. another option would be shopping it around to more honda dealerships. that $665 should include a water pump, as well.
$665 isnt *terribly* outrageous, but its no deal, either.
> I am not a very car-tech guy, so any friendly tips are very much > appreciated. > > Thanks a lot. > Savita. duckbill - 23 Apr 2005 23:27 GMT You have already received some solid advice; here are a few more thoughts to consider. If you get a water pump failure on a Civic it might break your new timing belt and cause your pistons and valves to collide......Big Expense. So, change the water pump along with the belt. While your getting the timing belt done, you might want to consider getting all your belts replaced. There should be no labor charge for that because the belts have to come off anyway. As a certified Honda Motorcycle guy, I know dealers sometimes charge full book time for replacing the water pump even though they are already charging you for replacing the timing belt. You might be paying for taking off the timing belt twice? Have the dealer break out the labor for each portion of the job and act savey. You will pay a lot less. Good luck.
slim - 24 Apr 2005 01:37 GMT > Hey all, > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > I am not a very car-tech guy, so any friendly tips are very much > appreciated. The Dealer wants to rape you...without any lube.
The belt and pump can be bought for $75. Its the labor (and the tools) that cost you. Buy OEM parts and have the wrench do the work.
Let the Dealer suck the blood from a different victim.
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
Lex - 24 Apr 2005 03:52 GMT would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease monkey "Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite saying. i would go to the dealership to do it. is that grease monkey going change the front crank and cam seal? ive seen aftermarket water pump crap out in a matter of months.
> Hey all, > [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > Thanks a lot. > Savita. Randolph - 24 Apr 2005 05:17 GMT > would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease monkey > "Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite saying. i would > go to the dealership to do it. is that grease monkey going change the front > crank and cam seal? ive seen aftermarket water pump crap out in a matter of > months. Said the man who works at a Honda dealership.
> > Hey all, > > [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > > Thanks a lot. > > Savita.
 Signature ======================================================= A very modest collection of Honda tech info can be found at: http://www.geocities.com/ng_randolph
SoCalMike - 24 Apr 2005 06:46 GMT >>would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease monkey >>"Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite saying. i would [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > Said the man who works at a Honda dealership. LOL. he will change his tune when he opens up his own "honda/acura only" shop. and i bet he will undercut the dealer as well.
slim - 24 Apr 2005 20:24 GMT > >>would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease monkey > >>"Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite saying. i would [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > LOL. he will change his tune when he opens up his own "honda/acura only" > shop. and i bet he will undercut the dealer as well. Thats not hard to do! LOL!!!!!!
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
savijith@gmail.com - 25 Apr 2005 22:21 GMT Thanks everyone for the responses. I checked up with another mechanic who specialises in Japaneses cars, and he mentioned two options. a) For $395, if my car has only one belt. b) For $585, if my car has a balancer belt. This he would know only after looking inside. He also mentioned that i could verify whether my car has a single belt or dual belts using my VIN number.
Do you guys know about this dual belt concept?
Please respond.
Thanks again
Regards Savita
duckbill - 25 Apr 2005 23:33 GMT Savita, your Japanese mechanic does not know if a civic has 1 or 2 belts....he did you a favor with that response. Avoid him and go to the dealer. They have real experience on your car and have a reputation to stand by their work. You really do get what you pay for. Is there another Honda dealer within 50 miles that you could get a price quote from? Again have the dealer break out the parts and labour costs. Were not sure what parts your dealer is going to change? Help us to help you.
slim - 26 Apr 2005 17:14 GMT > Savita, your Japanese mechanic does not know if a civic has 1 or 2 > belts....he did you a favor with that response. Avoid him and go to the [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > from? Again have the dealer break out the parts and labour costs. Were > not sure what parts your dealer is going to change? Help us to help you. Look for a independent mechanic who fixes a lot of Hondas.
Ask other Honda drivers where THEY go.
The dealer is going to rip you for almost SEVEN HUNDRED BUCKS because "he has to".
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
savijith@gmail.com - 26 Apr 2005 18:56 GMT Surprisingly, even the dealer mentioned he has to read the VIN number to determine number of belts.....again i dont know abcd of car internals, so i keep nodding my head.......
Regards - Savita
Randolph - 26 Apr 2005 02:41 GMT > Thanks everyone for the responses. > I checked up with another mechanic who specialises in Japaneses cars, [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > > Do you guys know about this dual belt concept? Yes, some Honda 4-cylinder engines have a harmonic balance shaft. Just like a cam-shaft, the balance shaft needs to be in the right relation to the crank shaft, and thus a timing belt is used for the balance shaft as well as one for the cam shaft. As far as I know, no engine with a balance shaft ever made it into a Civic (not from the factory, anyway) but I could be wrong.
E. Meyer - 26 Apr 2005 15:56 GMT On 4/25/05 4:21 PM, in article 1114464094.614866.181000@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com, "savijith@gmail.com"
> Thanks everyone for the responses. > I checked up with another mechanic who specialises in Japaneses cars, [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > Regards > Savita Some of the Honda 4 cylinder engines (the 90s Accord 4s have it) have a second belt in the same cavity with the timing belt. All it does is spin a balancing shaft that helps dampen engine vibrations. I don't know if your Civic has the second belt, but an extra $190 just to do a balancer belt while he is already in there is excessive by at least 2X.
If I were you, I would look for another mechanic. This guy sounds flaky.
motsco_ _ - 26 Apr 2005 17:06 GMT > On 4/25/05 4:21 PM, in article > 1114464094.614866.181000@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com, "savijith@gmail.com" [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] > > If I were you, I would look for another mechanic. This guy sounds flaky. --------------------------------
Yep, he is Kellog's Frosted . . . .:-)
'Curly'
slim - 26 Apr 2005 17:16 GMT > On 4/25/05 4:21 PM, in article > 1114464094.614866.181000@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com, "savijith@gmail.com" [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] > > If I were you, I would look for another mechanic. This guy sounds flaky. Look around, see if the mechanic has lots of Hondas in the shop, ask other Honda drivers. I would pass on this guy.
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
slim - 24 Apr 2005 20:22 GMT > > would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease monkey > > "Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite saying. i would [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > Said the man who works at a Honda dealership. He also said, "Look, pal...I HAVE to charge you for four hours labor, even though I did the job in half the time! Honda MAKES ME do it!"
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
SoCalMike - 24 Apr 2005 06:44 GMT > would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease monkey > "Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite saying. i would > go to the dealership to do it. is that grease monkey going change the front > crank and cam seal? ive seen aftermarket water pump crap out in a matter of > months. sometimes the grease monkeys are honda trained. the smart mechanics move on and open up their own shops. id imagine if they dont use OEM, they still use a good source. mechanics dont like having to do jobs over for free. id still insist on OEM for almost everything.
jim beam - 24 Apr 2005 14:22 GMT >> would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease >> monkey "Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > still use a good source. mechanics dont like having to do jobs over for > free. id still insist on OEM for almost everything. using oem for honda is /so/ true - quality is very high. but if i were doing domestics, i wouldn't be so bothered as initial quality can be real low.
slim - 24 Apr 2005 20:21 GMT > would you use OEM parts at a grease monkey garage? is that grease monkey > "Honda Trained"? "you get what you pay for" is my favorite saying. i would > go to the dealership to do it. is that grease monkey going change the front > crank and cam seal? ive seen aftermarket water pump crap out in a matter of > months. There is a HUGE difference between a "grease-monkey" joint and a good, independent mechanic.
You want to go to the dealer? Be my guest. I will support your right to do so. I will also say you are nuts to bring the car back to the dealer for oil changes and for ANYTHING after your warranty runs out.
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
MAT - 26 Apr 2005 20:01 GMT Go to the dealer locator at hondacars.com and check the 'Service Specials' of all proximal dealers. You can almost always find a coupon for a timing belt special. Then I bet you can use such coupons for leverage at other dealers.
slim - 27 Apr 2005 05:11 GMT > Go to the dealer locator at hondacars.com and check the 'Service Specials' > of all proximal dealers. You can almost always find a coupon for a timing > belt special. Then I bet you can use such coupons for leverage at other > dealers. The dealer will always have the out, "I have to charge you that much".
 Signature "This notion that the United States is getting ready to attack Iran is simply ridiculous. Having said that, all options are on the table," George Bush, Feb 22 2005
http://www.quantumphilosophy.net/files/clips/TimRyan_Medium.mov
http://www.bushflash.com/thanks.html http://www.worldmessenger.20m.com/weapons.html#wms WHY IRAQ?: http://www.angelfire.com/creep/gwbush/remindus.html http://www.toostupidtobepresident.com/shockwave/chickenhawks.htm
"Bubba got a BJ, BU$H screwed us all!" - Slim
MAT - 27 Apr 2005 15:54 GMT > The dealer will always have the out, "I have to charge you that much". Hmm, I've only been through one timing belt service on a 98 Civic back in 2002 which cost me 379 plus tax via an advertised web 'special'. I checked the smae dealer site and found out that prices are up in general but also that Accords cost sginificantly more plus extra charge for balancer belt.
Includes replacement of timing belt, all drive belts, and water pump. Balancer belt not included. Civic............................$439.95 Accord (4cyl.)...............$559.95 CR-V............................$599.95 Prelude.........................$699.95 V6 Accord.....................$699.95 Odyssey.......................$699.95 Pilot.............................$699.95 Passport, '98 & newer....$749.95 Passport, '97 & older......$789.95
|
|
|