 |
 | Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us |
 | Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network |
Car Forum / Honda Cars / September 2005honda accord questions
hello all, I currently own a 2001 maxima SE 5 speed and am looking to get rid of it in favor of better gas mileage (get 23 average and the most I've gotten is about 25 or so on a highway trip) and not having to use premium. one of the 3 cars I'm looking at is the accord (still want a 5 speed so not the accord hybrid cause it only comes in an auto) looking at either a 2005 or 2006 accord EX with leather and a navigation system with the 4 cyl. engine. just wondering if there are any main differences between the 05 and 06 models. if anyone has these cars and any known problems with them. I'm looking to buy new or lease. wondering what people have been paying for these. any other info you coudl give would be greatly appreciated. the cars I'm comparing it to are the mazda 3 and the Jetta TDI (yes I know they are not all the same "class" but they all seem to have what I want around the same price range) the jetta TDI was my first choice (2005.5 or 2006) but they are in low supply and theres a high demand that dealers arn't really doing anything with the prices, basically ya pay sticker or ya don't get one (sticker for what I want is 24,000 for package 1 or about 26,000 for package 2) looking at teh mazda 3 I can get all teh stuff I want (leather, 5 speed, moonroof and navigation system for a lot less than the jetta) sorry to make this so long just figure I'd gie some background info. also in my search I saw 2 honda groups so I posted this in both of them cause I'm not sure which one this type of question would belong in (alt.auto.honda or rec.autos.makers.honda) thanks a lot for your responses in advance. -Nick > hello all, I currently own a 2001 maxima SE 5 speed and am looking to get > rid of it in favor of better gas mileage (get 23 average and the most I've > gotten is about 25 or so on a highway trip) and not having to use premium. > one of the 3 cars I'm looking at is the accord (still want a 5 speed so not > the accord hybrid cause it only comes in an auto) looking at either a 2005 > or 2006 accord EX with leather and a navigation system with the 4 cyl. youre never going to make the money back that youll be losing on the 4 year old maxima. as for the "premium" issue? only if nissan calls for it, and even then some people run a midgrade (89) without problems. if you want a new car, fine... but spending over $23k to save a couple hundred a year on gas is kinda nutty. and at least in california, registration is based on car value and goes down yearly. insurance, too for the most part. so any "savings" from the gas are likely to get wiped out. > youre never going to make the money back that youll be losing on the 4 > year old maxima. as for the "premium" issue? only if nissan calls for it, [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > for the most part. so any "savings" from the gas are likely to get wiped > out. well nissan does call for premium. can you use less? sure, but the knock sensor retards the timing which means less gas mileage and less horse power. as far as doing this to save money, I'm not doing it for the short term but rather the long haul. right now if I keep driving my car value will keep going down, if I sell it now I can get about 13k for it. and not really alter my montly payments. insurance isn't based solely on the value of the car (example, my brother drive a 2005 infinity FX35 and pays LESS in insurance than my 2001 maxima yet his car is easily worth 3 times the amount, we are twins with the SAME clean driving record). plan on getting this car and keeping for at LEAST 4-5 years. also, with my maxima there is no warranty on it so anythign that goes wrong will be my problem (one thing that comes to mind are the MAF's tend to go bad as well as the ignition coils, total cost for both of those are over 1,000) my insurance will go down 80 bucks every 6 months, a total of 160 a year. plus the peace of mind that anythign goes wrong with the car, it's covered are the main reasons I'm doing this. I can also lease a accord, sell my car and invest the remaining money (stocks,bonds, ING high yield bank account (3.3%) ext.) plus using less gas and less expensive gas. thsi was my MAIN reason for looking at the jetta TDI orignally (40 MPG) but the cost of the car they are asking (26,000) isn't worth it. those are just my thoughs. >right now if I keep driving my car value will keep going down, Uh-huh. What will happen to your new purchase? it's obviously going to go up right? ;-) I know ANY car goes down in value the second you buy it. but like I said having a warranty, plus getting better gas mileage plus not needing premium plus lower insurance are all thigns I'm looking at (when I keep this car for the long haul). I'd rather make a steady payment and knwo I'm covered than have an unexpected repair thats a few hundred here or hey with a car mabye even 1,000 here or there. ya cna enver tell. thats my thinking. thanks for answering (or rather, not really answering) my questions. >>right now if I keep driving my car value will keep going down, > > Uh-huh. > > What will happen to your new purchase? You're probably saving about $60/month in fuel & insurance cost by switching to a new Accord. In 8 years an 05 Accord would be worth about 7K while the 2001 Maxima would be ready for the garbage heap. Assuming an additional $2000 of maintenance cost for keeping an older Maxima on the road. In 8 years, it'll probably cost an extra $7000 to own an 05 Accord vs keeping your old Maxima. However, if you don't have the $$$ to make the initial investment or you prefer the capability of your existing car, then I would stay put.. (I'm assuming a new Accord EX is about 22K and cost of owning would go up if you're financing) Pars > > youre never going to make the money back that youll be losing on the 4 > > year old maxima. as for the "premium" issue? only if nissan calls for it, [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > jetta TDI orignally (40 MPG) but the cost of the car they are asking > (26,000) isn't worth it. those are just my thoughs. well thanks for the info, that is probably the first actual answer Iv' gotten on here, haha. main thing is with gas prices right now begin as they are it's costing me 15 cents a mile to drive my car. (just for gas) not counting unexpected repairs. being able to get rid of this car for around 13k (private sale) will cut the accord down to about 9-10k. making my payments pretty easy to swallow. also can invest some of my money from the maxima (sort of cash out it's equity if you will) and get into somethign newer with a warranty. plus that wonderful new car smell ;-) > You're probably saving about $60/month in fuel & insurance cost by > switching [quoted text clipped - 52 lines] >> jetta TDI orignally (40 MPG) but the cost of the car they are asking >> (26,000) isn't worth it. those are just my thoughs. You got new-car-itis and are trying to justify it with the higher price of gas. I moved from a '96 I30t that I bought new, to an '04 Accord EX V6 not long ago. You probably know that this I30t is similar to a '96 Maxima SE with the 3.0 liter. In the I30t, I got 23 mpg on premium, 21 on regular (after the knock sensor died premium gas was of no importance). The 3.0 liter automatic Accord gets 24-25 on regular in the same driving conditions. The 2.4 I-4 might get about 27 mpg with an automatic. I understand you want a manual, so add a couple more mpg. Your Maxima is about ready for noise from the starter (grease dries up), and maybe a broken driver's door latch and dead knock sensor too if you have over 80K miles. Chances of a major malfunction are remote, however, assuming you've cared for it. The Accord does not have anywhere near the handling prowess you're used to. The ride is jiggly compared to a Maxima, and the trunk is somewhat smaller. The Accord is faster, gets better mileage, is equally reliable, has a fairly roomy cabin almost on a par with Maximas (which themselves are quite large for a mid-sized car). The leather (gasp, I'll be flamed for this) in the Accord is not as durable from what I've seen of friends' and will maybe fall apart after 5 years if you don't put treatment on it. The Accord is significantly safer if you get into a major collision. The Accord 60 to 0 stops are even longer than a Maxima, which is also pretty poor. So it is a little more likely you'll need that extra crash protection. The paint is crappy on Maximas but looks great for a few years. In most colors, the Accord doesn't have the Maxima's great wet-gloss look, but Accord paint generally will age better than a Maxima's. Financially there is no question that you'd be better served by saving up some money for repairs instead of trading in. If you simpy keep your payments equal, you are financially committing suicide like most people do, paying excessive depreciation year after year. End of lecture. > You got new-car-itis and are trying to justify it with the higher price > of gas. [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > driving conditions. The 2.4 I-4 might get about 27 mpg with an > automatic. I understand you want a manual, so add a couple more mpg The 5spd, 4cyl, 05 Accord is good for 30.5 mpg (combined) and is about 17% more efficieniet them the 2001 V6 Maixma. > Your Maxima is about ready for noise from the starter (grease dries > up), and maybe a broken driver's door latch and dead knock sensor too [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > The Accord does not have anywhere near the handling prowess you're used > to. The 4cyl Accord, with lighter front end, should handle better then nose heavy V6 version. The ride is jiggly compared to a Maxima, and the trunk is somewhat > smaller. The Accord is faster, gets better mileage, is equally > reliable, has a fairly roomy cabin almost on a par with Maximas (which [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > people do, paying excessive depreciation year after year. End of > lecture. well I appreciate all your comments. my plan isn't to be getting a new car every few years. basically with gas and needing premium and also some of the stupid problem with the max, I want to get rid of it before those problems arise and I have to put money to fix it. the next car I get I'm keeping for a min of 5 years. (which is why the jetta TDI is my first choice if i can find one) thanks again > well I appreciate all your comments. my plan isn't to be getting a new car > every few years. basically with gas and needing premium and also some of the > stupid problem with the max, I want to get rid of it before those problems > arise and I have to put money to fix it. the next car I get I'm keeping for > a min of 5 years. (which is why the jetta TDI is my first choice if i can > find one) thanks again VW's may be fun to drive, but they are very, very expensive to maintain once the warranty expires. You're likely to have a lot more problems with a VW than with a Nissan. Therefore, don't even think about getting a Jetta. You might also want to consider a 2006 Hyundai Sonata. Both Sonata engines have more power and, according to EPA, improved fuel economy in the new model (power and gas mileage are comparable to Accord). And Sonatas have proven to be very reliable over the long term. > You might also want to consider a 2006 Hyundai Sonata. Both Sonata engines > have more power and, according to EPA, improved fuel economy in the new > model (power and gas mileage are comparable to Accord). And Sonatas have > proven to be very reliable over the long term. A Sonata probably is a much better car than a VW, but... major, major depreciation. You'd have to drive this car into the ground to get your money's worth. Between the two, financially speaking, an Accord is a much better choice. > > You might also want to consider a 2006 Hyundai Sonata. Both Sonata engines > > have more power and, according to EPA, improved fuel economy in the new [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > money's worth. Between the two, financially speaking, an Accord is a > much better choice. Given the expensive suspension setup, solid chassis, moditertly efficient V6 engine, I doubt the new Sonata will depreciate as quickly as the earlier versions. IF EPA is a big motivator, the Accord 4 cyl would be the preferred engine choice and that engine will consume significantly less then a V6 (unless it's one of those V6 that also pack an electric motor). Also, the Accord 4 cyl engine is good enough to go up against a V6 engine in power and refinement which can not be said for any of the other manufactures. So, when comparing fuel efficiency results, it would be acceptable to match the efficiency a 4cyl Accord vs the efficiency of a V6 Nissan (or Sonata). And if that's case, the Accord will totally blow the other cars away in fuel consumption. If I was to gamble on the diesel engine, I'd wait for Mercedes' A2 to arrive. That 1.9T just seems a little too unstable (too many clanky oil burners among the smooth running gems). Pars > well I appreciate all your comments. my plan isn't to be getting a new car > every few years. basically with gas and needing premium and also some of the > stupid problem with the max, I want to get rid of it before those problems > arise and I have to put money to fix it. the next car I get I'm keeping for > a min of 5 years. (which is why the jetta TDI is my first choice if i can > find one) thanks again if you think the problems with your maxima are bad, wait til you get the VW. crappy build quality, halfassed electronics, rude dealers. ive had a VW, and im never going back. thanks a lot guys for the help. I've decided not to go with the Jetta. I'm ordering an 06 Accord ex with leater and navi, 5 speed manual. shoudl be good on gas. also got the price tag down to 23,300 for an order. that sounds like a good tag to you guys? thanks again |
Reply to this Message |
 Sign In
 Join
 My Latest Posts My Monitored Threads My Blog My Photo Gallery My Profile My Homepage Start New Thread Enable EMail Alerts Rate this Thread
|
©2008 Advenet LLC Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.