Car Forum / Honda Cars / May 2006
distributor
|
|
Thread rating:  |
cmozoo@verizon.net - 23 May 2006 02:13 GMT There is a clacking noise that just started inside the distributor. What is it caused by? I assume I can fix it by changing the distributor cap and rotor. Correct? (1990 civic DX) Thanks, Chris
jim beam - 23 May 2006 02:52 GMT > There is a clacking noise that just started inside the distributor. > What is it caused by? I assume I can fix it by changing the > distributor cap and rotor. Correct? (1990 civic DX) > Thanks, Chris test the central shaft inside for side play. if there is any, you need to replace the whole distributor. which may not be a bad thing since the oem distributor condensers tend to fail giving weak spark at about this vintage.
AZ Nomad - 23 May 2006 16:24 GMT >> There is a clacking noise that just started inside the distributor. >> What is it caused by? I assume I can fix it by changing the [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] >the oem distributor condensers tend to fail giving weak spark at about >this vintage. Vintage? We're talking about a car from 1990, not a car from before the mid 70's. Ignitions went electronic 30 years ago and concensers vanished along with points.
dimndsonmywndshld@yahoo.com - 23 May 2006 18:07 GMT > Vintage? We're talking about a car from 1990, not a car from before the > mid 70's. Ignitions went electronic 30 years ago and concensers vanished along > with points. You'd think so. But Honda retained their mechanical systems LONG after most of their competitors. Any here know when Honda finally did away with distributor/points/condensors? I'm pretty sure the last Prelude (2001) still used this ancient setup.
Elle - 23 May 2006 19:39 GMT > AZ Nomad wrote: >> [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] >> concensers vanished along >> with points. I'm sure Jim B. is referring to what's called the "noise suppressor" at http://www.hondaautomotiveparts.com/auto/jsp/mws/prddisplay.jsp?inputstate=5&cat cgry1=Civic&catcgry2=1991&catcgry3=4DR+LX&catcgry4=KA5MT&catcgry5=DISTRIBUTOR
The same part is called the "radio noise condenser" in the first schematic at http://home.earthlink.net/~honda.lioness/id5.html
He did an investigation of this sometime in the last year or so IIRC and found an old "radio noise condenser" did adversely and quite noticeably affect performance. The site above discusses some of what he found along with my own book study.
> You'd think so. > But Honda retained their mechanical systems LONG after [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > Prelude (2001) > still used this ancient setup. Majestic's online parts site for the 2001 Prelude, under "distributor," shows an igniter (the electronic equivalent of points).
Seems like the mid-1980s Civics were using some hybrid combination of points and an igniter, according to Majestic.
Tegger has a discussion of points v. igniters at http://tegger.com/hondafaq/igniter-operation/index.html
jim beam - 24 May 2006 14:35 GMT >>>There is a clacking noise that just started inside the distributor. >>>What is it caused by? I assume I can fix it by changing the [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > mid 70's. Ignitions went electronic 30 years ago and concensers vanished along > with points. translation: "about this vintage" means "around this age". ok?
and "condenser" is the term still used in ignition systems. yes, it's a capacitor - capacitors were used in kettering systems too, but they were called "condensers" and the term has stuck.
AZ Nomad - 24 May 2006 14:43 GMT >>>>There is a clacking noise that just started inside the distributor. >>>>What is it caused by? I assume I can fix it by changing the [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] >> mid 70's. Ignitions went electronic 30 years ago and concensers vanished along >> with points.
>translation: "about this vintage" means "around this age". ok?
>and "condenser" is the term still used in ignition systems. yes, it's a >capacitor - capacitors were used in kettering systems too, but they were >called "condensers" and the term has stuck. Condensers on distributors vanished with points. The statement that a 1990 car would have distributor with a condenser is absolute rubbish.
TeGGeR® - 25 May 2006 03:03 GMT > Condensers on distributors vanished with points. They vanished even before that.
My '75 Corolla had a hybridized electronic ignition that used the points to signal the electronic module when to perform the break function. The points lasted far longer than in a Kettering system (25K miles, as I recall), as they were never exposed to high tension curent.
> The statement that a > 1990 car would have distributor with a condenser is absolute rubbish. It does have one, strangely enough. It's a radio noise suppressor and is placed in the line from the ignition switch to the coil. Personally, I can't see how it would affect spark.
 Signature TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
AZ Nomad - 24 May 2006 14:45 GMT >>>>There is a clacking noise that just started inside the distributor. >>>>What is it caused by? I assume I can fix it by changing the [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] >> mid 70's. Ignitions went electronic 30 years ago and concensers vanished along >> with points.
>translation: "about this vintage" means "around this age". ok?
>and "condenser" is the term still used in ignition systems. yes, it's a >capacitor - capacitors were used in kettering systems too, but they were >called "condensers" and the term has stuck. Also your statement that you should replace a distributor because of a worn out condensor was BULLSHIT. No car made in any year has had a condensor as a nonreplaceable part of a distributor. If a distributor had a condensor, you remove one screw, pull the wire out and replace it.
Elle - 24 May 2006 15:00 GMT > Also your statement that you should replace a distributor > because of > a worn out condensor was BULLSHIT. He said side play of the central shaft suggested the need for a new distributor (housing, at least, IMO). He added that this also had the advantage of getting the guy a new condenser.
Sounds like good counsel to me.
From what I've seen on my 91 Civic and on other cars discussed here, it's pretty usual for an older Honda to require at least one new, replacement distributor housing in its life. My Civic at 177k miles is on its second.
AZ Nomad - 24 May 2006 16:03 GMT >> Also your statement that you should replace a distributor >> because of >> a worn out condensor was BULLSHIT.
>He said side play of the central shaft suggested the need >for a new distributor (housing, at least, IMO). He added >that this also had the advantage of getting the guy a new >condenser.
>Sounds like good counsel to me. Except that it's bullshit. There isn't a condenser on that distributor. Perhaps a 76 civic might have one, but not a 1990.
I think he probably doesn't know the difference between an ignitor, coil, or condenser.
Elle - 24 May 2006 20:56 GMT > On Wed, 24 May 2006 14:00:40 GMT, Elle > <honda.lioness@nospam.earthlink.net> wrote: [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > that distributor. > Perhaps a 76 civic might have one, but not a 1990. I posted links before showing the service manual drawing of the ignition system for a c. 1990 Civic CRX. The condenser is clearly shown.
> I think he probably doesn't know the difference between an > ignitor, coil, or > condenser. From previous discussions on this, I am certain he knows the basic differences and then some.
No big deal. I'm posting for the OP's information at this point.
jim beam - 24 May 2006 15:29 GMT >>>>>There is a clacking noise that just started inside the distributor. >>>>>What is it caused by? I assume I can fix it by changing the [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > Also your statement that you should replace a distributor because of > a worn out condensor was BULLSHIT. dude, why are you so tweaked? i said the reason to replace the housing was because of a shaft bearing if it had excessive play. replacing just the bearing is possible, but the reluctor timing has to be recalibrated, and i doubt anyone here has the equipment to do that laying about in their garage, hence replacement is best policy.
and that replacement has an additional benefit because it also means the condenser gets replaced at the same time, and condensers start to fail with age. sheesh. maybe you should take a moment to read what i said before jumping off the deep end.
> No car made in any year has had > a condensor as a nonreplaceable part of a distributor. agreed, but if you get a new distributor, all this is taken care of.
> If a distributor had a condensor, you remove one screw, pull the wire out > and replace it. on the tec - td01u, the type on this vintage of civic, it's a huge pita. you have to strip the whole thing down because the condenser comes with half of the internal wiring for the distributor so the whole lot needs to come out. i'll post pics on how to do it if you want.
Grumpy AuContraire - 24 May 2006 17:28 GMT snip
> > No car made in any year has had > > a condensor as a nonreplaceable part of a distributor. [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > with half of the internal wiring for the distributor so the whole lot > needs to come out. i'll post pics on how to do it if you want. I have a back up distributor for my '83 Civic FE that has points and the capacitor is mounted externally on the side. I realize that in order to use this that I would have to route the coil wire through a resistor.
I have a soft spot for some older designs as they provided wiggle room to fix on the road...
JT
cmozoo@verizon.net - 25 May 2006 23:53 GMT By side play, do you mean the central shaft should be rock solid?
I replaced the distributor cap and the noise "improved" a bit. But now it's a squeaking noise.
Also, I'm having a hard time getting the rotor off. Is there some type of screw somewhere? I thought it just pulls off. -at least that's the way my truck was 20+ years ago :)
Chris
TeGGeR® - 27 May 2006 13:13 GMT > By side play, do you mean the central shaft should be rock solid? > > I replaced the distributor cap and the noise "improved" a bit. But now > it's a squeaking noise. Check for red dust.
> Also, I'm having a hard time getting the rotor off. Is there some type > of screw somewhere? I thought it just pulls off. -at least that's > the way my truck was 20+ years ago :) http://www.tegger.com/hondafaq/distrotor.html
 Signature TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Mike Doyle - 27 May 2006 14:41 GMT >> By side play, do you mean the central shaft should be rock solid? >> [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > > http://www.tegger.com/hondafaq/distrotor.html Tegger your site is a great help. I recently changed my cap & rotor, but didn't check your site first. I too thought the rotor would just pull off. When I figured out that it was held on by a screw, I tapped the ingition key 3 times to bring the screw into sight. Luckily, mine wasn't rusted, & came right out. I may go back & add some anti-sieze to it's threads.
On a 94 Civic with 200,000 + miles, would you recommend changing the coil & igniter? Are there any symptoms if they are failing?
Elle - 27 May 2006 14:48 GMT > TeGGeR® wrote: >>> By side play, do you mean the central shaft should be [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > & came right out. I may go back & add some anti-sieze to > it's threads. The threads of that little screw (and/or the threads in the rotor shaft) have a reputation for stripping. I would not apply anti-seize. If anything, I'd apply Lock-Tite.
When the threads are fully stripped, either (1) a new distributor housing is required; or (2) drilling through rotor and shaft so as to use a cotter pin to attach them are the remaining options.
This is one of several reasons why I think Honda tend to require a second distributor housing sometime after about 130k miles/ten years.
> On a 94 Civic with 200,000 + miles, would you recommend > changing the > coil & igniter? Are there any symptoms if they are > failing? See discussions of Honda coils and igniters at: http://tegger.com/hondafaq/faq.html#startrun
Mike Doyle - 27 May 2006 15:40 GMT >> On a 94 Civic with 200,000 + miles, would you recommend >> changing the [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > See discussions of Honda coils and igniters at: > http://tegger.com/hondafaq/faq.html#startrun Thanks Elle. I thought of that just after I posted. Off to bleed my brakes.
jim beam - 27 May 2006 15:07 GMT >>> By side play, do you mean the central shaft should be rock solid? >>> [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > key 3 times to bring the screw into sight. Luckily, mine wasn't rusted, > & came right out. I may go back & add some anti-sieze to it's threads. don't put anti-seize on the threads of the retaining screw! oem factory uses low strength thread lock.
> On a 94 Civic with 200,000 + miles, would you recommend changing the > coil & igniter? Are there any symptoms if they are failing? no symptoms from the igniter in my experience. one moment, everything's working fine. next, she's dead and you're holding up the traffic. i've had that a couple of times on the 88-91's. embarrassing and expensive to get towed home. i used to carry a spare igniter. now, since i was able to pick up a spare from a junkyard for a great price, i just carry a whole distributor in the trunk. i fitted it and marked the position so if i need to use it, it will be timed correctly.
i don't know for sure, but i suspect that my igniter failures were related to an ignition condenser problem. since your distributor doesn't have one of these things, i don't think it relevant for you, but mention it for general interest. my condenser was failing, and spark was very weak. i noticed this because at the time of one of my failures, i had to "borrow" the distributor from my crx, which had been refurbished with the newer style "condenserless" wiring. performance of the vehicle with the crx's distributor was great. since both coil and igniter of my old distributor had been renewed by this time, and performance sucked, i guessed condenser replacement was in order. when this was done, suddenly, the old distributor had the car performing like a champ again! prior to that time, i'd had to replace igniters every 10 months or so.
TeGGeR® - 27 May 2006 18:07 GMT >>> By side play, do you mean the central shaft should be rock solid? >>> [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > wasn't rusted, & came right out. I may go back & add some anti-sieze > to it's threads. Excellent idea if the screw has a Philips head.
> On a 94 Civic with 200,000 + miles, would you recommend changing the > coil & igniter? Are there any symptoms if they are failing? Weak spark. Don't change them.
What I would STRONGLY recommend is that you NEVER AGAIN attempt to crank the engine with the distributor cap removed, or the wires unplugged. THAT'S what kills the coil.
 Signature TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
TeGGeR® - 27 May 2006 22:21 GMT >> Luckily, >> mine wasn't rusted, & came right out. I may go back & add some >> anti-sieze to it's threads. > > Excellent idea if the screw has a Philips head. I hasten to say the anti-seize ought to be dabbed ONLY on the back of the screw head, and NOT on the threads or on the hole.
It's the perimeter of the head that gets corroded in place, so that's where you need the anti-seize.
 Signature TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
cmozoo@verizon.net - 28 May 2006 00:58 GMT I found the screw and have unscrewed it but I still can't get the rotor off. I can't get the screw to screw totally out of the rotor. I can turn the screw by hand and it seems like it should be out but it isn't. When I did find the screw it was partially smushed into the plastic of the side of the rotor. Chris
Elle - 28 May 2006 03:16 GMT To confirm: The screw is supposed to come totally free. Drill and Easy-Out (= screw extractor) it. Easy-Outs are not always successful, though. You might want to just drill a hole through rotor and shaft, buy a new rotor, and cotter pin the rotor into position. Worked on my 91 Civic until I ended up buying a new housing several months later. A person here suggested the cotter pin fix to me, having had success with it on his Honda.
<cmozoo@verizon.net> wrote re a 1990 Civic DX
>I found the screw and have unscrewed it but I still can't >get the rotor [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > the plastic of > the side of the rotor.
|
|
|