>>>> Conclusion: The prohibition on "flushing" is "Internet wisdom".
>>>> There is nothing wrong with a "flush" as routinely performed by
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> means what exactly? no fireball explosion? no leakage? do they
> actually monitor individual transmissions? over what period?
>>>>> Conclusion: The prohibition on "flushing" is "Internet wisdom".
>>>>> There is nothing wrong with a "flush" as routinely performed by
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
> thrid generationn of family ownership with a loyal customer base is
> proof 'nuff for me.
do they monitor individual transmissions? over what period?
> I never subscribe to much of the hype offered by manufacturers including
> Honda where most of the profit exists with "service" after the sale.
with respect, that's illogical. honda service intervals are /way/
longer than most shops will have you changing your oil, so there's no
"extra profit" built into their schedule. all the profit is with the
shops that have you spending money on excess oil changes.
>> what i usually see is it gets "flushed" with non-honda atf, the shift
>> quality goes to heck, and the transmission gets replaced because "when
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> Where did I say "non Honda" fluid?
do you /know/ they use honda fluid?
>> and don't get too panty-bunched about frequent transmission oil
>> changes either. look at the change schedule in the owner manual and
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> It won't in Texas. Dino based fluids go kaput shortly after 50K. Don't
> ask me how I know...
you mean heat problems, right? i have family in las vegas, so schlep on
over the high desert passes on the road from san francisco bay area
regularly. i haven't noticed any heat degradation problems on my
civics, and i wouldn't call death valley exactly chilly.
Grumpy AuContraire - 25 Mar 2007 05:53 GMT
>>>>>> Conclusion: The prohibition on "flushing" is "Internet wisdom".
>>>>>> There is nothing wrong with a "flush" as routinely performed by
[quoted text clipped - 26 lines]
>
> do they monitor individual transmissions? over what period?
If they weren't performing satisfactory work, they would be out of business.
>> I never subscribe to much of the hype offered by manufacturers
>> including Honda where most of the profit exists with "service" after
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> "extra profit" built into their schedule. all the profit is with the
> shops that have you spending money on excess oil changes.
Uh, when I said "service," I implied the whole scheme of "service after
the sale." That is where the real profit(s) lie.
>>> what i usually see is it gets "flushed" with non-honda atf, the shift
>>> quality goes to heck, and the transmission gets replaced because
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> do you /know/ they use honda fluid?
Yes.
>>> and don't get too panty-bunched about frequent transmission oil
>>> changes either. look at the change schedule in the owner manual and
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> regularly. i haven't noticed any heat degradation problems on my
> civics, and i wouldn't call death valley exactly chilly.
jim beam - 25 Mar 2007 06:22 GMT
>>>>>>> Conclusion: The prohibition on "flushing" is "Internet wisdom".
>>>>>>> There is nothing wrong with a "flush" as routinely performed by
[quoted text clipped - 29 lines]
> If they weren't performing satisfactory work, they would be out of
> business.
i hear what you say jt, but i gotta tell ya, that logic doesn't hold.
san francisco honda are quite unspeakably abysmal, either grossly
incompetent or utter rip-off, and they stay in business. so does the
kwik-lube place where my grandmother sometimes goes - you know the kind
of place: "your transmission fluid needs to be flushed urgently" - only
300 miles after i personally changed it.
fact is, most places do /not/ really know what they're talking about,
they simply go through a routine money-making routine while telling the
customer they're doing them a favor. and 99% of car owners know no
better [and nor do many mechanics for that matter]. to that 99%,
there's some nice professional person "offering friendly advice". and
cars are expensive to maintain - it just goes with the territory.
>>> I never subscribe to much of the hype offered by manufacturers
>>> including Honda where most of the profit exists with "service" after
[quoted text clipped - 35 lines]
>> regularly. i haven't noticed any heat degradation problems on my
>> civics, and i wouldn't call death valley exactly chilly.