>> The fellow at the auto supply said that you don't really need to
>> replace the two phillips screws. Just drill them out and use rubber
>> hammer to coax rotor off, then don't use any on machined rotors.
>
> I wish the auto supply fellow would get a job at Honda and get them to
> stop putting all those unnecessary parts on their cars.
-------------------------
Them Japs . . . Waste, waste, waste. They're a disgrace to the auto
industry the way they throw spare parts in that aren't even needed.
:-)
> > The fellow at the auto supply said that you don't really need to replace the
> > two phillips screws. Just drill them out and use rubber hammer to coax
> > rotor off, then don't use any on machined rotors.
>
> I wish the auto supply fellow would get a job at Honda and get them to
> stop putting all those unnecessary parts on their cars.
Honestly, I think the screws are just to keep the rotors from falling
off on the assembly line before the wheels get put on, when everything
is new and nonrusty and not stuck. don't most manufacturers have
similar screws on the rotors? I've seen a looooot of guys who don't
put them back when they finally get the rotors loose. it's not as if
the two philips screws are going to pull the rotor tight against the
hub through all the rust and crud, when the wheel stud nuts won't.
newman - 07 Dec 2007 00:59 GMT
You may very well be correct. I did a search and found that there is much
disagreement on whether to use them or just leave them out.
But I checked the local Honda dealer online for parts. The screws appear to
just cost 47 cents each. For that price, I'll just play it safe and
reinstall them.
Any tips on removing the rotors one I drill out the screws?
Thanks for all the replies.
On Dec 3, 10:00 pm, Al <a...@spamless.com> wrote:
> newman wrote:
> > The fellow at the auto supply said that you don't really need to replace
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> I wish the auto supply fellow would get a job at Honda and get them to
> stop putting all those unnecessary parts on their cars.
Honestly, I think the screws are just to keep the rotors from falling
off on the assembly line before the wheels get put on, when everything
is new and nonrusty and not stuck. don't most manufacturers have
similar screws on the rotors? I've seen a looooot of guys who don't
put them back when they finally get the rotors loose. it's not as if
the two philips screws are going to pull the rotor tight against the
hub through all the rust and crud, when the wheel stud nuts won't.
Tegger - 07 Dec 2007 01:53 GMT
> You may very well be correct. I did a search and found that there is
> much disagreement on whether to use them or just leave them out.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Any tips on removing the rotors one I drill out the screws?
See here for my own description, based on very much experience
with this very thing:
<http://groups.google.com/group/alt.autos.toyota/browse_frm/thread/19225956d59e45
c2/2096a6c0819cdc56?lnk=st&q=#2096a6c0819cdc56>

Signature
Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
z - 10 Dec 2007 18:29 GMT
> > You may very well be correct. I did a search and found that there is
> > much disagreement on whether to use them or just leave them out.
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
>
> The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQwww.tegger.com/hondafaq/
I don't think it's true for Hondas, but one of my cars; maybe the
Mitsubishi (Plymouth Sapporo)? had a neat deal; if you managed to get
the two stupid little philips screws out of the rotor, there were two
additional threaded holes at 90 degrees to them where you could drive
the philips screws in, and they would bottom against the hub and bust
the rotor free. Of course, by the time a rotor got so crudded onto the
hub, the screws were well frozen in, and the threaded holes were
pretty corroded, but at least it's a nice thought.
Tegger - 10 Dec 2007 22:37 GMT
> I don't think it's true for Hondas, but one of my cars; maybe the
> Mitsubishi (Plymouth Sapporo)? had a neat deal; if you managed to get
> the two stupid little philips screws out of the rotor, there were two
> additional threaded holes at 90 degrees to them where you could drive
> the philips screws in, and they would bottom against the hub and bust
> the rotor free.
Hondas and Toyotas have this as well. You'll see those holes in the photos
I referenced in my previous message.
But if the rotors are frozen to the hubs as in the example I referenced,
bolts in those little holes will do bugger all except crack the face of the
top hat.
That sort of rust which gets bad enough to hook the rotor onto the hub
seems to be something almost unique to the North-east of the US and Canada.
Posters outside this region do not seem to be able to get a handle on just
how bad it can be.

Signature
Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
z - 11 Dec 2007 16:01 GMT
> > I don't think it's true for Hondas, but one of my cars; maybe the
> > Mitsubishi (Plymouth Sapporo)? had a neat deal; if you managed to get
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
>
> The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQwww.tegger.com/hondafaq/
It's a good thing; holds the car together.
Tegger - 07 Dec 2007 01:50 GMT
>> > The fellow at the auto supply said that you don't really need to
>> > replace the two phillips screws. Just drill them out and use
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
> off on the assembly line before the wheels get put on, when everything
> is new and nonrusty and not stuck.
You'd think so, but that's not why they're there.
The real reason for those little screws is to keep the rotors from shifting
when you have the caliper off during brake servicing. If the rotors shift,
crud falls between the rotor and hub, causing brake vibration.
> don't most manufacturers have
> similar screws on the rotors?
Not Toyota, for some very odd reason.
> I've seen a looooot of guys who don't
> put them back when they finally get the rotors loose. it's not as if
> the two philips screws are going to pull the rotor tight against the
> hub through all the rust and crud, when the wheel stud nuts won't.
It's quite a lot more complicated than that...

Signature
Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
jim beam - 07 Dec 2007 04:09 GMT
>>> The fellow at the auto supply said that you don't really need to replace the
>>> two phillips screws. Just drill them out and use rubber hammer to coax
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> the two philips screws are going to pull the rotor tight against the
> hub through all the rust and crud, when the wheel stud nuts won't.
that's pretty much it. they help with assembly, but mean nothing to the
integrity of the mechanicals.