Car Forum / Honda Cars / December 2007
94 accord, fuel pump not running sometimes when starting
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Howard Goldstein - 17 Dec 2007 15:45 GMT I have a 94 Accord EX with an intermittent fuel pump not running condition when trying to start the car. I can crank it forever it won't catch.
When the condition occurs the check engine light remains on and the fuel pump doesn't run. I can sit there for up to five minutes with the key ON and eventually it runs and I can go mobiling on down the highway. It has all of the symptoms of the well-documented fscked up main relay problem...
I've worked through the diagnostics in the service manual: The main relay testing, the voltage checks at the relay connector, and the relay internal PCB repair (and then replaced the relay since it didn't seem it could be anything else even though the original main relay checked out). I cleaned up the relay connectors with no residue contact cleaner, and the fuel pump ground, and they all look great. The basic problem of course is no 12v measured at the fuel pump connector by the tank when the car is in this no-start state.
Finally it does seem temperature dependent but more so it won't happen with the car is warm, or ambient is very cold (<60F), but only when it's just right - like 75)
Where I seem to be left with now acccording to the svc manual is stuff around the ECM. I don't have a break out connector for the ecm and I'm nervous about probing around that area, *if* I could even get to it. I have a n00b problem though in reaching the ECM: How on earth does one get the kick panel covering the ECM off? Pry it off with a flat head screwdriver after after removing the weatherstripping?
Also if you've had this probem how did you resolve it? Funky crap on the ECM connector? Bad ground?
Any suggestions please?
Tegger - 17 Dec 2007 17:10 GMT hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in news:1197906337.39292 @news.queue.to:
> I have a 94 Accord EX with an intermittent fuel pump not running > condition when trying to start the car. I can crank it forever it > won't catch. > > When the condition occurs the check engine light remains on and the > fuel pump doesn't run. The Check Engine light stays ON all the time when the key is turned to "II"? That's one /possible/ sign of a bad ECU...
Check the ECU ground at the thermostat housing. Check engine to body ground strap. How are they?
<rest of original text snipped>
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Howard Goldstein - 17 Dec 2007 22:50 GMT : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in news:1197906337.39292 : @news.queue.to: : : > I have a 94 Accord EX with an intermittent fuel pump not running : > condition when trying to start the car. I can crank it forever it : > won't catch. : > : > When the condition occurs the check engine light remains on and the : > fuel pump doesn't run. : : : : The Check Engine light stays ON all the time when the key is turned to : "II"? That's one /possible/ sign of a bad ECU...
Not all the time, it goes out when the relay finally clicks the second time and the fuel pump starts right up at that point. When the problem is expressing itself it'll stay on for as long as I sit there and wait for it, sometimes 3-4 minutes after turning the key to on, and extinguishes two seconds after the pump comes on (I think II is the on position, 'll tkae a look at the key when I check the grounds)
: : Check the ECU ground at the thermostat housing. Check engine to body ground : strap. How are they?
Not sure. The engine to body ground is the same thick strap that carries the battery negative to the engine or is this a different strap (I'm stupid)? I had the timing belt and the radiator hoses changed a few months ago, are either of those attachments the sort that'd have beend disconnected for those services?
Tegger - 17 Dec 2007 23:45 GMT > : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in news:1197906337.39292 > : @news.queue.to: [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > and extinguishes two seconds after the pump comes on (I think II is > the on position, 'll tkae a look at the key when I check the grounds) If the problem is intermittent and the Main Relay's been checked out OK, I'd certainly be checking for ground problems. Correct Main Relay, ECU and ignition operation is heavily dependent on proper grounding.
When did the issue surface? Did it happen all of a sudden? Any rust on the car? Any recent collision damage?
> : Check the ECU ground at the thermostat housing. Check engine to > : body ground strap. How are they? > > Not sure. The engine to body ground is the same thick strap that > carries the battery negative to the engine or is this a different > strap Different. The engine-to-body ground goes from the valve cover to the rad support. It's usally a wire about 3/16" diameter, a lot smaller than the battery negative cable. On much older cars it's often frayed, broken or missing entirely. That's part of the reason some people have such trouble with older cars: Missing/bad grounds.
Besides, battery negative goes to the body, not the engine! Battery positive goes to the starter, which is on the engine. Don't mix them up, whatever you do!
> (I'm stupid)? I had the timing belt and the radiator > hoses changed a few months ago, are either of those attachments the > sort that'd have beend disconnected for those services? If the thermostat housing was opened up, that's when somebody often misses the little wire going to that third bolt. Leaving the ECU ground undone can cause some pretty strange problems.
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Howard Goldstein - 17 Dec 2007 23:56 GMT : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in : news:1197931832.3508@news.queue.to: : : > On Mon, 17 Dec 2007 17:10:57 +0000 (UTC), Tegger <tegger@tegger.c0m> : > wrote: : > : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in news:1197906337.39292 : > : @news.queue.to: : > : : > : > I have a 94 Accord EX with an intermittent fuel pump not running : > : > condition when trying to start the car. I can crank it forever it : > : > won't catch. : > : > : > : > When the condition occurs the check engine light remains on and : > : > the fuel pump doesn't run. : > : : > : : > : : > : The Check Engine light stays ON all the time when the key is turned : > : to "II"? That's one /possible/ sign of a bad ECU... : > : > Not all the time, it goes out when the relay finally clicks the second : > time and the fuel pump starts right up at that point. When the : > problem is expressing itself it'll stay on for as long as I sit there : > and wait for it, sometimes 3-4 minutes after turning the key to on, : > and extinguishes two seconds after the pump comes on (I think II is : > the on position, 'll tkae a look at the key when I check the grounds) : : : : If the problem is intermittent and the Main Relay's been checked out OK, : I'd certainly be checking for ground problems. Correct Main Relay, ECU : and ignition operation is heavily dependent on proper grounding. : : When did the issue surface? Did it happen all of a sudden? Any rust on : the car? Any recent collision damage? :
It started happening suddenly. The only thing done was the radiator hose change and the timing belt/oil pump. No rust, no collissions.
: : > : > : : > : Check the ECU ground at the thermostat housing. Check engine to : > : body ground strap. How are they? : > : > Not sure. The engine to body ground is the same thick strap that : > carries the battery negative to the engine or is this a different : > strap : : : : Different. The engine-to-body ground goes from the valve cover to the : rad support. It's usally a wire about 3/16" diameter, a lot smaller than : the battery negative cable. On much older cars it's often frayed, broken : or missing entirely. That's part of the reason some people have such : trouble with older cars: Missing/bad grounds. : : Besides, battery negative goes to the body, not the engine! Battery : positive goes to the starter, which is on the engine. Don't mix them up, : whatever you do! :
Oh from the valve cover to the rad support? I don't remember seeing one there. There's about three grounds brought together somewhat beneath the valve cover on the engine front/passenger side, those are nice and tight and I cleaned them up. I'll look for the spot for htis other one. It should be shown in the Honda service manual so you shouldn't need to point me to this one (wishful thinking I think! This one has me stymied).
: : : > (I'm stupid)? I had the timing belt and the radiator : > hoses changed a few months ago, are either of those attachments the : > sort that'd have beend disconnected for those services? : > : : : : If the thermostat housing was opened up, that's when somebody often : misses the little wire going to that third bolt. Leaving the ECU ground : undone can cause some pretty strange problems.
Ahhhh cool I'll hunt this down and report back this eve. Thank you for the great info and quick response
Tegger - 18 Dec 2007 00:05 GMT > : > Not sure. The engine to body ground is the same thick strap that > : > carries the battery negative to the engine or is this a different [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > : often frayed, broken or missing entirely. That's part of the reason > : some people have such trouble with older cars: Missing/bad grounds. I should have checked earlier to be sure. It appears your engine ground goes from valve cover to the left-hand shock tower area, not the rad support.
You've also got a couple of grounds to the transmission housing.
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Howard Goldstein - 18 Dec 2007 00:45 GMT : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in : news:1197935760.10125@news.queue.to: : : > On Mon, 17 Dec 2007 23:45:33 +0000 (UTC), Tegger <tegger@tegger.c0m> : > wrote: : : > : > : > : > Not sure. The engine to body ground is the same thick strap that : > : > carries the battery negative to the engine or is this a different : > : > strap : > : : > : : > : : > : Different. The engine-to-body ground goes from the valve cover to : > : the rad support. It's usally a wire about 3/16" diameter, a lot : > : smaller than the battery negative cable. On much older cars it's : > : often frayed, broken or missing entirely. That's part of the reason : > : some people have such trouble with older cars: Missing/bad grounds. : : : : I should have checked earlier to be sure. It appears your engine ground : goes from valve cover to the left-hand shock tower area, not the rad : support. : : You've also got a couple of grounds to the transmission housing.
Thanks. That has got to be the one on the driver's side from the corner of thevalve cover, goes a few inches over to that tower and then over to the frame. I cleaned those up with no-residue cleaner and did a few tightening/untightening cycles, move the tab around, etc to try to dislodge any gunk. Also did the same to the grounds attached to the intake manifold (driver side, there's an attachment point with two heavyish cables each paired with two thin yellow cables (?)(but it does go to bare metal)(the manual says those are the ECM grounds? What a weird place to bring them?)
Before I did that though I ohmed out the leads back to the negative battery cable with the cable detached from the battery and they looked ok. *However* the problem was not existent when I started doing this.
Another question please: You mentioned another ground over by the temperature housing? Is this on the firewall-side of the engine, passenger side? I couldn't find a ground wire there but I don't think I"m looking in the right place, or I'm not able to see it easily
: :
Tegger - 18 Dec 2007 01:25 GMT > Thanks. That has got to be the one on the driver's side from the > corner of thevalve cover, goes a few inches over to that tower and > then over to the frame. That's the one.
> I cleaned those up with no-residue cleaner > and did a few tightening/untightening cycles, move the tab around, etc [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > (?)(but it does go to bare metal)(the manual says those are the ECM > grounds? What a weird place to bring them?) My manual says G101, which is the one under the engine end of the lower rad hose, which is also the thermostat housing.
> Before I did that though I ohmed out the leads back to the negative > battery cable with the cable detached from the battery and they looked [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > passenger side? I couldn't find a ground wire there but I don't think > I"m looking in the right place, or I'm not able to see it easily It's immediately under the engine end of the lower rad hose. Some cars use only two bolts on the thermostat housing, with the ground cable attached to of those two bolts. Hunt around for an unconnected wire around that location.
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Howard Goldstein - 18 Dec 2007 02:10 GMT : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in : news:1197938730.15124@news.queue.to: : : : > : > Thanks. That has got to be the one on the driver's side from the : > corner of thevalve cover, goes a few inches over to that tower and : > then over to the frame. : : : : That's the one. : : : : > I cleaned those up with no-residue cleaner : > and did a few tightening/untightening cycles, move the tab around, etc : > to try to dislodge any gunk. Also did the same to the grounds : > attached to the intake manifold (driver side, there's an attachment : > point with two heavyish cables each paired with two thin yellow cables : > (?)(but it does go to bare metal)(the manual says those are the ECM : > grounds? What a weird place to bring them?) : : : : My manual says G101, which is the one under the engine end of the lower rad : hose, which is also the thermostat housing. : : : > : > Before I did that though I ohmed out the leads back to the negative : > battery cable with the cable detached from the battery and they looked : > ok. *However* the problem was not existent when I started doing this. : > : > Another question please: You mentioned another ground over by the : > temperature housing? Is this on the firewall-side of the engine, : > passenger side? I couldn't find a ground wire there but I don't think : > I"m looking in the right place, or I'm not able to see it easily : : : : It's immediately under the engine end of the lower rad hose. Some cars use : only two bolts on the thermostat housing, with the ground cable attached to : of those two bolts. Hunt around for an unconnected wire around that : location. : :
I'm pushing my luck with you probably. There are three bolts into the thermostat, one of them I can't see but can feel, but man I don't feel or see anything attached or hanging around nearby. You wouldn't happen to recall where it came from, would you? If not don't sweat it, you've given me more to poke around on and I need to put a lot more time into looking around for a loose wire under there before I bug you again, I need to get a mirror and pull it out into the daylight tomorrow.
FWIW, thus far I've cleaned and resecured G101 (above) G1, and G2 and G351. I'm not sure how to get at G201 and G301 which the diagrams show stuck up in the front corners around the marker lights. Velly intelesting...
Tegger - 18 Dec 2007 15:08 GMT .
> I'm pushing my luck with you probably. There are three bolts into the > thermostat, Then you have the usual three bolt style. Two of those bolts are long and go into the thermostat housing, holding the thermostat cover on. The third is very short (same head size) and only holds the ground wire to the thermostat cover.
It is /possible/ Honda used the 3-bolt style of housing from other vehicles, but never actually put a ground wire to it.
> one of them I can't see but can feel, but man I don't feel > or see anything attached or hanging around nearby. There ought to be, /if/ I'm remembering correctly from what I have seen. Lord knows where it might be if it's got messed up with other wiring.
> You wouldn't > happen to recall where it came from, would you? If not don't sweat > it, I don't. I'm thinking /if/ it's there at all (and it might not be), it should still be hanging around someplace close by. Unless somebody's taped or cut it off...
> you've given me more to poke around on and I need to put a lot > more time into looking around for a loose wire under there [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > show stuck up in the front corners around the marker lights. Velly > intelesting... My manual says G101 is the ECU ground, but then my manual also shows a 2-bolt thermostat cover...
Sometimes there are mistakes in the manuals, so what we're seeing in them isn't necessarily correct, and I don't have an actual Accord handy to look at.
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Howard Goldstein - 18 Dec 2007 20:33 GMT : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in : news:1197943802.54992@news.queue.to: : : . : > : : > : : > : > I'm pushing my luck with you probably. There are three bolts into the : > thermostat, : : : : Then you have the usual three bolt style. Two of those bolts are long : and go into the thermostat housing, holding the thermostat cover on. The : third is very short (same head size) and only holds the ground wire to : the thermostat cover. : : It is /possible/ Honda used the 3-bolt style of housing from other : vehicles, but never actually put a ground wire to it. :
It's really tough to see what's going on with this housing. I can only see one bolt head, another is attached to what looks like a useless bracket, and a third is on the underside below the rad hose and I can only feel that
: : : > one of them I can't see but can feel, but man I don't feel : > or see anything attached or hanging around nearby. : : : : There ought to be, /if/ I'm remembering correctly from what I have seen. : Lord knows where it might be if it's got messed up with other wiring.
Yeah, looks like I need a mirror or something and poke around with that. Times like this I wish the ancients had picked a different color for ground, like glow-in-the-dark green or something....
: : : : > You wouldn't : > happen to recall where it came from, would you? If not don't sweat : > it, : : : : I don't. I'm thinking /if/ it's there at all (and it might not be), it : should still be hanging around someplace close by. Unless somebody's : taped or cut it off... : : : : > you've given me more to poke around on and I need to put a lot : > more time into looking around for a loose wire under there : > before I bug you again, I need to get a mirror and pull it out into : > the daylight tomorrow. : > : > FWIW, thus far I've cleaned and resecured G101 (above) G1, and G2 and : > G351. I'm not sure how to get at G201 and G301 which the diagrams : > show stuck up in the front corners around the marker lights. Velly : > intelesting... : > : : : My manual says G101 is the ECU ground, but then my manual also shows a : 2-bolt thermostat cover...
As does my manual.
Pardon two very silly questions. If I've gotten everything reasonable the only connections I've yet to clean are the connectors for the ECM and the ground that the manual shows inside the cabin, passenger side, above the ECM. Can you think of any reason I shouldn't at least hit the ECM sockets and the connector with good no-residue contact cleaner in case I can dislodge potential oxidation? If there aren't good reasons not to do this then HTH do folks I get the kickpanels off? After lifting the weatherstipping and carpet I've got access to it but tugging at the panel doesn't do any good. Can I pry it off with a flathead screwdriver to pop the kickpanel's plastic anchors out of the body (is there a better way?)
: : Sometimes there are mistakes in the manuals, so what we're seeing in : them isn't necessarily correct, and I don't have an actual Accord handy : to look at.
At least part of the problem here is relying on my descriptions. I'm only slightly better with cars than I am with household plumbing, and that's not saying much.
Tegger - 18 Dec 2007 23:44 GMT > Pardon two very silly questions. If I've gotten everything reasonable > the only connections I've yet to clean are the connectors for the ECM > and the ground that the manual shows inside the cabin, passenger side, > above the ECM. Can you think of any reason I shouldn't at least hit > the ECM sockets and the connector with good no-residue contact cleaner > in case I can dislodge potential oxidation? No reason /not/ to do that...except that Honda does not ground its ECMs at that location.
And it is very rare for Honda grounds to become compromised which are inside the passenger compartment.
> If there aren't good > reasons not to do this then HTH do folks I get the kickpanels off? They're held on with metal friction clips. Grab the panel at its edges and pull gently to see where it flexes least. The locations of least flex are the clip locations. Move your fingers there and tug sharply. The clips will pop out of their holes. Wrap your fingers as far around the panel as possible to minimize flex as you yank.
> After lifting the weatherstipping and carpet I've got access to it but > tugging at the panel doesn't do any good. Tug more sharply. Those clips are in there quite solidly.
> Can I pry it off with a > flathead screwdriver to pop the kickpanel's plastic anchors out of the > body (is there a better way?) See above. Fingers only; no screwdrivers. Don't be afraid to give it a good hard yank. The more suddenly force is applied, the more effective it will be.
> : Sometimes there are mistakes in the manuals, so what we're seeing > : in them isn't necessarily correct, and I don't have an actual [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > only slightly better with cars than I am with household plumbing, and > that's not saying much. If I had actual hands-on experience with this model, we'd probably have this fixed by now, but I don't. A suggestion: Go to a local U-Pull wrecking yard. Find a copy of your model there. Inspect--with a bright flashlight and a mirror--the same area of your car on the wreck. A wrecking yard excursion will also allow you to study without penalty how plastic trim panels come off.
You can purchase fairly inexpensively an extensible inspection mirror at any auto parts place, such as AutoZone, Kragen, NAPA...
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Howard Goldstein - 18 Dec 2007 00:46 GMT : You've also got a couple of grounds to the transmission housing.
Should I expect any with a standard transmission?
Tegger - 18 Dec 2007 01:26 GMT > : You've also got a couple of grounds to the transmission housing. > > Should I expect any with a standard transmission? Don't know. Probably.
 Signature Tegger
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
Howard Goldstein - 17 Dec 2007 23:47 GMT : hgoldste@mpcs.com (Howard Goldstein) wrote in news:1197906337.39292 : @news.queue.to: : : > I have a 94 Accord EX with an intermittent fuel pump not running : > condition when trying to start the car. I can crank it forever it : > won't catch. : > : > When the condition occurs the check engine light remains on and the : > fuel pump doesn't run. : : : : The Check Engine light stays ON all the time when the key is turned to : "II"? That's one /possible/ sign of a bad ECU...
Not all the time, it goes out when the relay finally clicks the second time and the fuel pump starts right up at that point. When the problem is expressing itself it'll stay on for as long as I sit there and wait for it, sometimes 3-4 minutes after turning the key to on, and extinguishes two seconds after the pump comes on (I think II is the on position, 'll tkae a look at the key when I check the grounds)
: : Check the ECU ground at the thermostat housing. Check engine to body ground : strap. How are they?
Not sure. Is the engine to body ground the same thick strap that carries the battery negative to the engine or is this a different strap (I'm stupid)?
(I had the timing belt and the radiator hoses changed a few months ago, are either of those attachments the sort that'd have beend disconnected for those services?)
motsco_ - 18 Dec 2007 02:59 GMT > I have a 94 Accord EX with an intermittent fuel pump not running ---------------------------
Sit quietly in the car with the key in position II. Smack the dash on the left side of the steering wheel. If the fuel pump is heard to run for three seconds, the car will now start. It will also keep running because of the vibration.
Resolder the relay. (don't unbolt it, just slip it out of it's case by pulling on the harness and prying with a small screwdriver).
I was gonna say Merry Christmas :-)
'Curly'
Howard Goldstein - 18 Dec 2007 03:36 GMT : Howard Goldstein wrote: : > I have a 94 Accord EX with an intermittent fuel pump not running : : --------------------------- : : Sit quietly in the car with the key in position II. Smack the dash on : the left side of the steering wheel. If the fuel pump is heard to run : for three seconds, the car will now start. It will also keep running : because of the vibration.
Sadly, no. Relay is fine.
: : Resolder the relay. (don't unbolt it, just slip it out of it's case by : pulling on the harness and prying with a small screwdriver). :
I covered that in the snipped parts of my post :(
carepair4free - 28 Dec 2007 00:18 GMT check your car main replay
-- Message posted using http://www.talkaboutautos.com/group/rec.autos.makers.honda/ More information at http://www.talkaboutautos.com/faq.html
|
|
|