I have a 2007 CRV and it says it still has 60% oil life.  I have 5000 miles now.  How long is the first oil change suppose to go?  I changed my 2001 CRV every 5000-7500 miles.  I am sorry I cannot answer your question, but I do know that Honda is doing what they can to force us to use them for oil change.  Did you get a new crusher for your oil plug?

I just did the first oil change in my 2007 CRV and need to reset the
oil life indicator. According to the manual, I push the stick that
selects tripa/tripb/oillife until it's on oil life. Then, hold it in
for 10 seconds until the display starts blinking. Then, turn it until
Oil Life is blinking. Then, push it again.

That just stops the blinking and sets the value back to 60%.

I'm sure I'm missing a step here somewhere.

My Honda dealer says if I bring the car in, they'll reset it, but it's
my fault for not having the oil changed by Honda.