Since I stopped commuting daily and am using my Miata for quick trips
around town, after the last 15K miles, the brake pad on the left
(passenger side) began to squeal and it is now time for new front pads
after nearly four years and 25k miles. My problem is the mechanic also
wants to turn the rotors, and the front brake job will be ~$250. He is
quite adamant that it is proper to turn rotors with each brake job, and
I have heard that myself but...
He seems to have very high standards and normally we crawl across
deserts to find such mechanics but it seems so...soon for turning.
Thoughts?
Mike - 17 Jun 2004 01:27 GMT
I am sure you are not going to do the brakes your self, but when I do mine
it only costs $4 or $5 a rotor to turn. The cost to do the job right is not
much more than cheaping out is what I'm getting at. I would be more
concerned about why the originals wore out after so few miles, like a
sticking caliper slider. A do it yourself front brake job is well under
$50, but I wouldn't recommend this route unless you or a very good friend
know exactly what your doing.
Either shop around for a better deal or pay the price, but turn the rotors
unless all 4 surfaces are perfect and you are very strapped for cash.
> Since I stopped commuting daily and am using my Miata for quick trips
> around town, after the last 15K miles, the brake pad on the left
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> Thoughts?
tooloud - 17 Jun 2004 02:10 GMT
> A do it yourself front brake
> job is well under $50, but I wouldn't recommend this route unless
> you or a very good friend know exactly what your doing.
You should also qualify that by telling the OP exactly how ridiculously easy
it is to replace disc brake pads and rotors (and calipers, for that matter).
Too many people are put off by the guys at Midas or some place scaring them
into believing that replacing brakes requires an engineering degree.
> Either shop around for a better deal or pay the price, but turn the
> rotors unless all 4 surfaces are perfect and you are very strapped
> for cash.
Man, or you could pay the $17 or so I paid for each of my new rotors last
time I did them.
<snip>

Signature
tooloud
Remove nothing to reply...
Larry Gadbois - 18 Jun 2004 03:31 GMT
You should be able to get a brake job for less than $100. It will take the
shop less than one hour to remove the pads, clean the calipers, turn the
rotors, bleed the lines, and add brake fluid. Turning the rotors may not be
necessary with only 25k on them.
> Since I stopped commuting daily and am using my Miata for quick trips
> around town, after the last 15K miles, the brake pad on the left
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> Thoughts?
Dana Myers - 20 Jun 2004 04:05 GMT
> My problem is the mechanic also
> wants to turn the rotors, and the front brake job will be ~$250. He is
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> He seems to have very high standards and normally we crawl across
> deserts to find such mechanics but it seems so...soon for turning.
You'll be happier with the results - the brakes will work
better - if you surface the rotors with each brake job, but
you can get away without it if the rotors aren't scored
badly.
I dunno what it costs now, and it's a 15 mile drive each, but
my local Pep Boys would turn rotors for $6/ea last year. Call
around town; I was quoted everything from $6 at Pep Boys to
$25/ea somwhere else. $12 to turn the rotors, and $40 for
the pads, and two hours of labor, that doesn't sound like
$250 most anywhere in the US....
www.tirerack.com has Brembo street rotors for $70/ea new,
and OEM pads for $27/set; that's $190 with shipping. If
you do your own brakes, you can have new rotors and pads
for under $200 and under 2 hours.
Dana
chuckk - 22 Jun 2004 23:54 GMT
The only problem that turning the rotors can cause happens when the rotors
are turned off the car. They can turn them out of true. The Miata is more
sensitve to this than most. I had problems after a brake job by a reputable
shop, measured the runout, grabbed my manual, and back I went. It is
necessary to at least "dress" the rotors if you want the new pads to seat
correctly. In a pinch, I've done this by hand with a good flat stone. Some
mechanics also take the pads and rub them on the rotor while it's turning to
break a "glaze" on the surface of some new pads.
The biggest thing to worry about on a Miata is related to the emergency
brake, adjusters and the rear brakes. An inexperienced (on Miatas) mechanic
can easily screw things up badly. There is an article or two in the garage
about brakes that you should read. $250 for front brakes only is a big
ripoff.
Since the wheels are removed to do the brakes, re installing the wheels with
the correct torque is also an important thing to do. Forget the air impact
wrench.
> > My problem is the mechanic also
> > wants to turn the rotors, and the front brake job will be ~$250. He is
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
>
> Dana