Car Forum / Mazda / Mazda Miata / November 2007
Oil drain plug
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Clark Friedrichs - 16 Sep 2006 21:53 GMT Folks,
I was just at the Miata.net site looking for the torque specs for the drain plug on my '03. In the torque spec section it states 22-30 lbs for a 19mm plug. I have a 17mm plug, does anyone know the torque spec for that? Or am I being just a little anal?
Thanks
 Signature ----- Clark Friedrichs / 1clarkf@sbcglobal.net
M. Cantera - 17 Sep 2006 02:16 GMT The 03 uses a 14 mm ID crush ring. The spec is the same: Use no more than 30 ft-lbs.
If you are uring a new crush ring you will feel the crunch as it sets. I stop at that point and I've never had it leak.
>Folks, > [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > >Thanks KWS - 17 Sep 2006 02:25 GMT I've had the '90 since it was new. Just for the hell of it, I used the original washer over and over again. I think it finally replaced it after about 10 years. It never leaked. I'm on the second one now.
There is no real reason not to use a new one. If none is handy, however, the world will still turn just fine.
Ken
> The 03 uses a 14 mm ID crush ring. The spec is the same: Use no > more than 30 ft-lbs. [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] >> >> Thanks Chas Hurst - 17 Sep 2006 02:36 GMT There are a few instances of using no washer with no leaks.
> I've had the '90 since it was new. Just for the hell of it, I used the > original washer over and over again. I think it finally replaced it after [quoted text clipped - 19 lines] >>> >>> Thanks ron - 17 Sep 2006 13:21 GMT I can't give you a professional answer to your question, but I believe you should be safe be torqueing at 20 pounds. If this results in some oil seapage, you can always go back and tighten it a little more. You probably already know this, but traditionally car manufacturers have made the drain plugs out of softer metal than the threads inside the oil plug hole, in order to to safeguard against over tightening. Theoretically the threads on the plug will strip out before the threads in the hole, resulting in your having to replace the plug, but not having to re-tap the hole. I would like you to first get some second opinions on this though.
pws - 17 Sep 2006 17:10 GMT > I can't give you a professional answer to your question, but I believe > you should be safe be torqueing at 20 pounds. If this results in some [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > having to re-tap the hole. I would like you to first get some second > opinions on this though. Ron, from what I have seen, most modern cars use an aluminum oil pan and a steel bolt, so the threads are going to be softer than the steel bolt unless a steel thread insert is set into the oil pan, which I have not seen yet.
The miata oil pan does not have any such insert, you are screwing a steel bolt into aluminum threads in much the same manner as a spark plug into the aluminum receiving threads, which of course have been stripped out by thousands of people.
Too much torque and that bolt will either strip the threads or crack the oil pan. I had a quick-lube shop do that to a '90 T-Bird SC many years ago.
I have usually just taken the bolt down until tight, then a tiny bit more with a standard short 3/8" ratchet drive. It doesn't need to be that tight and can always be tightened further in the unlikely event that it starts seeping. You obviously don't want it coming loose, but over many oil changes I have found that most people tighten both the drain bolt and the filter far more than is necessary.
It really takes a decent amount of force to damage the pan, but those people at Jiffy Lube can accomplish it.
Pat
miker - 18 Sep 2006 19:13 GMT > It really takes a decent amount of force to damage the pan, but those > people at Jiffy Lube can accomplish it. On my '96 the guy opened the oil container with a flourish that sent a tongue of oil across my engine, fenders, and even the underside of the hood. So he restrained himself as he poured the subsequent quarts in... all without his pal having replaced the drain plug.
Second time around (after they put the plug in) he didn't splash any more oil around, but broke off my dipstick doing the final check.
If you go to these places, WATCH THEM!
miker
pws - 18 Sep 2006 22:32 GMT > On my '96 the guy opened the oil container with a flourish that sent a > tongue of oil across my engine, fenders, and even the underside of the hood. [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > miker Be careful there miker. I once implied that someone who barely makes a living wage is probably not the best person to be wrenching on your car because they are less likely to care than a relatively well-paid mechanic. I was then told that I did not understand people by someone who earns enough to go buy a 2006 MX-5 without giving up their old miata. ;-)
Pat
Zog the Undeniable - 17 Sep 2006 18:33 GMT > Folks, > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > I have a 17mm plug, does anyone know the torque spec for that? Or am I > being just a little anal? As I can't get a socket onto mine, I do it as tight as I can with a ring wrench. Given that I will generally be lying on the ground and doing this at arm's length, I doubt I put more than 20 ft-lb on it. No problems in about 5 changes.
ron - 18 Sep 2006 12:16 GMT To those of you who enlightened me on the oil pan threads being alumnium, I thank you. I though they were still made the old way. I guess my age is showing. Ron
hotclub57@hotmail.com - 18 Sep 2006 12:56 GMT >To those of you who enlightened me on the oil pan threads being >alumnium, I thank you. I though they were still made the old way. I >guess my age is showing. Ron Try one of these and you'll never worry about it - http://www.fumotovalve.com/
pws - 18 Sep 2006 21:26 GMT > To those of you who enlightened me on the oil pan threads being > alumnium, I thank you. I though they were still made the old way. I > guess my age is showing. Ron As a cynic, I would have assumed that this is the way it has been done since aluminum oil pans were introduced. Why would a stealership want to sell you a $5.00 to $10.00 bolt when they can instead charge you an arm and a leg for an oil pan and probably for the labor involved in replacing it? The estimate to replace the broken oil pan on the '90 T-Bird was over $800.00 in parts and labor, and this was about 10 years ago.
Pat
hotclub57@hotmail.com - 16 Nov 2007 09:45 GMT >To those of you who enlightened me on the oil pan threads being >alumnium, I thank you. I though they were still made the old way. I >guess my age is showing. Ron With one of these drain valves you'd never have to worry about it - http://www.fumotovalve.com/
Leon van Dommelen - 16 Nov 2007 13:01 GMT On Fri, 16 Nov 2007 10:45:06 +0100, hotclub57 wrote:
>>To those of you who enlightened me on the oil pan threads being >>alumnium, I thank you. I though they were still made the old way. I >>guess my age is showing. Ron > > With one of these drain valves you'd never have to worry about it - > http://www.fumotovalve.com/ Just about hitting something on the road. That is quite a torque arm.
 Signature Leon :) Bess :) Bozo .)
Geary Morton - 16 Nov 2007 18:56 GMT > >To those of you who enlightened me on the oil pan threads being > >alumnium, I thank you. I though they were still made the old way. I > >guess my age is showing. Ron > > With one of these drain valves you'd never have to worry about it - > http://www.fumotovalve.com/ Does that thing protrude below the bottom of the oil pan? If so, wouldn't it be prone to getting knocked off? Also, is there a way to orient the handle, so it too isn't vulnerable to getting hit? When you have so little ground clearance to begin with, it seems like you would have to be careful.
thx,
Geary
XS11E - 16 Nov 2007 19:40 GMT > Does that thing protrude below the bottom of the oil pan? If so, > wouldn't it be prone to getting knocked off? That's the self changing feature, when your oil is dirty you just hit a rock and then all that's left to do is to change the filter, repair the gaping hole in the oil pan and refill it. It's a GREAT time saver! <G>
 Signature XS11E, Killing all posts from Google Groups The Usenet Improvement Project: http://improve-usenet.org
hotclub57@hotmail.com - 17 Nov 2007 12:57 GMT >> With one of these drain valves you'd never have to worry about it - >> http://www.fumotovalve.com/ [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] >have so little ground clearance to begin with, it seems like you would >have to be careful. I can't measure but it seems to me to protrude at most a couple of millimetres and that's the spout rather than the handle, which is more out of the way. I've had mine for several years with no problem but also have very few occaisons to drive on other than paved roads. I think you'd have to be very unlucky to hit anything.
Chris D'Agnolo - 17 Nov 2007 18:18 GMT All I know is that I've had to run over at least 2 big tire chunks in the last couple months alone. Both were on paved roads and in traffic where, there was not time or space to avoid the debris. Both were run over by the car in front of me and somewhat flipped up. Not good! Ended up sounding worse than they were however, I did have to remove my mesh guard down in the nose of the car and flatten it out on one of the occasions. Could be some added risk having that thing under there but I agree, you'd have to be pretty unlucky for the exact wrong impact to occur.
Chris 99BBB
>>> With one of these drain valves you'd never have to worry about it - >>> http://www.fumotovalve.com/ [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > also have very few occaisons to drive on other than paved roads. I > think you'd have to be very unlucky to hit anything. Leon van Dommelen - 18 Nov 2007 00:09 GMT On Sat, 17 Nov 2007 13:57:17 +0100, hotclub57 wrote:
>>> With one of these drain valves you'd never have to worry about it - >>> http://www.fumotovalve.com/ [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > also have very few occaisons to drive on other than paved roads. I > think you'd have to be very unlucky to hit anything. The thing itself sticks out at least half an inch below the oil pan. It has head and valve in series. It will very likely hit whatever is on the road, including the road itself where uneven enough.
I bought one, but never installed it. I would not have trusted it even if the oil pan was steel. Come to think of it, I forgot what I did do with the thing. Probably just threw it away. Can't in good conscience sell it or give it away.
Leon
 Signature Leon :) Bess :) Bozo .)
|
|
|