Car Forum / Mercedes-Benz Cars / March 2005
Chucking out electronics - Merc leads way?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Dori A Schmetterling - 17 Mar 2005 11:27 GMT Will we see car reliability rise?
http://www.viamichelin.com/viamichelin/gbr/tpl/mag4/art20050301/htm/tech_panne_e lectronique.htm
DAS
For direct contact replace nospam with schmetterling ---
Electronic breakdowns
By L. Meillaud
Although the cars of today are generally much more reliable, their high technological content can sometimes generate breakdowns. Since they are electronic, these breakdowns are more difficult to diagnose and lead to complications in the after-sales area. But manufacturers are aware of the problem.
? Delphi The electronics share will exceed 30% of the cost price by 2010. Although the integration of electronics dates back to the early 1980s, this phenomenon has become increasingly apparent in recent years. Nowadays, cars contain an average of 40 onboard computers. These are needed to operate the equipment for safety (ABS, airbags, ESP), comfort (air conditioning, automatic windscreen wipers, automatic headlight activation, navigation) and entertainment (sound system). However, overzealous manufacturers have gone too far, integrating an ever-increasing number of software packages and sensors with the result that bugs have appeared, just as they have in personal computers. But you can't always start a car again like you can reboot a PC, in which case it remains stranded on the roadside. Inexplicable breakdowns can also occur and never happen again. All these little problems (a car that no longer starts, an electronic key card that no longer opens the doors) have contributed towards damaging the image of the automobile industry and, in particular, the image of certain top-of-the-range manufacturers who had got into the habit of offering an ever-increasing number of innovations. Mercedes has thus decided to react by getting rid of 600 electronic components in its cars.
Autosar: an initiative to make electronics more reliable At the same time, German manufacturers and some parts manufacturers have decided to develop a common electronic architecture together. The work is being carried out within the framework of the Autosar* consortium and the aim is to define common standards for basic components, in the knowledge that the manufacturer maintains ultimate control of the software. In this way, the automobile industry hopes to be able to make the electronic content of vehicles reliable. In any case, going back is out of the question. Without electronics, it would not now be possible to satisfy European standards with respect to safety and the environment. Engineers are therefore looking into multiplexing (a process which enables several streams of information to be transmitted by the same electric wires) and the communication networks of the future. Although vehicle data is now transmitted via the Can** network, the arrival of new standards must be anticipated, in particular for multimedia and by-wire applications where hydraulic circuits are replaced by electric wires (braking, steering, suspension).
Awaiting the arrival of remote diagnosis...
? Bosch Repair mechanics are increasingly well equipped to repair modern cars. Meanwhile, garage mechanics are having to tackle electronic breakdowns in the field. They are now equipped with diagnosis devices that are connected directly under the bonnet. As on a computer, they search for the fault, which is signalled by a computer code. Once the problem has been located, it is just a question of downloading new software or reprogramming the computer. Naturally, these are operations that only repair mechanics are authorised to carry out. Some manufacturers, such as Peugeot and Citro?n, have even developed technological platforms where an operator can give remote guidance to the repair mechanic or take action on the vehicle themselves if necessary. In order to definitively reconcile drivers with electronics, the automobile industry is counting heavily on remote diagnosis. Thanks to an onboard modem, cars in the future will be able to forewarn manufacturers of a risk of breakdown. Then all they need to do is direct the client to the nearest garage in order to repair the faulty component before the breakdown occurs. A dream that is about to become reality...
* Automotive Open System Architecture ** Controlled Area Network: network through which information related to the engine, passenger compartment and body is transmitted.
Des - 17 Mar 2005 15:46 GMT >Will we see car reliability rise? > [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > >Electronic breakdowns <etc.>
See, this is what happened to my car, I believe. (Not that "posessed by demons" is completely ruled out.) Whether it's because of some sensor that got wet, or simply a computer glitch, after they charged the battery that had run down, and put the car on the Star diagnosis, and cleared all the codes, the weird behavior went away. Actually, the car got "better" in that the electric driver's seat worked better than it had in a while, moving more quickly (at least that's my impression) and to full range. (Since I am petite and my husband is tall, it's an important detail to us.) Also, the radio and climate control is working properly. So far.
~Des
Dori A Schmetterling - 17 Mar 2005 18:32 GMT I saw your earlier post (E320 1998) and before I got to the end I did think of the smart-aleck reply "ghosts" but you thought of it anyway, I noticed
:-) An experienced technician at my (almost) local Merc service station has commented about the increasing problems with increasing electronics and motors.
DAS
For direct contact replace nospam with schmetterling ---
[...]
> See, this is what happened to my car, I believe. (Not that "posessed > by demons" is completely ruled out.) Whether it's because of some [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > > ~Des Engineer - 20 Mar 2005 01:23 GMT >I saw your earlier post (E320 1998) and before I got to the end I did >think of the smart-aleck reply "ghosts" but you thought of it anyway, >I noticed :-) (snip)
Oh, dear... I've got one of these... (1998 E320)
Not entirely happy with the electrics. On very cold days, often long after starting and warming up, the "fuel tank low" flasher comes on, even though he needle and actual fuel level is way up. To fix it, I have to stop, park, switch off engine (key fully to the left), and then restart.
Also, randomly the ventilating fan speeds up to full for just a second or two then drops to proper speed. Very odd! BTW, I had to have this fan replaced recently (67,000 km) due to a failure of the controller output DC driver transistor - I'm told you can't buy it separately. Cost = arm and a leg! Value of transistor: 50 cents, but not sold separately. Does anyone want a perfect fan unit? (Motor, fanwheel and housing.) Email me at: "analogdino 'at' rogers 'dot' com" For those keeping score, would I buy another MB? Sorry, no (and I've driven them for 15 years.)
Cheers, Roger Toronto, Canada.
> An experienced technician at my (almost) local Merc service station > has commented about the increasing problems with increasing [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] >> >> ~Des greek_philosophizer - 20 Mar 2005 15:25 GMT > BTW, I had to have this > fan replaced recently (67,000 km) due to a failure of the controller > output DC driver transistor - I'm told you can't buy it separately. > Cost = arm and a leg! Value of transistor: 50 cents, but not sold > separately. Someday when a bulb burns out we will have to replace the car.
.
 Signature Nothing is the way it is because that is the way it has to be.
1 HP = 745.69987158227022 Watts 1 PS = 735.49875 Watts
http://www.publicdebt.treas.gov/opd/opdpenny.htm - Current national debt On November 02, 2004 the USA National Debt was $7,429,582,471,118.88 On February 24, 2005 the USA National Debt was $7,717,009,809,507.08 , up 288 billion in the 3 months and 22 days since the last Presidential election.
http://www.ips-dc.org - The nation's oldest multi-issue progressive think tank.
http://brookings.edu - Writing, and speaking about the major challenges and opportunities facing the United States and the world.
http://www.carnegieendowment.org - Dedicated to advancing cooperation between nations and promoting active international engagement by the United States.
http://www.cannabisnews.com - Stay abreast of marijuana news.
http://www.norml.com - Support marijuana legalization by becoming a member of NORML.
http://www.mpp.org - Support marijuana legalization by becoming a member of MPP.
http://narconews.com - Learn about the South of the Border drug war.
FOUR MORE YEARS to a 10 trillion dollar national debt! ( $10,000,000,000,000.00 )!
FOUR MORE YEARS until 20% of the federal budget is interest payments on the debt!
.
pool man - 21 Mar 2005 03:49 GMT and you wonder what the next smart bomb is going to hit.
BEEMER
OR
the MB <oops> CHRYSLER look a likes
AM only please with the WONDER BAR <any body recall those>?
the case, minus a few cans!
T.G. Lambach - 18 Mar 2005 04:59 GMT Sunday's NY Times had an article about all the antennas that upscale cars carry. It's a wonder (to me) that all this stuff works at all!
Their example is an S Class M-B which can carry up to 18 antennas!
AM-FM Radio - in the windshield Radar cruise control - in the grill Keyless Go - an antenna in each door and the console Satellite Radio - in roof Navigation & Cellphone (combined) above rear window Tire Pressure Monitor - one at each wheel + spare Emergency notification system & GPS - left rear bumper + left rear door Parktronic - inside bumpers TV in roof panel
The higher the technology the greater the obsolescence (and depreciation).
As these cars age the DIY owner won't need wrenches but rather an electrical engineering degree!
|
|
|