> Just changed my clubman (1980) starter motor and thought I would just
> turn the key and go but all I get is a click and nothing.
I'm assuming this is the older type Lucas M35 starter with the bendix
drive, not the newer type pre-engaged starter. Does the starter motor
even "whir" feebly?
> I know the starter is okay and the solenoid was working before I
> changed starter motor. Can anybody advise what might be the problem.
Two possibilities:
A) The starter motor is faulty.
You say you know it is OK, but can you tell us a little more about how
you know this, just in case you've missed something? From your
description so far though I think the problem will be:
B) The starter motor is not getting adequate voltage and current.
B-1) Battery is near flat. Solenoid will click, but starter may not
turn.
B-2) The wiring is faulty or incomplete.
The starter can hardly fail to be earthed to the motor! Is the motor
properly earthed to the body? Did you remove the earth strap whilst
replacing the starter motor?
Is the cable from the solenoid to the starter correctly connected at
both ends?
Have you checked for 12V present at the starter motor terminal when you
try to start?
Robert Picknell - 26 Jan 2004 13:50 GMT
I only disconnected battery then undid starter motor cable, then took bolts
out to remove starter motor.
As per friendly haynes manual.
Starter motor has been checked by local garage.
Just had my other starter motor refurbished but still no joy just a click
from solenoid and nothing after. Will look at wiring and earth. Hopefully
will be as simple as this.
> > Just changed my clubman (1980) starter motor and thought I would just
> > turn the key and go but all I get is a click and nothing.
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
> Have you checked for 12V present at the starter motor terminal when you
> try to start?
Graham W - 26 Jan 2004 14:31 GMT
> I only disconnected battery then undid starter motor cable, then took
> bolts out to remove starter motor.
> As per friendly haynes manual.
> Starter motor has been checked by local garage.
> Just had my other starter motor refurbished but still no joy just a
> click from solenoid and nothing after.
That should have been a warning that the starter wasn't the problem in
the first place!
> Will look at wiring and earth. Hopefully will be as simple as this.
I would suggest that if the wiring is OK and neither starter is working
then the solenoid is probably not closing properly. Check for voltage
present on the heavy terminal which connects to the starter when you
turn the key.
> Graham wrote:
> > Have you checked for 12V present at the starter motor terminal when
> > you try to start?
Robert Picknell - 26 Jan 2004 15:46 GMT
Yes it appears Solenoid is the problem.
Thanks for help its easier when you have some good advice.
> > I only disconnected battery then undid starter motor cable, then took
> > bolts out to remove starter motor.
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> > > Have you checked for 12V present at the starter motor terminal when
> > > you try to start?