>ATF or gear oil should be changed every 60k. Don't pay the extra money
>for a 'flush'.
My mechanic says to always do the ATF flush, otherwise you are only
changing about 2/3 of the fluid. Any other opinions?

Signature
Steve Green
mike w - 02 Mar 2007 21:52 GMT
>>ATF or gear oil should be changed every 60k. Don't pay the extra money
>>for a 'flush'.
>
> My mechanic says to always do the ATF flush, otherwise you are only
> changing about 2/3 of the fluid. Any other opinions?
I agree that an ATF drain and fill is about worthless, especially since
the filter is about impossible to replace and rarely ever done. It
replaces less than 1/2 of the fluid, whereas the flush should remove it ALL.
-mike
David Geesaman - 02 Mar 2007 22:45 GMT
>> ATF or gear oil should be changed every 60k. Don't pay the extra money
>> for a 'flush'.
>>
> My mechanic says to always do the ATF flush, otherwise you are only
> changing about 2/3 of the fluid. Any other opinions?
When I do a drain/replace I do change the complete fluid. I also drop
the pan and change the filter if it's accessible. Each car is a little
different, but there is generally a simple procedure where you can push
thru 100% of the old fluid out of the torque converter and tranny
cooler. Even if you don't know that procedure, getting 2/3 of it
changed is still a substantial improvement.
I don't advocate those 'power flush' things where they try to blast out
every bit of grit in the tranny. That's the waste of money I suggest
you avoid.
Dave
JimV - 02 Mar 2007 22:52 GMT
>>> ATF or gear oil should be changed every 60k. Don't pay the extra
>>> money for a 'flush'.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Dave
There is not usually an "easy procedure" to get all the fluid out. If
you just drain the pan you are only getting about a third of it.
David Geesaman - 03 Mar 2007 02:25 GMT
>>>> ATF or gear oil should be changed every 60k. Don't pay the extra
>>>> money for a 'flush'.
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> There is not usually an "easy procedure" to get all the fluid out. If
> you just drain the pan you are only getting about a third of it.
Pull plug; drain converter. Pull cooler return line, run engine (need a
helper), stop engine when it stops. Pull pan, change filter, refill.
It's a very reasonable DIY on the car and truck I've maintenanced. And
it clears 100% of the fluid.
Dave
JimV - 03 Mar 2007 03:43 GMT
>>>>> ATF or gear oil should be changed every 60k. Don't pay the extra
>>>>> money for a 'flush'.
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
>
> Dave
Except for there's no converter drain plug. Plus the fact that most
people wouldn't know which line is the return, and would likely damage
it by running it dry. Most people should pay for the flush.