I may have been mistaken about the 'singing' noise in my '93 Sentra.
Simply rolling down the driver's side window has added a new dimension
to the problem. Let me know what you think of this:
At low speed -- 20 miles per hour or less -- there is definitely a
metallic "swashing" noise. By that, I mean it sounds like a steel brush
scraping sheet metal with each turn of the wheel or axle. It's not
always there, but when it is, it sounds like hell.
I thought I was lucky to get the axles replaced a week ago for $275 (my
parts), but now I wonder if I should even go back to that mechanic to
have him check out the noise. Originally he quoted $650 to replace axles
(supplied), thermostat (supplied), and two rear wheel cylinders, change
the fluids, and do... eh... something to the transmission (5-speed).
Can't remember. Basically a 50,000 mile maintenance. Yes, it has only
52,000 miles on it.
I balked at the cost, but the axles were an emergency repair, so he
charged $275 for labor to replace them and do an alignment. He also said
the thermostat job required a "special tool," so he couldn't do that. I
have not had the chance to even get under the car to see if something's
wrapped around the axle.
Ratcheting noise from the failing CV joints wasn't as bad as the noises
it has now. I.E., the Sentra he returned to me has more noises than the
car I gave him. Do you suppose the 'special tool' he mentioned might be
one used to screw a customer who can't/won't fork over $650 all at once?
I apologize if I sound meanly suspicious, but I can't believe that he
could get this result on a job many amateurs do easily.
D. - 10 Mar 2008 21:42 GMT
i'd junk the f.cking thing and give us all a break!
DemoDisk - 10 Mar 2008 23:53 GMT
> i'd junk the f.cking thing and give us all a break!
Aw. Does oo need a break?
al - 11 Mar 2008 01:11 GMT
> i'd junk the f.cking thing and give us all a break!
Sounds like a classic case of the splash shield behind the caliper
getting bent and rubbing against the rotor. You ought to be able to
remove the tire, turn the wheel by hand and see it rubbing. Good
luck. Al
DemoDisk - 11 Mar 2008 05:16 GMT
On Mar 10, 4:42 pm, "D." <wdst...@sover.net> wrote:
> i'd junk the f.cking thing and give us all a break!
Sounds like a classic case of the splash shield behind the caliper
getting bent and rubbing against the rotor. You ought to be able to
remove the tire, turn the wheel by hand and see it rubbing. Good
luck. Al
Thanks, Al. Is the problem easily solved by just bending it back?
Andrew Chaplin - 11 Mar 2008 10:11 GMT
> On Mar 10, 4:42 pm, "D." <wdst...@sover.net> wrote:
>> i'd junk the f.cking thing and give us all a break!
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> Thanks, Al. Is the problem easily solved by just bending it back?
Generally, yes. If the part it is intended to protect is covered, if it is not
in contact with any moving part, and if it is properly secured, it doesn't
matter what colour or shape it is, it can do its job.

Signature
Andrew Chaplin
SIT MIHI GLADIUS SICUT SANCTO MARTINO
(If you're going to e-mail me, you'll have to get "yourfinger." out.)
DemoDisk - 11 Mar 2008 21:43 GMT
On Mar 10, 4:42 pm, "D." <wdst...@sover.net> wrote:
> i'd junk the f.cking thing and give us all a break!
Sounds like a classic case of the splash shield behind the caliper
getting bent and rubbing against the rotor. You ought to be able to
remove the tire, turn the wheel by hand and see it rubbing. Good
luck. Al
Hi, Al. You were right!
I went by the place at just the right time and the mechanic didn't have
to drive it more than 50 feet before he knew the brake backing plate was
the problem.
Thanks to you, Andrew, and AS for the ideas you offered.
al - 12 Mar 2008 02:22 GMT
> On Mar 10, 4:42 pm, "D." <wdst...@sover.net> wrote:
>
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> Thanks to you, Andrew, and AS for the ideas you offered.
Thanks for letting us know how it came out. That splash shield can
get bent surprisingly easily. After any brake work or anything
involving the wheels, once everything is back together again and
before mounting the tire, it's good practice to rotate the wheel by
hand several times while watching and listening. Al
DemoDisk - 12 Mar 2008 04:30 GMT
> I may have been mistaken about the 'singing' noise in my '93 Sentra.
> Simply rolling down the driver's side window has added a new dimension
[quoted text clipped - 26 lines]
> I apologize if I sound meanly suspicious, but I can't believe that he
> could get this result on a job many amateurs do easily.
Ahh, forget about my rant in the foregoing post. It's just that I
really have had problems in the past with people unable to do what
you're paying them for. This mechanic really seems like a good sort and
fixed the problem easily, no complaints.
speedy - 30 Mar 2008 02:56 GMT
While he may be a good sort he was still CARELESS, and if you use him
again he needs to be reminded of his carelessness.
-SP
> "DemoDisk" <packrat@nospam.com> wrote in message
> Ahh, forget about my rant in the foregoing post. It's just that I
> really have had problems in the past with people unable to do what
> you're paying them for. This mechanic really seems like a good sort and
> fixed the problem easily, no complaints.