Car Forum / Porsche / Porsche Cars / June 2004
944 oil use
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Alan Keen - 10 May 2004 05:58 GMT Is it normal for a 1986 non turbo 944 to burn 1/2 - 1 quarter of synthetic oil over a period of 5,000 miles?
Alan Keen - 10 May 2004 06:11 GMT > Is it normal for a 1986 non turbo 944 to burn 1/2 - 1 quarter of synthetic > oil over a period of 5,000 miles? sorry I meant quart, not quarter.
doug - 10 May 2004 06:33 GMT by the book, "normal" comsumption is "up to 1.5 liter per 1000km, yours falls into the very good category.., mine ran about 1 qt per 2500 miles.
Doug C ('86 NA, 87 Turbo)
> > [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > > Bill - 10 May 2004 19:27 GMT > by the book, "normal" comsumption is "up to 1.5 liter per 1000km, yours > falls into the very good category.., mine ran about 1 qt per 2500 miles.
> Alan Keen wrote:
>>>Is it normal for a 1986 non turbo 944 to burn 1/2 - 1 quarter of synthetic >>>oil over a period of 5,000 miles? >>sorry I meant quart, not quarter. I have a 1983 that I purchased new in Apr 83 and I have never had to add a drop of oil and I have put some hard miles on it. Every Porsche I had before this one did use a little oil. I considered a quart every 1,500 miles normal for a 356. A quart every 2,500 miles normal for a 68 911. A quart every 1,500 miles for a 76 turbo without hard driving.
Jack D. Russell, Sr. - 11 May 2004 00:31 GMT ======================================================================== * Reply by Jack D. Russell, Sr. <jackru$$ell2@notmail.com> * Newsgroup: alt.autos.porsche.944,alt.autos.porsche * From: "Bill" <william.loftin@verizon.net> * Date: Mon, 10 May 2004 18:27:21 GMT * Subj: Re: 944 oil use ======================================================================== ==
B> doug wrote: D>> by the book, "normal" comsumption is "up to 1.5 liter per 1000km, D>> yours falls into the very good category.., mine ran about 1 qt per D>> 2500 miles.
FL>> Alan Keen wrote:
B> I have a 1983 that I purchased new in Apr 83 and I have never had to B> add a drop of oil and I have put some hard miles on it. B> Every Porsche I had before this one did use a little oil. I B> considered a quart every 1,500 miles normal for a 356. A quart every B> 2,500 miles normal for a 68 911. A quart every 1,500 miles for a 76 B> turbo without hard driving.
And...just a FYI...My 1987 944 N/A (122K miles) has never used or leaked any oil at all. It's usually my daily driver too.
 Signature Jack
D Corley - 11 May 2004 18:14 GMT Not to be a cynic , but statements like "never used any oil", etc... are meaningless if you follow any sort of oil change cycle....
Assuming that you (or your mechanic) are like the rest of us, and slide a container under the drain plug and let it all drain out, replace the oil filter and then refill with the full 6 qts...
Short of measuring what you drain out (and even then that value will show less coming out then went in) one cannot determine how much oil was consumed.
There is no way to get around it.... EVERY engine will use oil as it burns what was left on the cylinder wall as the piston goes down, and on the valve stems as the valves go up and down etc.. and what oil vapor get cycled into the intake and burned from the crankcase pressure relief syatem...
The only issue is how close the tolerances are to perfect and how good the interface between the sliding surfaces and the oil seals are....
Point is that if you check your oil at each fillup and do not have to add any to stay within the marks, with a 3-5K oil change cycle; then you are doing much better then Porsche notes in their workshop manual. I know what mine was as I did have to add oil between changes.
my 2.5 cents worth.....
DC
> ======================================================================== > * Reply by Jack D. Russell, Sr. <jackru$$ell2@notmail.com> [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > And...just a FYI...My 1987 944 N/A (122K miles) has never used or leaked > any oil at all. It's usually my daily driver too. Dave Ryman - 11 May 2004 18:54 GMT D Corley <drcorley@pacbell.net> wrote in news:qS7oc.106$ha7.9346@nntp1- sf.pbi.net:
> Not to be a cynic , but statements like "never used any oil", etc... are > meaningless if you follow any sort of oil change cycle.... [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > > DC ========================================================================
>> * Reply by Jack D. Russell, Sr. <jackru$$ell2@notmail.com> >> * Newsgroup: alt.autos.porsche.944,alt.autos.porsche >> * From: "Bill" <william.loftin@verizon.net> >> * Date: Mon, 10 May 2004 18:27:21 GMT >> * Subj: Re: 944 oil use ========================================================================
>> == >> [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] >> And...just a FYI...My 1987 944 N/A (122K miles) has never used or leaked >> any oil at all. It's usually my daily driver too. Except, of course, when you're burning significant amounts of oil, your oil pressure light comes on periodically between services, and half a litre (or so) has to be added.
 Signature Regards, Dave
dave_ryman@hotmailNOSPAM.com http://welcome.to/daves.website http://travel.to/formula.one
Jack D. Russell, Sr. - 12 May 2004 10:28 GMT ======================================================================== * Reply by Jack D. Russell, Sr. <jackru$$ell2@notmail.com> * Newsgroup: alt.autos.porsche.944,alt.autos.porsche * From: "D Corley" <drcorley@pacbell.net> * Date: Tue, 11 May 2004 10:14:59 -0700 * Subj: Re: 944 oil use ==========================================================================
D> Not to be a cynic , but statements like "never used any oil", etc... D> are meaningless if you follow any sort of oil change cycle....
D> Assuming that you (or your mechanic) are like the rest of us, and D> slide a container under the drain plug and let it all drain out, D> replace the oil filter and then refill with the full 6 qts...
D> Short of measuring what you drain out (and even then that value will D> show less coming out then went in) one cannot determine how much oil D> was consumed.
D> There is no way to get around it.... EVERY engine will use oil as it D> burns what was left on the cylinder wall as the piston goes down, D> and on the valve stems as the valves go up and down etc.. and what D> oil vapor get cycled into the intake and burned from the crankcase D> pressure relief syatem...
D> The only issue is how close the tolerances are to perfect and how D> good the interface between the sliding surfaces and the oil seals D> are....
D> Point is that if you check your oil at each fillup and do not have D> to add any to stay within the marks, with a 3-5K oil change cycle; D> then you are doing much better then Porsche notes in their workshop D> manual. I know what mine was as I did have to add oil between D> changes.
D> my 2.5 cents worth.....
D> DC
D> Jack D. Russell, Sr. wrote: FL>> ================================================================== FL>> * Reply by Jack D. Russell, Sr. <jackru$$ell2@notmail.com> FL>> * Newsgroup: alt.autos.porsche.944,alt.autos.porsche FL>> * From: "Bill" <william.loftin@verizon.net> FL>> * Date: Mon, 10 May 2004 18:27:21 GMT FL>> * Subj: Re: 944 oil use FL>> ================================================================== FL>> == FL>> FL>> And...just a FYI...My 1987 944 N/A (122K miles) has never used or FL>> leaked any oil at all. It's usually my daily driver too.
All I can say in reply is... My oil level between changes (3K) doesn't change or vary from the top mark...ever. There are no leaks visible (seals done with each timing belt change) and my oil pressure is, and always has been good. Now use Castrol 10w40, high mileage formulation. I've used Castrol 10w40 since I bought the car. I also have been adding a bottle of Prolong® engine treatment every year since it came out. To me...that means my car doesn't leak or burn any oil at all. It does use oil for it's intended purpose. (Lubrication/cooling/cleaning). ;) That better?
 Signature Jack
william_b_noble - 11 May 2004 05:23 GMT 1. a vertical cylinder engine won't emit the "PUFF" of oil at starting that the horizontally opposed engines do 2. water cooling means more stable temperature, hence tighter bore and ring tolerances, hence better seals particularly at cold temp 3. the engine is easier to seal than the horizontally ooposed ones, so less leakage 4. lower overall oil temp, I'd theorize, since oil is not a primary means of cooling the car, hence less evaporation
that said, burning or losing a quart on 5K miles is not an issue. With my 944, which I put 250K miles on, I'd change the oil every 5K, used regular cheap oil, at the 250K mark it might use a quart or two in that distance - I have the records somewhre if it would be helpful. Don't worry about it
> > by the book, "normal" comsumption is "up to 1.5 liter per 1000km, yours > > falls into the very good category.., mine ran about 1 qt per 2500 miles. [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > normal for a 68 911. A quart every 1,500 miles for a 76 turbo without > hard driving. John Rankin - 29 Jun 2004 20:54 GMT Seems to me it is normal to burn a quart in ONE thousand miles. My 924S (same engine) has done so since it was about three years old (at least it SEEMS like that long), and continues to run like a dream. John Rankin
> Is it normal for a 1986 non turbo 944 to burn 1/2 - 1 quarter of synthetic > oil over a period of 5,000 miles?
|
|
|