Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / RVs / November 2005
Slide-in Camper weight question
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Charles - 27 Nov 2005 22:38 GMT We recently got a 2001 Dodge 2500 Cummins TD quad cab long bed 4WD. Also a 1997 Coachmen Ranger camper. Camper plate says 3000 lbs, truck weights around 7,000 lbs that puts the total at 10,000 or thereabouts.
We have the camper helper spring/sway bar setup and air bags. New studded snow tires, 10 ply, load range E. I got Torklift frame mount tie downs. Truck barely notices the camper is there. It seems to handle very well.
However, 10,000 lbs is more than the GVWR of 8,800 lbs specified for this truck. So while I feel comfortable driving this rig, I am over spec.
The RV dealer said the camper would work with this truck if I got air bags. My friends who know these trucks and also have campers said it would work.
I am not sure they make modern campers that weigh less than 3,000 lbs as the fridge, bathroom, etc. will weigh that much for sure.
This is our first pickup truck and first camper.
Please don't say I need a 3500 dually because duallys are squirelly in snow and we want this for snowmobiling.
That brings me to the next question, how to get the hitch extended 3 feet to reach the snowmobile trailer?
Thanks for any help,
Charles.
Will Sill - 27 Nov 2005 23:14 GMT I see where Charles <cstoyer@interpex.com> contributed:
>We recently got a 2001 Dodge 2500 Cummins TD quad cab long bed 4WD. Also >a 1997 Coachmen Ranger camper. Camper plate says 3000 lbs, truck weights >around 7,000 lbs that puts the total at 10,000 or thereabouts.
>However, 10,000 lbs is more than the GVWR of 8,800 lbs specified for >this truck. So while I feel comfortable driving this rig, I am over >spec. Congratulations for having the good sense to consider weight, but forgive me for saying so, if you are getting weight information out of a book, you don't have a clue what it weighs. Try a scale. With all yer stuff aboard.
>The RV dealer said . . . [blah blah blah] The typical rv dealer will tell you whatever it takes to make a sale. The honest few would not have made the deal.
>That brings me to the next question, how to get the hitch extended 3 >feet to reach the snowmobile trailer? You are gonna have to get someone else to recommend extending the hitch, as I would NEVER recommend that. Instead, extend the tongue on the trailer - it will handle far better.
Will Sill The Curmudgeon of Sill Hill
Lechugon - 29 Nov 2005 02:52 GMT > I see where Charles <cstoyer@interpex.com> contributed: >> We recently got a 2001 Dodge 2500 Cummins TD quad cab long bed 4WD. Also [quoted text clipped - 24 lines] > Will Sill > The Curmudgeon of Sill Hill Good advice on the hitch extension. I would have done the same thing he asked about, although I have the means to extend a trailer tongue. So now I know what to do.
Jim - 27 Nov 2005 23:23 GMT Slide-in Camper weight question Group: alt.rv Date: Sun, Nov 27, 2005, 3:38pm (EST-2) From: cstoyer@interpex.com (Charles)
>We recently got a 2001 Dodge 2500 Cummins > TD quad cab long bed 4WD. Also a 1997 > Coachmen Ranger camper. Camper plate > says 3000 lbs, truck weights around 7,000 lbs > that puts the total at 10,000 or thereabouts. ...snip....
I'd start by taking it to a public scale and spending about $10....Try a truck stop with a Cat scale, or a few moving companies, or look in the yellow Pages under 'Weighers'.
You'll want it loaded as for travel, including passengers, fuel, etc. Get at least axle weights and corner weights are even more useful, tho' some scales don't allow it.
Do that before you worry too much.
Jim, "On a clear night, I can hear the fish laughing."
BF Lake - 27 Nov 2005 23:24 GMT > However, 10,000 lbs is more than the GVWR of 8,800 lbs specified for > this truck. So while I feel comfortable driving this rig, I am over [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > That brings me to the next question, how to get the hitch extended 3 > feet to reach the snowmobile trailer? Been there : ( First thing is that you are in worse shape than you have stated: a. The actual weight of the camper will be way, way more than what the plate says (that's its shell weight)--have you been on the scales with and without? b. Your truck's "payload" includes gas in the tank, you , your dog, the camper, etc . The "cargo weight" is what you can put in the box. Quite a bit less than "payload", but you are way over payload , never mind cargo weight. c. You can play with stronger tires, air bags, and springs all you want for the back end, but your brakes are designed for stopping your GVWR in a certain distance, and with all that extra weight, you can't stop in time. For extra thrills go down a steep hill where all the real trucks are required to stop before that and check their brakes. d. Let's not mention that over-weight is top-weight on a truck that already sits high. e. The trailer's hitch weight is back of the axle and even more so with an extension, so you have to do the leverage calculation of the (higher) effective weight on the rear axle (and so your tires) same as shown in the driver's manual for a snow plow on the front of the truck and add that to your overweightedness. f. Does the trailer have its own brakes? If not add that to your (non) stopping distance.
There is no escaping the whole thing is just plain unsafe. We got sucked in the same way. Got the nice camper, got the matching truck. We got the "fleet manager" expert at the truck dealer to talk to the RV manager and make sure we would get the right truck. Turned out they both were out to lunch. We got screwed. The camper looked good on the truck and drove nicely. Never had an inkling we were in trouble till I took it on the scales for fun after reading an article about weights in an RV mag. (being green, I never got right into the mysteries of weight until after--just had a notion or two--not enough) Wow. Vastly overweight! Then you agonize, rationalize, do the denial/anger/routine.
Then you think about your wife in this thing and say, bugger this, and trade the camper for a fifth wheel and keep the truck. Looks like to pull the other trailer you need to get the one ton truck and keep the camper. Unless you travel where you are allowed to tow a trailer behind your fifth wheel. You likely don't take nearly as big a bath on the camper if you trade at the same RV dealer as you would with trading the truck..
Life is great if you don't weaken
Regards, Barry
J Harris - 27 Nov 2005 23:36 GMT >>However, 10,000 lbs is more than the GVWR of 8,800 lbs specified for >>this truck. So while I feel comfortable driving this rig, I am over [quoted text clipped - 61 lines] > Regards, > Barry Barry is correct on every point he's making. You don't have enough truck, and what you do have is too high off the ground.
First question I have is: If this is your first pickup and your first camper, how do you know that a dually is squirrely in the snow?
I had a Lance on an F250 single axle for awhile. Same story - way too much camper, way too little truck. I got an F350 dually to handle the weight and the horse trailer behind it. I used a 2x2 solid steel bar fabricated by a hitch shop to extend the hitch out and looking back now, that was probably a dumb thing to do. I had the power, and with the trailer brakes I could stop it, but even with the '350 I was probably overweight. That said, I've been driving trucks, buses, campers, etc for a lot of years and I felt like I was safe in it. I probably wasn't.
Best advice - don't do it with the size truck you've got.
John
Charles - 28 Nov 2005 00:17 GMT > We recently got a 2001 Dodge 2500 Cummins TD quad cab long bed 4WD. Also > a 1997 Coachmen Ranger camper. Camper plate says 3000 lbs, truck weights > around 7,000 lbs that puts the total at 10,000 or thereabouts. To answer your most favorite question, two people, tank of diesel, nothing else besides empty camper is 10,280.
I live on a hill where there are a lot of signs telling the truckers they are not down yet, 1.5 more miles of steep hills and sharp curves to go and I don't feel uncomfortable about the brakes. This is I-70 west of Denver.
Truck has the 6-speed manual and I fully intend to use gears for going slowly down hills.
Truck has rear disc brakes.
Charles
BF Lake - 28 Nov 2005 00:35 GMT > To answer your most favorite question, two people, tank of diesel, > nothing else besides empty camper is 10,280. [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > Truck has the 6-speed manual and I fully intend to use gears for going > slowly down hills. You are still in the "denial " phase. Another goodie is that if you want to go to load range G tires in the back to take the weight as at least one thing you can do, it turns out that the truck comes with rims for the Es at 80 pounds and the Gs take 100 pounds or so, and your rims are only rated to the 80 pounds. There is such a thing as a burst rim it seems. So now you get to buy new rims too. Only what about tire rotation and the spare? That's five new rims and tires and you are still deluding yourself that this will make your wife any safer.
Regards, Barry
> Truck has rear disc brakes. > > Charles Charles - 28 Nov 2005 00:47 GMT I guess I am wondering why the RV sales place, my friends who have trucks and campers and the tire guy, all who knew I was fixin' to buy a 3,000 lb camper to put on this truck didn't say something (besides needing air bags). I was worried about the weight from the get-go but no one else seemed to think this was a real problem. I can add 2 and 2 and get 4. I can also add 7,000 and 3,000 and get 10,000. And I can tell this is more than 8,800 by quite a bit.
Fix would be to buy a lighter camper, not a bigger truck. Which is what I wanted to do in the first place. Camper was only $4,400 so we can get our money back on that I think easily.
What do they make these 3,000 lb campers for?
All of the smaller, lighter campers we saw were from the 1970's and were pretty grotty. This one is really nice. Something in between would work.
So what are all the problems I will (possibly) have if I refuse to come out of denial? Failed brakes on a long steep hill? What else?
Charles
> > To answer your most favorite question, two people, tank of diesel, > > nothing else besides empty camper is 10,280. [quoted text clipped - 22 lines] > > > > Charles Frank Tabor - 28 Nov 2005 01:09 GMT >I guess I am wondering why the RV sales place, my friends who have >trucks and campers and the tire guy, all who knew I was fixin' to buy a [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > >Charles Possible roll over, rear ending that surprise stopper in front of you.
I drive a dually as a daily driver. 4wd, and it's not squirrely. Not by any stretch of the imagination. I pulls good and handles very well.
 Signature Frank Tabor
BF Lake - 28 Nov 2005 01:25 GMT > I guess I am wondering why the RV sales place, my friends who have > trucks and campers and the tire guy, all who knew I was fixin' to buy a > 3,000 lb camper to put on this truck didn't say something (besides > needing air bags). Good question. Unfortunately, "justifiable homicide" is not a valid defence for irate RVers who kill their dealers.
> Fix would be to buy a lighter camper, not a bigger truck. Which is what > I wanted to do in the first place. Camper was only $4,400 so we can get > our money back on that I think easily. Good thing! You are saved. (We bought new--very sad)
> What do they make these 3,000 lb campers for? People like us? :(
> All of the smaller, lighter campers we saw were from the 1970's and were > pretty grotty. This one is really nice. Something in between would work. May I suggest you do all the weight calculations for GCWR with your trailer (loaded with the machines) and the leverage of the trailer on the rear truck axle and get your truck front and back weights and everything all figured---and then see what is left over you can carry for a camper? Then you can choose a likely camper, but insist on taking it to the scales *before* you buy it , not taking anybody's word for what it weighs (now that you are sufficiently paranoid)
> So what are all the problems I will (possibly) have if I refuse to come > out of denial? Failed brakes on a long steep hill? What else? a. Not just on a hill. How about sailing past a stop sign and getting T-boned? b. Running over a little kid who steps out in front that you would otherwise have stopped in time for? c. Roll over
Regards, Barry
Frank Tabor - 28 Nov 2005 00:37 GMT >We recently got a 2001 Dodge 2500 Cummins TD quad cab long bed 4WD. Also >a 1997 Coachmen Ranger camper. Camper plate says 3000 lbs, truck weights [quoted text clipped - 27 lines] > >Charles. You are about 2000 lbs over gross. Air bags won't increase your weight handling. Only jack the rear end back up.
Did I say you are way overweight? Well, let me say it then, you are way over weight. Adding a trailer to the back will only make you dangerously overweight.
A 3500 Dually would be hard pressed to carry that weight. You need to do a lot better research.
 Signature Frank Tabor
William Boyd - 28 Nov 2005 03:01 GMT <snip>
> Charles. They really worked you over on this one didn't they. Nothing like being wrong and knowing it, but then to come here and expect redemption, never happen. Actually they were nice about it. Look at it this way, Barry touched on the bottom line. Liability, is the biggest factor here. You do any thing wrong and an accident occurs, you become the fall guy for it. Overloaded can affect your ability to swerve around something, increase your stopping distance. Not to mention your breakdown probability. Don't waste your time on that trip to the scales, you know the numbers already. Some, including me try to stay under weight to a point of 80% of the GVWR or GCWR numbers. Cant always do that but she stops at those points, never did like putting someone else's life in my hands. Maybe you could keep the camper and trade the truck in for an M-35 http://www.joeyoung.com/main.html ;-)
 Signature
BILL P.
2004, 2500 SLT Quad Cab, Dodge Ram, SLT, SWB, 2WD, 5.9 HO Turbo Diesel, 48RE Auto Trans, Anti-Spin 3.73 Dif.Rhino Liner, Husky 16K. Voyager Controller 2005, 27RL Wildcat, DT/PC Wi-Fi. Dual EU2000i Hondas Just Me and Dog
Chris Cowles - 28 Nov 2005 04:02 GMT > Liability, is the biggest factor here. I don't disagree with any comments made about being overweight. I do disagree with the importance of liability.
The main problem is that someone could end up dead or maimed. At that point, it doesn't really matter who's fault it is, because they're already dead or maimed.
The tragedy is what should to be avoided - not the liability for the tragedy.
 Signature Chris Cowles Gainesville, FL '00 Coleman Mesa/'05 Durango Hemi
William Boyd - 28 Nov 2005 05:28 GMT >>Liability, is the biggest factor here. > [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > The tragedy is what should to be avoided - not the liability for the > tragedy. On the contrary, avoiding the liability prevents the tragedy.
 Signature BILL P.
2004, 2500 SLT Quad Cab, Dodge Ram, SLT, SWB, 2WD, 5.9 HO Turbo Diesel, 48RE Auto Trans, Anti-Spin 3.73 Dif.Rhino Liner, Husky 16K. Voyager Controller 2005, 27RL Wildcat, DT/PC Wi-Fi. Dual EU2000i Hondas Just Me and Dog
TheSnoMan - 28 Nov 2005 14:36 GMT >>> Liability, is the biggest factor here. >> [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > > On the contrary, avoiding the liability prevents the tragedy. Not to mention that the greater "liabilty" due to a unsafe vehicle combo to begin with, the accident lawyer will clean your clock whether someone is killed or not because it will be more than a "accident" it will be for operating a unsafe vehicle too. Take more than just a motor, it take a complete package to do it safely.
 Signature ----------------- www.thesnoman.com
|
|
|