Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
HomeAnnouncements
Discussion Groups
By Brand
BMWChevroletDodgeFordGMHondaLexusMercedes-BenzNissanPeugeotToyotaVolkswagenOther Brands
By Topic
4x4 CarsRVsDrivingMaintenance & RepairCar AudioCollectible Cars
Country Specific
Australian ForumsUK Forums
ArticlesAuto InsuranceBuyingCars & TechnologyMaintenanceMiscellaneousSafety
DMV Resources
Related Topics
MotorcyclesBoatsMore Topics ...

Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / RVs / November 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

What' the truck?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
J & S - 11 Nov 2006 00:36 GMT
I have been reading the "Ford 2006 RV & Trailer Towing Guide and the F250 /
F350 Super Duty Brochure".  I am getting puzzled with some of the stuff I am
reading.

Like this about the F350 4X4, Diesel, Crew, Short bed, SRW, suspension:

Front Axle (rating @ ground) 4 X 4 = 6000 lbs.

F350 Rear Axle (rating @ ground) 4 X 4 = 7280 lbs.

Max. Payload Wt. Rating F350 4 X 4 = 11400 lbs.

5th wheel towing Max. 15400 lbs.

My question is why is the 5th wheel rating so high?  What is the
relationship between axle ground rating and max. trailer rating?   I am
interested because I want to safely tow a 12,000 lbs 5th wheel with a pin
around 1,700 lbs. and I would like to have some safety in the margins.
J & S - 11 Nov 2006 00:40 GMT
I forgot to add this;

Will the single rear wheel provide this?  I have read that with the Gross
trailer Wt. above 10,000 lbs. one should go to Dual rear wheel or the larger
trucks and beyond?  If someone can point to an easy source to understand
where these calculations are described I would really appreciate seeing that
link or links.

Thanks,
Jon
Eisboch - 11 Nov 2006 00:54 GMT
>I forgot to add this;
>
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> Thanks,
> Jon

Can't help you with specs other than the Ford Tow guide, however I have an
'05 F-350, crew, diesel, SRW with the same ratings.  I bought it to tow a
15,500 (GVW) Raptor 5th wheel.  Empty, the trailer was just over 11k lbs.  I
never towed it at full capacity ... more like 13,500.   Truck pulled it fine
and the integral trailer brakes work very nicely.

Eisboch
J & S - 12 Nov 2006 19:43 GMT
How much weight does your truck weigh on average?
Thanks

>>I forgot to add this;
>>
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
>
> Eisboch
Eisboch - 12 Nov 2006 21:45 GMT
> How much weight does your truck weigh on average?
> Thanks

Curb weight is somewhere around 7400-7600 lbs.
GVW is rated at 11,400 lbs.

Eisboch
BF Lake - 11 Nov 2006 02:31 GMT
>   I am
> interested because I want to safely tow a 12,000 lbs 5th wheel with a pin
> around 1,700 lbs. and I would like to have some safety in the margins.

That pin wt is only 14%.   It looks like you might be using the dry pin wt
listed in the brochure, but this applies to the dry wt of the trailer.  You
take these two dry wts and get the pin wt percent and then apply that
percent to the 12K to get the pin wt that goes with the 12K.   Typically,
pin wt will be~19% (some Wildcats being an exception at ~15%)  19% of 12K is
2,280 lbs pin wt.

Say the Diesel 4X4 truck weighs 7,500 lbs and has GVWR of 10K, that leaves
2,500 for payload/cargo.  The hitch in the bed might weigh 250 lbs so that
and the pin wt of 2,280 is 2,530lbs.  Now add people , dogs, gasoline,
assorted stuff.  Say another 600lbs.   Now the truck is over its GVWR by
~600lbs.

The other number is the GCWR  Diesels can pull big amounts.  But truck
weighs a lot too.  Say GCWR is 23,000 and truck weighs (loaded for trip)
7,800lbs.  Trailer can weigh 15,200.   But pin wt will be (using 19%)
2.900. So now you need the 1-ton and probably a 1-ton dually.

Look at another truck, a Chev 2500HD gas 6.0/4.10 weighs 6,700 with hitch
and people, gas, dogs. GVWR is 9,200.  Can take 2,500 pin wt.  (more than
the Diesel 4x4.) but GCWR is only 16K so max trailer is 9,300lbs (not the
10,000 as stated in the driver's manual!!!) (Diesel and transmission add
700lbs, 4X4 add 300lbs) so same truck with those options would weigh 7,700
and have pin wt capacity of only 1,500.

So you want a truck with a big engine to pull a big trailer but with enough
carrying capacity to take the carrying weight.  Lose the 4X4 and save
300lbs!   Maybe go with the big gas 8 instead of the Diesel and save more
pounds. (pay lots for gas!)
SRW 1ton Diesel with no 4X4?  Got to be careful with the math.  SRW 1ton has
only slightly more carrying capacity than  the 2500HD.   Big jump in
carrying capacity and same pulling by going to DRW.

As seen above, the trailer towing capacity in the truck brochure is with the
truck not loaded for a trip and without the heavy option package either.
You have to get the real weight of the truck with all your stuff in it, a
full tank, and the hitch installed, and go weigh it before you know for sure
what is left over for pin wt.  You can get reasonable example weights from
others here or similar forums who have that truck.

Regards,
Barry
J & S - 11 Nov 2006 03:23 GMT
This feels like good advice.  Here, in a month, I will be taking ownership
of this fiver,
give or take, and I really don't have any of the true weights.  I used
12,000 as a max. figure due to the two 6,000 lbs axle which I optionally
installed but I  now realize I forgot to record what the new Pin, Dry, and
GVWR will be.

The brochure listed a stock unit: Dry Pin 1,628 lbs. ,  dry Wt. 9,108 lbs. ,
and
GVWR 11,600 lbs.

It is hard to sit on the sidelines knowing that I have to buy this 1 ton PU
soon but
that is out of my reach 'cause I don't have my figures straight.  Back to
the chalk board.  At times like this it is good to be able to think out
loud.  Thanks for the help.

Good numbers,

Jon

>>   I am
>> interested because I want to safely tow a 12,000 lbs 5th wheel with a pin
[quoted text clipped - 48 lines]
> Regards,
> Barry
BF Lake - 11 Nov 2006 05:14 GMT
> The brochure listed a stock unit: Dry Pin 1,628 lbs. ,  dry Wt. 9,108 lbs. ,
> and
> GVWR 11,600 lbs.
>
> It is hard to sit on the sidelines knowing that I have to buy this 1 ton PU
> soon but..............

So your pin wt percent is 18 and if you"  load forward" putting your stuff
in the trailer it might be 19.  So if you get it up to GVWR (unlikely but
should plan for worst case) pin  is 2,200lbs.  Hitch 250? Also you want a
long box so you can have room for a tool box and a Honda generator and some
levelling lumber all weighing maybe 300lbs more,  so you want an allowance
of ~2,800 as the "cargo weight/slide-in camper" rating.  (found on sticker
in glove box) This cargo weight is part of the "payload" where the rest is
gasoline, you , wife, dog, etc.

Can't be that hard to find the right truck with a glove box sticker that
says it can take a 2,800lb camper in the box and has a GCWR of  20K or so.
Chev has a "light 1-ton" , a 3500 with SRW.   I think the idea is this can
carry the extra weight of the Diesel etc and still do the same cargo as the
gas 2500HD with the 6.0/4.10, but have a big GCWR.  Should be perfect for
that size trailer. Need to run the numbers--it might also be near its limits
but ok.  Don't know the Ford or Dodge equivalent, but they must have
something like that too.

Regards,
Barry
RichA - 11 Nov 2006 05:42 GMT
>I have been reading the "Ford 2006 RV & Trailer Towing Guide and the F250 /
>F350 Super Duty Brochure".  I am getting puzzled with some of the stuff I am
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>interested because I want to safely tow a 12,000 lbs 5th wheel with a pin
>around 1,700 lbs. and I would like to have some safety in the margins.

Hi,
The 5th wheel rating is high because with a 5th wheel you put a lot of
the towed weight into the box of the pickup truck as pin weight.
Usually 20 to 25 percent of the weight of the trailer.  So the max 5th
wheel tow rating is based on a weight that they figure won't overload
the vehicle and stay within it's tow rating and GCWR.  If you use a 20
percent pin weight with the 15400 lb max 5th wheel towing you get a pin
weight of close to 3100 lbs. 25 percent 3850 lbs.  If the cargo carrying
capacity is less then this with the truck fully loaded to travel, or if
this puts the truck over it's GVWR or GAWR or over it's GCWR you can't
tow that heavy of a vehicle, legally...  

With a 5th wheel the things to look at in a truck to pull it,  is it's
cargo carrying capacity it's GVWR and GAWR and it's GCWR capacity.  The
truck has to have a cargo carrying capacity that can safely carry the
pin weight of the 5th wheel plus the weight of the hitch, fuel,
passengers and anything else you may have in it.  And it fully loaded to
travel should stay under it's GVWR, GAWR and it's GCWR.

Typically 5th wheels have pin weights that are around 20 percent or so
of their total weight.  If you have a trailer that has a GVWR of 12,000
lbs.  then the pin weight should be somewhere in the 2400 lb to 2600 lb
range fully loaded.

With the truck you mention above the cargo max weight according to the
Ford site is 4000 lbs.  It's GVWR is 11,400 lbs. So you should have no
problems with a 12,000 lb. 5th wheel.  Unless you get a fully loaded
truck and carry rocks around with you.. :)

Take care and Happy Campin...
Signature

RichA
"We Get Too Soon Olde and Too Late Smart"

 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.