Car Forum / Driving, Maintenance, Tuning / RVs / July 2007
THE best 12V battery for a camper?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
nospam@sbcglobal.invalid.net - 20 Jul 2007 07:37 GMT If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most dependable 12V camper battery on the market?
Dave in Lake Villa - 20 Jul 2007 12:38 GMT Im interested in hearing what it is also. I thought the Trojan J-150 AGM Deep Cell Battery having 150 amp-hours was pretty good, but, im sure theres better . Hopefully someone in here will tell us along with the specs.
Will Sill - 20 Jul 2007 12:42 GMT I see where <nospam@sbcglobal.invalid.net> contributed:
>If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most >dependable 12V camper battery on the market? A pair of 6v golf car batteries in series. Around $50 each at Sam's Club.
Will Sill The Curmudgeon of Sill Hill
Frank Tabor - 20 Jul 2007 13:50 GMT > I see where <nospam@sbcglobal.invalid.net> contributed: >>If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most dependable 12V [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > Will Sill > The Curmudgeon of Sill Hill Those $50 batteries are closer to $80 now.
 Signature Frank Tabor Truth is the most valuable thing we have -- so let us economize it. -- Mark Twain
Will Sill - 20 Jul 2007 14:21 GMT I see where Frank Tabor <ftabor@gmail.com> contributed:
Will:
>> A pair of 6v golf car batteries in series. Around $50 each at Sam's >> Club. FT:
>Those $50 batteries are closer to $80 now. Could be. Funny thing - I tried to check on line and found nothing.
Will Sill The Curmudgeon of Sill Hill
Arnold Ziffle - 20 Jul 2007 15:06 GMT >I see where Frank Tabor <ftabor@gmail.com> contributed: > [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > Will Sill > The Curmudgeon of Sill Hill I bought two in April on sale for $69. Regular was $89, I think.
nospam@sbcglobal.invalid.net - 20 Jul 2007 15:20 GMT > >I see where Frank Tabor <ftabor@gmail.com> contributed: > > [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > > I bought two in April on sale for $69. Regular was $89, I think. Great. Now could someone kindly answer the question?
We have a Lance 815, who's battery compartment isn't large enough for two 6V's.
Frank Tabor - 20 Jul 2007 15:33 GMT >> >I see where Frank Tabor <ftabor@gmail.com> contributed: >> > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > We have a Lance 815, who's battery compartment isn't > large enough for two 6V's. Then buy the 12v agc gel cells. Deep cycle.
 Signature Frank Tabor
Mickey - 20 Jul 2007 16:49 GMT > If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most > dependable 12V camper battery on the market? Another one of these impossible to answer "what's the best" questions. Like with most of these questions the party asking gives little detail to help define BEST.
Is "longest lasting" a reliability, battery capacity or depth of discharge kind of question?
Are you asking brand or battery type?
Are you aware there a few companies that make automotive type lead acid batteries? These few companies make batteries for many companies that are marketing batteries under there own brand. Are you aware that for even major brands like say from Sears and their Die-Hard brand, they may be manufactured be different companies in different parts of the country. There might be small differences depending upon which factory they came from. Marketing companies change suppliers from time to time and so would any comments be valid for a specific brand. Example, everyone knows Wal-Mart/Sams and was recommended in one of the posts. In this area Wal Mart's batteries were manufactured by Johnson Control, one of the largest LA battery mfgrs in the country. Last fall they dropped Johnson Control and are now being made by Exide. So is any comment about this brand still valid. Are the Exide made batteries you buy from WM any different the the batteries bought from a different chain with their own brand on them that are built by Exide also?
Battery type, there is the convientional wet cell, the gel cell, and the starved electrolyte (AGM) construction. Each have there own characteristics. Within these groups you have batteries intended for starting engines, there are others intended for deep discharge and there are variations in between.
Then you have the situation of regional availability. Do you want a brand that is decent but would be difficult to find warranty coverage if you are away from an area where this brand is offered? Would you care if that replacement battery with same brand and model number were made by a different battery mfgr and possible perform differently?
Does battery location present a problem for normal and regular maintenance? If so maybe one of the maintenance free typs may better suit your needs even though it may not be the best choice from other characteristics stand point.
Sorry to be giving what some would consider a smart-a.s response but I hope it does show the futility of a "what's best" kind of question.
Mickey
no_spam@nordquist.us - 20 Jul 2007 19:14 GMT > nos...@sbcglobal.invalid.net wrote: > > If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most [quoted text clipped - 46 lines] > > Mickey Mickey: I agree. You have a good point in what you are saying. So, I will ask again what is the best battery based on those things that are important to me: 1. Overall battery capacity 2. Must be 12V deep cycle. No space for 2ea 6V 3. Plenty of space for routine maintenance 4. Cost no option 5. For me, I'll not worry about regional availability. - Personal preference. 6. Long battery warranty is important, but capacity is more important.
So, based on the above personal preferences, what do you think the best battery might be?
Dave
Tom J - 20 Jul 2007 19:38 GMT > I agree. You have a good point in what you are saying. So, I will > ask again what is the best battery based on those things that are [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > So, based on the above personal preferences, what do you think the > best battery might be? Now I can give you the best choice IMHO. If there is a West Marine near you, go in and get the largest true deep cycle battery that will fit your compartment. West has 3 types of batteries, starting, dual purpase & Deep Cycle. The last is the one you want & they are not listed on their website, but are in stock in the stores.
Tom J
nospam@sbcglobal.invalid.net - 20 Jul 2007 20:05 GMT > Mickey: > I agree. You have a good point in what you are saying. So, I will > ask again what is the best battery based on those things that are > important to me: Can you say thread hijack, a.shole?
Tom J - 20 Jul 2007 22:15 GMT >> Mickey: >> I agree. You have a good point in what you are saying. So, I will >> ask again what is the best battery based on those things that are >> important to me: > > Can you say thread hijack, a.shole? I saw the no spam and assumed it was you again. SO, what are your actual requirements if different from the hijacker??
Tom J
nospam@sbcglobal.invalid.net - 21 Jul 2007 01:38 GMT "Tom J" <tomnews@earthlink.net> wrote in message news:HB9oi.10285$Od7.246@newsread1.news.pas.earthlink.net...
> I saw the no spam and assumed it was you again. SO, what are your > actual requirements if different from the hijacker?? Thanks Tom, I think we have it sorted out. Overall capacity was #1 priority for us, as we're often dry camping away from site power.
West Marine does have the deep cycle batteries on their website (although with the usual disclaimer that shipping isn't available for most of them). The specs didn't look bad at all. But then we came across Trojan's site, and consistently glowing reviews of their batteries in various RV forums. We opted for their J150, which is rated at 280 discharge minutes at 25A. This is the largest battery that will fit in a Lance 815 battery compartment.
Thanks again all.
Dave in Lake Villa - 21 Jul 2007 12:42 GMT 'But then we came across Trojan's site, and consistently glowing reviews of their batteries in various RV forums. We opted for their J150, which is rated at 280 discharge minutes at 25A. This is the largest battery that will fit in a Lance 815 battery compartment. Thanks again all.'
REPLY: Just curious to know what youre paying for your J150 ; heres what I paid 2 years ago which i thought was a good deal :
(from my supplier) --- We do not stock the J-150 batteries. These are available only by special order. We do receive Trojan loads weekly, so I could add these to our order. Your cost on the J-150 batteries would be $148.49 each. Give me a call if you want to place an order. Thanks, Tom Baker Battery Service Corporation (800)425-4071
nospam@sbcglobal.invalid.net - 21 Jul 2007 18:43 GMT > 'But then we came across Trojan's site, and consistently glowing reviews > of their batteries in various RV forums. We opted for their J150, which [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > Battery Service Corporation > (800)425-4071 Dave, that does sound like a good deal. We checked several sources for the J150 and prices came in at $200-230.
Dave in Lake Villa - 22 Jul 2007 12:26 GMT Ok, thanks. I think youll like the J150. Its got a huge capacity rating .
Harry Harris - 20 Jul 2007 20:30 GMT > If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most > dependable 12V camper battery on the market? I'm an expert on deep cycle batteries as I use them in my all-electric RV. The best batteries, by far, that I've found are made by Rolls. They have a SEVEN year warranty and high storage capacity.
Check them out here: http://www.dcbattery.com/rollssurrettemarine.html
Harry Harris
 Signature Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com
Frank Tabor - 20 Jul 2007 20:51 GMT >> If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most dependable >> 12V camper battery on the market? >> > I'm an expert on deep sucking. > Harry Harris
 Signature Frank Tabor Q: How many lawyers does it take to change a light bulb? A: One. Only it's his light bulb when he's done.
Harry Harris - 20 Jul 2007 20:56 GMT >> I'm an expert on deep sucking. Yes, Frank, we all know you're gay but must you gay up every post?
Harry Harris
 Signature Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com
Frank Tabor - 20 Jul 2007 21:02 GMT >>> I'm an expert on deep sucking. > > Yes, Frank, we all know you're gay but must you gay up every post? > > Harry Harris I'm not the one doing all the sucking. Idiot.
 Signature Frank Tabor You will gain money by an immoral action.
Harry Harris - 20 Jul 2007 21:07 GMT >>>> I'm an expert on deep sucking. >> [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > I'm not the one doing all the sucking. Idiot. Coulda fooled me, Frank.
Harry Harris
 Signature Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com
Frank Tabor - 20 Jul 2007 22:13 GMT >>>>> I'm an expert on deep sucking. >>> [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > Harry Harris You're the fool allright.
 Signature Frank Tabor Q: What's the difference betweeen USL and the Graf Zeppelin? A: The Graf Zeppelin represented cutting edge technology for its time.
stan.birch@hotmail.com - 23 Jul 2007 04:29 GMT >If money was no object, what is the longest lasting, most >dependable 12V camper battery on the market? Rolls/Surette
|
|
|