> I'm not a fan of the parts people at my dealer. I wanted to change my oil
> at 3000 miles so I called the dealer to see if they could give me a part
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> the other, I'm pissed that they couldn't give me the part number for a 5
> dollar filter when I just spent over 30000 on a car.
> I have an idea...
> why not just *buy* the first filter from the dealership instead of
> *demanding* free information?
> Yes it will be a few dollars more than the online places, but:
> a) if you go to the dealership and pick it up you will save the shipping
> cost
Because the dealer is an hour away and the parts store I go to is 10
minutes away. There are no shipping charges involved.
> b) you will have the correct part number (on the box and paperwork) for
> future reference.
The dealer will most likely give me a Saab filter, which the parts store
doesn't stock. I was looking for a Fram, Purolator, or similar generic
filter. I wanted a third party filter that I could pick up at my parts
store.
> c) you will have maintained your dignity at the dealership and won't have
> come across as a PITA tight wad.
There are way betters ways to earn and maintain dignity than putting up
with a dealer that isn't interested in helping a customer. My next
question after "what's the part number" would have been "how much do you
charge for those filters?" If the price was fair, even if it was more
than what I would pay elsewhere, I probably would have stopped in to pick
up a couple filters the next time I was in the area. He wasn't interested
in helping me, only in taking my money. I understand his position, but
I'd rather take my money to someone will is just as interested in helping
me as they are in taking my money.
> Besides, why would you change your oil at 3000 miles? It isn't called for
> by the manufacturer and really isn't necessary.
Why not? The only reason not to change the oil is time and money. Oil
and filters are cheap and it takes only a short amount of time to change.
It never hurts to take extra good care of your car. Also, my commute is
very short, so my engine doesn't have a chance to really warm up. We've
always changed oil religiously in my house. My last car had its oil
changed at 125, 250, 500, 1000, and 2000 miles and then every 2000 miles
after that for 18 years until I got rid of it and got my Saab.
Also, the manufacturer doesn't always recommend what's best. The Passat
and Audi 1.8T engines are the same. Audi covers oil changes in the
warranty at 10000 mile intervals. VW doesn't cover oil changes and
recommends a 5000 mile interval. Same engine, same oil, but Audi doesn't
want to pay for twice as many oil changes. Do you think Saab would
recommend a 15000 mile interval if it wasn't covered under the free
maintanence?
Fred W. - 25 Jun 2004 17:12 GMT
> > I have an idea...
> > why not just *buy* the first filter from the dealership instead of
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> Because the dealer is an hour away and the parts store I go to is 10
> minutes away. There are no shipping charges involved.
In that case, ask the guy at the parts counter of the parts store.
> > b) you will have the correct part number (on the box and paperwork) for
> > future reference.
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> filter. I wanted a third party filter that I could pick up at my parts
> store.
The only part number the dealer would have given you is a SAAB one. The
don't use aftermarkeyt filters in their shops.
Please, refrain from using Fram filters. You'd be far better off not
changing the oil at all than putting one of those in there.
"Friends don't let friends use Fram" ;-)
Purolator's are fine though. I buy either these or the OEMs for my SAABs.
8< 8< 8<
8<
> > Besides, why would you change your oil at 3000 miles? It isn't called for
> > by the manufacturer and really isn't necessary.
>
> Why not? The only reason not to change the oil is time and money.
Well, that and you are supposed to allow the rings to seat before you change
the oil.
> Oil and filters are cheap and it takes only a short amount of time to
change.
> It never hurts to take extra good care of your car. Also, my commute is
> very short, so my engine doesn't have a chance to really warm up. We've
> always changed oil religiously in my house. My last car had its oil
> changed at 125, 250, 500, 1000, and 2000 miles and then every 2000 miles
> after that for 18 years until I got rid of it and got my Saab.
Well in your new SAAB, you'll go broke if you follow that zealous schedule.
Your car calls for full synthetic oil.
> Also, the manufacturer doesn't always recommend what's best. The Passat
> and Audi 1.8T engines are the same. Audi covers oil changes in the
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> recommend a 15000 mile interval if it wasn't covered under the free
> maintanence?
Probably not, but 5000 miles is a far more reasonable number than 500 or
2000.
-Fred W
Shane Almeida - 25 Jun 2004 21:10 GMT
> In that case, ask the guy at the parts counter of the parts store.
2004 9-3 Aero's don't exist in all the parts catalogs. Most list the
non-existent Vector instead. When I was looking, the catalog listed the
Vector but didn't list any parts for it. I stopped in again today and
this time they had the Fram CH9018 listed for the Vector.
> The only part number the dealer would have given you is a SAAB one. The
> don't use aftermarkeyt filters in their shops.
> Please, refrain from using Fram filters. You'd be far better off not
> changing the oil at all than putting one of those in there.
> "Friends don't let friends use Fram" ;-)
> Purolator's are fine though. I buy either these or the OEMs for my SAABs.
I figured they might be able to suggest a compatible after-market filter.
That's all I was really asking of them. Is Fram really that bad?
> Well, that and you are supposed to allow the rings to seat before you change
> the oil.
If brand new oil is okay at 0 miles, why wouldn't it also be okay at 3000
miles? How long does it take for the rings to seat?
> Well in your new SAAB, you'll go broke if you follow that zealous schedule.
> Your car calls for full synthetic oil.
Mobil 1 0W-30. I've always use fully synthetic. It'll cost me less than
200 bucks and 2.5 hours a year to change my oil every 3000 miles. That's
not much at all.
> Probably not, but 5000 miles is a far more reasonable number than 500 or
> 2000.
I never said I was reasonable ;)
Fred W. - 27 Jun 2004 12:28 GMT
> > In that case, ask the guy at the parts counter of the parts store.
>
> 2004 9-3 Aero's don't exist in all the parts catalogs. Most list the
> non-existent Vector instead. When I was looking, the catalog listed the
> Vector but didn't list any parts for it. I stopped in again today and
> this time they had the Fram CH9018 listed for the Vector.
From Purolator's web site:
http://www.pureoil.com/
2004 - SAAB - 9-5 Aero
4 cyl. 2.3L F.I. H.O. Turbo PL10241
SEARCH RESULTS
OIL L10241
AIR A25358
FUEL F64857
BREATHER N/R
PCV N/R
> > The only part number the dealer would have given you is a SAAB one. The
> > don't use aftermarkeyt filters in their shops.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> I figured they might be able to suggest a compatible after-market filter.
> That's all I was really asking of them. Is Fram really that bad?
You decide:
http://www.frankhunt.com/FRANK/corvette/articles/oilfilterstudy/oilfilterstudy.html
> > Well, that and you are supposed to allow the rings to seat before you change
> > the oil.
>
> If brand new oil is okay at 0 miles, why wouldn't it also be okay at 3000
> miles? How long does it take for the rings to seat?
I'm not sure that this is really valid , and perhaps should not have said
it. I have heard this, but can not verify it's truth one way or another.
Years ago, when I bought my '90 SAAB 900 new, it came filled with some
special break-in oil which was supposed to be changed precisely at XXX
miles. Of course that first oil change was free, which may just hgave been
a way for the dealership to get you into their shop thje first time and
set-up a running maintenance schedule.
> > Well in your new SAAB, you'll go broke if you follow that zealous schedule.
> > Your car calls for full synthetic oil.
>
> Mobil 1 0W-30. I've always use fully synthetic. It'll cost me less than
> 200 bucks and 2.5 hours a year to change my oil every 3000 miles. That's
> not much at all.
Sounds like you plan on doing all of your own maintenance? Or just the
added oil changes not called for by SAAB?
> > Probably not, but 5000 miles is a far more reasonable number than 500 or
> > 2000.
>
> I never said I was reasonable ;)
Sounds like your passionate about your maintenance, and while I still
believe 3k mile oil changes really are is not needed, I respect your passion
far more so than the guy who waits too long.
-Fred W