Last night my beloved 1997 Saab 9-5 suffered a major breakdown and I'm
looking for help in deciding what to do. I bought the car 3 years ago
with 90K miles on the clock and have added a further 65K myself. Of
late the engine has been burning more oil, and for the last few days
sounding a bit "tappety". Last night the engine cut out and would not
restart (at an unlit busy T-junction of course!) and inspection
revealed smoke coming out of the oil filler tube and the horrible
greasy yellow foam suggesting a blown head gasket.
I was recovered to my local car mechanic where the car is serviced,
and my diagnosis was confirmed. As major work is needed to replace the
head gasket it makes sense to replace the cam followers at the same
time, and fitting new piston rings might improve oil consumption.
I now have 3 choices:
1. let my local mechanic rebuild the engine (expensive)
2. buy a second-hand engine with no guarantee that it will be any
better than the old engine or indeed any cheaper.
3. buy a reconditioned engine with warranty (VERY expensive)
Any guidance/assistance/advice would be appreciated.
Many thanks,
Jim
Grunff - 10 Mar 2005 14:16 GMT
> Last night my beloved 1997 Saab 9-5 suffered a major breakdown and I'm
> looking for help in deciding what to do. I bought the car 3 years ago
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> head gasket it makes sense to replace the cam followers at the same
> time, and fitting new piston rings might improve oil consumption.
This is crazy. Unless the engine has been seriously abused, there is *no
way* it would need tappets and piston rings at 90k. Not even at 190k.
Why do you believe this is required?

Signature
Grunff
Dave Hinz - 10 Mar 2005 15:05 GMT
>> Last night my beloved 1997 Saab 9-5 suffered a major breakdown and I'm
>> looking for help in deciding what to do. I bought the car 3 years ago
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
>
> Why do you believe this is required?
Could this be the PCV/sludge problem with the B235?
Grunff - 10 Mar 2005 17:28 GMT
> Could this be the PCV/sludge problem with the B235?
Hmm, it could be - I must say, despite reading lots about this, I've yet
to see a case in real life.

Signature
Grunff
Dave Hinz - 10 Mar 2005 17:56 GMT
>> Could this be the PCV/sludge problem with the B235?
>
> Hmm, it could be - I must say, despite reading lots about this, I've yet
> to see a case in real life.
I've got one in my garage. Still haven't seen my letter from Saab yet.
Pooh Bear - 11 Mar 2005 05:49 GMT
> Last night my beloved 1997 Saab 9-5 suffered a major breakdown and I'm
> looking for help in deciding what to do. I bought the car 3 years ago
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
>
> Jim
As others have noted it might simply be a severe case of the 'sludge
problem' associated with the ( now acknowledged problematic ) engine
breather system.
Don't authorise any expensive work until that possibility is resolved.
What engine btw ?
What engine oil have you been using and what change intervals ?
Graham