Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
HomeAnnouncements
Discussion Groups
By Brand
BMWChevroletDodgeFordGMHondaLexusMercedes-BenzNissanPeugeotToyotaVolkswagenOther Brands
By Topic
4x4 CarsRVsDrivingMaintenance & RepairCar AudioCollectible Cars
Country Specific
Australian ForumsUK Forums
ArticlesAuto InsuranceBuyingCars & TechnologyMaintenanceMiscellaneousSafety
DMV Resources
Related Topics
MotorcyclesBoatsMore Topics ...

Car Forum / Saab Cars / October 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

[Saab_c900] balljoint removal/replacment on a C900 - tools? tips?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Craig's Saab C900 Site - 02 Oct 2005 06:15 GMT
Hi everyone,

I'm trying to replace a dud balljoint on my 1985 900i (they all need
replacing but one at a time suits me so far!) and am a bit stuck (for want
of a better phrase!). I've posted a couple of messages and linked to some
pictures via this forum thread:

http://www.saab900classic.net/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=137

Please take a look and let me know what you think. I could well be trying
to remove the upper balljoint using the wrong method so please jump in and
suggest some ideas! If you're interested in checking out the image
galleries themselves, the new image gallery system is accessible at:

http://www.saab900classic.net/gallery2

Feel free to create your own Saab-related image galleries and upload your
images if you would like to!

Thanks very much for any help you can provide.

Regards,

Craig.

Signature

Craig's Saab C900 Page --> http://lios.apana.org.au/~c900 Sydney, NSW Australia
 Craig's Classic Saab Workshop -- For Saab 99/C900/9000 Enthusiasts world-wide!
  http://www.saab900classic.net http://www.saab900.org c900@lios.apana.org.au
  Come and explore our site, and check out our web-forums, mailing list, etc.

Charles C. - 02 Oct 2005 13:53 GMT
Hi,

> Hi everyone,
>
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>
> http://www.saab900classic.net/gallery2

I wish you would stop talking about galleries and cr@p (below) and talk
about the ball joint.  It is confusing to understand what exactly is
your problem in between plugs for your site.

> Feel free to create your own Saab-related image galleries and upload
> your images if you would like to!
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Craig.

OK.  Whichever way you use, you must compress the coil spring with
spring clamps before you can remove the ball joint.  See more below.

============================
Spring clamps are like so (and YOU MUST use them as a pair)
http://www.tool-catalogue.co.uk/tools.php/cPath/222_60/products_id/992
The above is about the cheapest style you will get.

Look at this page and it lists more tools
http://www.tool-catalogue.co.uk/index.php/cPath/222_60

From memory the above ball joint separator would be difficult :-) to
use on one of the two balljoints - bottom probably - as there is no
space between the threaded end of the ball joint and the hub(?) where
the pivoting arm of the ball joint has to fit.

==============================

The advice I remember for doing any work like you do was to put a piece
of wood under the top wishbone and the body (the opening in the inner
wing) and jam the suspension high, with the weight of the car on the
suspension hence you jammed the wishbone high (I then clamped it on top
of jamming it).

WARNING.  Inner wings have been know to collapse when used to jam the
spring in place.

Once you take the pressure of the spring from the wishbone you can try
to remove the balljoint.

First outwards ie. remove the ball joint from the wishbone then the
final separation.
===============================

I only had to remove one ball joint and by then (because of cv boot
experience) I found the easiest way for me was to:

a. jam and clamp spring as described above.
b. Remove two bolts of brake caliper and suspend from coil spring
c. remove clip from inner boot of drive shaft.
d. remove bolts of both upper and lower ball joints
e. remove drive knuckle thingie

Take the complete hub off on the bench, you can then replace ball joints
CV boots and admire it :-)

================================

Even if you don't go for complete removal you may need to do step (c)
and less likely (e) to give you enough room to pull the ball joint
outwards from the wish bone.  You will pull out first then you will take
it off the hub.

Now I hope someone will correct my recollections.

Regards
Charles

PS.  Is this photo from this job
http://www.saab900classic.net/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.ShowItem&g2_itemId=
191&g2_GALLERYSID=318e53d2478e394ade7864c4aca34dbe

One wheel bolt being knackered?
Or is this an older photo?

Maybe I don't want to know the answer :-(

Signature

Please remove _removeme_ to reply.

John B - 02 Oct 2005 18:57 GMT
> OK.  Whichever way you use, you must compress the coil spring with
> spring clamps before you can remove the ball joint.  See more below.

Ok, I did c900 balljoints recently, and this is totally not true. You just need
to insert spacers between the body and the upper A-arm, as detailed in the
Bentley manual (and here's a tip from me- if you're not using the offical Saab
spacer tool, make sure the spacers you use on either side of the A-arm are the
same size. Otherwise the A-arm gets twisted a bit by the pressure of the spring
and it's really tough to get the ball joints in and out of the A-arm). Also, I
used a cheap ball joint fork rather than a press tool.  It took some hammering,
but it worked just fine.

Good luck,

John
Charles C. - 02 Oct 2005 19:45 GMT
>>OK.  Whichever way you use, you must compress the coil spring with
>>spring clamps before you can remove the ball joint.  See more below.
>
> Ok, I did c900 balljoints recently, and this is totally not true.

Me thinks you are wrong

(a) you did not read all the message where I mentioned jamming up the
suspension (ok you mentioned spacers).

(b) The idea of using the clamps is over and above jamming or spacing
the wishbone as they will take a lot of the tension whether the tension
goes on the wishbone or on the inner wing.  Both of which - according to
your and my message - are known to collapse.

(c) The book does not tell you to use clamps nor does it tell you that
your 15-20 year old car will collapse if pressure is put in the wrong place.

> You just need
> to insert spacers between the body and the upper A-arm, as detailed in the
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> used a cheap ball joint fork rather than a press tool.  It took some hammering,
> but it worked just fine.

And if you are lucky you will have done only small damage to the
alignment of the wishbone.  And that for a tool that costs (in Blighty
any way) 10GBP versus a fork that costs half that.

> Good luck,
>
> John

Charles :-)

Signature

Please remove _removeme_ to reply.

John B - 02 Oct 2005 20:18 GMT
> (b) The idea of using the clamps is over and above jamming or spacing
> the wishbone as they will take a lot of the tension whether the tension
> goes on the wishbone or on the inner wing.  Both of which - according to
> your and my message - are known to collapse.

Ok, fair enough. But I think that if you can't see any cracks in the A-arms
and the body is rust-free, it's probably ok.

> And if you are lucky you will have done only small damage to the
> alignment of the wishbone.  And that for a tool that costs (in Blighty
> any way) 10GBP versus a fork that costs half that.

Yes, I fully acknowledge the superiority of the press tool. I ended up using a
fork because I couldn't find an alternative in the time I had alotted for tool
shopping that day. Any damage incurred by the wishbone has yet to manifest
itself, though of course it could be subtle.

The main thing is that none of my wheels have fallen off. Yet.

John
Craig's Saab C900 Site - 06 Oct 2005 05:00 GMT
>>>OK.  Whichever way you use, you must compress the coil spring with
>>>spring clamps before you can remove the ball joint.  See more below.
>>
>> Ok, I did c900 balljoints recently, and this is totally not true.

>Me thinks you are wrong

>(a) you did not read all the message where I mentioned jamming up the
>suspension (ok you mentioned spacers).

>(b) The idea of using the clamps is over and above jamming or spacing
>the wishbone as they will take a lot of the tension whether the tension
>goes on the wishbone or on the inner wing.  Both of which - according to
>your and my message - are known to collapse.

Never heard of this happening but if the car has been abused and spacers
have not been used in the past the body metal could well be deformed or
damaged and not be able to take the pressure. My home-made spacers spread
the load out and will not slip out - that's just as important as having them
the same size, etc.

Craig.
Signature

Craig's Saab C900 Page --> http://lios.apana.org.au/~c900 Sydney, NSW Australia
Craig's Classic Saab Workshop -- For Saab 99/C900/9000 Enthusiasts world-wide!
 http://www.saab900classic.net http://www.saab900.org c900@lios.apana.org.au
 Come and explore our site, and check out our web-forums, mailing list, etc.

Craig's Saab C900 Site - 05 Oct 2005 22:55 GMT
>I wish you would stop talking about galleries and cr@p (below) and talk
>about the ball joint.  It is confusing to understand what exactly is
>your problem in between plugs for your site.

Fair point Charles. I'm sorry if anyone's getting offending by mentioning
the links into bit's of my sites in most of my postings. If anyone wants to
talk about this more please email my privately and we'll nut it out.

>OK.  Whichever way you use, you must compress the coil spring with
>spring clamps before you can remove the ball joint.  See more below.

I have made up my own upper control arm spacer tools which take the place of
Saab's special tool. Dave New's balljoint guide shows bundles of washers
taped together but I made something using pieces of 44 mm high blank rack
panel cut up and bolted so that the rough-cut edges dig into the dirt and
crud and won't slip out when the jack pushing up the lower control arm is
lowered again. I do have some pics on the site - won't post the URL at the
moment unless someone asks.

> From memory the above ball joint separator would be difficult :-) to
>use on one of the two balljoints - bottom probably - as there is no
>space between the threaded end of the ball joint and the hub(?) where
>the pivoting arm of the ball joint has to fit.

There is a little trick here - I took off the brake disk after removing the
brake caliper and holding it up with some wire (pics are online of this -
more on the digital cam which will come off later today). Then I undid the
three small 10 mm head bolts holding the protective plate onto the steering
swivel member and moved it forward, which then provides plenty of access to
get a tool (press or seperator fork as I used) into the bottom balljoint.

>I only had to remove one ball joint and by then (because of cv boot
>experience) I found the easiest way for me was to:

>a. jam and clamp spring as described above.
>b. Remove two bolts of brake caliper and suspend from coil spring
>c. remove clip from inner boot of drive shaft.
>d. remove bolts of both upper and lower ball joints
>e. remove drive knuckle thingie

>Take the complete hub off on the bench, you can then replace ball joints
>CV boots and admire it :-)

I'm trying to avoid going that far. I ended up enlisting my wife and between
the two of us we worked out that we hadn't been hitting the end of the fork
hard enough and after more brutal (controlled!) hitting with the hammer, the
swivel member dropped off the top ball joint! The bottom ball joint was
easier to remove and replacment was much easier since the whole lower
control arm could then be moved downwards with relative ease to slide the
new balljoint into place.

>PS.  Is this photo from this job
>http://www.saab900classic.net/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.ShowItem&g2_itemId=
191&g2_GALLERYSID=318e53d2478e394ade7864c4aca34dbe

>One wheel bolt being knackered?
>Or is this an older photo?

He he yes that's the side I have been working on. The car came to be with
the wheel stud broken - that definitely is a press job to get out.

That side is mostly all back together now but I've had a really good look at
all the bushes and they're all going to need replacement before I
re-register the car later in the year. I'm going to start with the shock
bushings and replace them with poly ones to try them out.

I've got a really good close-up picture of the brake caliper piston from
that side of the car which I need to pull off the camera. The caliper is in
a bit of a sad state so I'm not sure whether to have a go at rebuilding it
or just buying a remanufactured caliper to replace it.

Regards,

Craig.
Signature

Craig's Saab C900 Page --> http://lios.apana.org.au/~c900 Sydney, NSW Australia
Craig's Classic Saab Workshop -- For Saab 99/C900/9000 Enthusiasts world-wide!
 http://www.saab900classic.net http://www.saab900.org c900@lios.apana.org.au
 Come and explore our site, and check out our web-forums, mailing list, etc.

Charles C. - 06 Oct 2005 21:44 GMT
>>I wish you would stop talking about galleries and cr@p (below) and talk
>>about the ball joint.  It is confusing to understand what exactly is
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> the links into bit's of my sites in most of my postings. If anyone wants to
> talk about this more please email my privately and we'll nut it out.

No brother, it is simple.  Use a footer in your email messages separated
by two hyphens like in my message, then you plug your site there.

<snip>
No wonder you live in a dry country
http://www.saab900classic.net/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.ShowItem&g2_itemId=221

Yes you could undo the bolts of the disk guard ... mine 1983 model (long
gone to where all good old cars go) was - how to put it - a bit rusty.

Well worth working on your car.

Charles
Signature

Please remove _removeme_ to reply.

Craig's Saab C900 Site - 06 Oct 2005 22:42 GMT
>>>I wish you would stop talking about galleries and cr@p (below) and talk
>>>about the ball joint.  It is confusing to understand what exactly is
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>> the links into bit's of my sites in most of my postings. If anyone wants to
>> talk about this more please email my privately and we'll nut it out.

>No brother, it is simple.  Use a footer in your email messages separated
>by two hyphens like in my message, then you plug your site there.

I don't think I'm your brother. 8-) I do use a footer - it's called a
.signature in *nix parlance.

Craig.
Signature

Craig's Saab C900 Page --> http://lios.apana.org.au/~c900 Sydney, NSW Australia
Craig's Classic Saab Workshop -- For Saab 99/C900/9000 Enthusiasts world-wide!
 http://www.saab900classic.net http://www.saab900.org c900@lios.apana.org.au
 Come and explore our site, and check out our web-forums, mailing list, etc.

Charles C. - 06 Oct 2005 23:56 GMT
> I don't think I'm your brother. 8-) I do use a footer - it's called a
> .signature in *nix parlance.
>
> Craig.

Honestly I looked for the signature (I thought that was windoze talk)
and did not see it.  I must have looked in my quoted reply which
correctly cut it off.  APOLOGIES to you :-)

Now on you go to read my reply about the nut and the A arm :-)

Charles

Signature

Please remove _removeme_ to reply.

Tom - 02 Oct 2005 18:15 GMT
> Hi everyone,
>
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
> Craig.

This is the simple way of doing classic 900 ball joints if you do not have
the `correct` tools, Take off hub cap, loosen cv nut and wheel nuts, jack up
front of car and place on axle stands at the front jacking points and remove
wheel. Swing hub outwards so the track rod end is easier to get at, undo nut
and remove tre by giving the steering arm a whack with a hammer where the
pin of the tre goes through, A two pound hammer is about the best size.Now
place a jack under the lower wishbone where the ball joint is located and
jack up until the shocker starts to compress a little, undo lower shock nut
[11/16af] and pry away shock from mounting pin, lower the jack under the
wishbone, this allows for the the tension on the joints to be released,
easier and safer than chocking up the top arm. The next two steps are not
mandatory but it makes it easier, undo brake calliper [and cable if fitted],
hang up brake calliper up to prevent strain on brake hose, undo cv nut and
tap inwards with a copper hammer, some do requre a bit of a wallop to get
them to move, undo through nuts and bolts on joint in question and swing hub
outwards by tapping hub where the joint goes through if needed, undo ball
pin nut, using the good old two pounder a few sharp wacks on the pin eye and
out she pops. It is definately worth doing both joints at the same time as
checking for play without taking the tension of first is nigh on immpossible
and I have seen 900`s pass their mot with ball joints that are on the point
of failure. Reassembley is the reverse of what you have done [quote from
Haynes manual]. HTH Tom, Saabtech.
Jim - 08 Oct 2005 20:37 GMT
I agree with Tom's method of whacking the "pin eye" and have used the
following modified method for years:

Upon removing the ball joing nut, if it is a "castle type" I turn it
over and thread it so it is flush with the top of the ball joint stud.
Then I apply some pressure through any clamp or spreader I can to put
the ball joint stud under pressure (pushing the ball joint out). Then a
little bit of pentrating oil to help loosen any rust that may have
formed between the ball joint stud and retaining part (steering
knuckle, control arm, etc). I then whack the top of the nut to drive
the ball joint out. Sometimes if it is stubborn, I will whack the
retaining part perpendicular to the ball joint stud to set up a
vibration allowing the pentrating oil to work its way in.

Using this method I have never damaged a boot or a frame part. The
pressure on the ball joint stud reduces the amount of hammer force
needed to cause a successfull separation. I use the same method for tie
rod ends and any other similar joints.

Jim

87 C900 RIP
87 C900S RIP
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.