On Jul 28, 12:21 am, johngd...@hotmail.com wrote:
> If you still have the original alternator then you got pretty good use
> out of it. And if you still have the original battery, likewise.
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
>
> - Show quoted text -
"I personally change the battery every 5 years. No questions asked.
$39.99 (now $45) for a Johnson Controls at Walmart is a very good
deal. A weak battery strains the alternator and can cause it to fail.
"
"I'd change out the alternator ."
You are 100% correct on this.Had this happen to me twice.(Ya I know ,
slow learner LOL) but had never had this happen on a NA car only on my
Jap. cars.
I dont know why the discrepancy?
If you replace the battery ? try and replace it with one of the new
design maintenance free ones,.they are practically indestructible.
I have one in my `01 750 Shadow Ace (original) and I have one in my
`02 Camry.
Neither one (so far ) show any signs of failure.
Of course I maintain them like everyone should
Disconnect them once a year and clean the connectors and terminals
till they`re squeeky clean and then reconnect.(even if they LOOK
good).
Pretty simple really , no liquid to check in maintenance free
batteries.
Hope this helps ?
mred
johngdole@hotmail.com - 28 Jul 2007 18:25 GMT
Yes, I'd absolutely go for the AC-Delco maintenance-free batteries.
GMs and Hondas come with these. But not all Toyotas do. These have
different plate metallurgy that cuts down on hydrogen out gassing. And
they sure seem to last forever. These I'm comfortable to leave in for
7-8 years vs the 5 for standard batteries. That way only $20 brushes
around 100,000 miles is needed until the alternator bearings dry up.
Why do I swap them out before batteries fail? Because a battery is
relatively cheap compared to an alternator. A strained alternator
charging a weak battery overheats it and shortens its life. And then
people got into a cycle of replacing the battery, after the
alternator, after another battery, etc.....
IMO, ~$80 AC-Delcos are the best-in-class maintenance free batteries,
but the 24F is very hard to find. So I pick the next best - Johnson
Controls, available under many brands such as Walmart, AutoZone, etc.
Just don't get the blue light specials at any place because there are
different grades for different shopping levels.
> If you replace the battery ? try and replace it with one of the new
> design maintenance free ones,.they are practically indestructible.
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> Hope this helps ?
> mred