Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
this morning (a humid) morning, I pulled up besides a Prius at a stop
light and exhaust gases were obviously pouring out of the tail pipe.
How can this be? Assuming a Prius buyer is not do dumb as to be
sitting at a light revving the engine.
Reed - 22 Mar 2008 19:41 GMT
> Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
> understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
> this morning (a humid) morning, I pulled up besides a Prius at a stop
> light and exhaust gases were obviously pouring out of the tail pipe.
> How can this be? Assuming a Prius buyer is not do dumb as to be
> sitting at a light revving the engine.
Not an owner either, but maybe the battery (batteries ?) needed
charging ??
BTW, what happens if driver sets the heater (or A/C) to max ? Will gas
engine run as needed ???
Chas Gill - 22 Mar 2008 20:00 GMT
>> Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
>> understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> BTW, what happens if driver sets the heater (or A/C) to max ? Will gas
> engine run as needed ???
The gas engine will run under many specific circumstances but, when the car
is stationary, chiefly when (a) The cabin needs heat (b) the car has just
been started and the catalytic converter needs to be quickly brought up to
operational temperature and (c) the battery needs charging.
It is not possible to "rev" a Prius engine. The accelerator pedal is
precisely that - it makes the car go. It does NOT do this by varying engine
throttle, but by a complex combination of activities that cause the electric
motor to move the car, plus the gas motor - if needed. "Blipping" the
throttle on a Prius has no effect whatsoever on engine revs when the car is
in Neutral. This is unexpected and somewhat bizarre behaviour!
If the heater is set to max the engine will run until there is enough heat
in the engine coolant to provide sufficient heat to the cabin heater to
achieve the max temperature. In practice I think this means that it will
run most of the time when the heater setting is max. Oh, and by the way,
when it is the cabin gets VERY hot!.
I speak not as an expert but as an owner.
Regards
Chas
Tomes - 23 Mar 2008 02:09 GMT
"Chas Gill" ...
> "Reed" ...
>> kaplan3jiim@example.com :
[quoted text clipped - 31 lines]
>
> I speak not as an expert but as an owner.
Yep, this pretty much says what it is.
Tomes
kaplan3jiim@example.com - 23 Mar 2008 19:49 GMT
>>> Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
>>> understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
[quoted text clipped - 32 lines]
>
>Chas
Thanks for the clarification Chas and others.
JK
Shawn Hirn - 23 Mar 2008 03:21 GMT
> > Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
> > understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> BTW, what happens if driver sets the heater (or A/C) to max ? Will gas
> engine run as needed ???
Yes, but the fuel economy will be reduced somewhat.
Tomes - 23 Mar 2008 14:01 GMT
>> > Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
>> > understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
>
> Yes, but the fuel economy will be reduced somewhat.
Which is why I usually do not use the heater much at all unless I must.
Tomes
Chas Gill - 23 Mar 2008 14:15 GMT
>>> > Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
>>> > understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> Which is why I usually do not use the heater much at all unless I must.
> Tomes
I have to say I "just drive it" and let the car manage itself. If I'm cold
I'll use the heat and if I'm hot I'll use the cooler. Don't see a lot of
point in switching off the heater when the car is being driven - all it
means is the heat generated by the engine will go outside the car rather
than inside! Only if the car is standing for long periods will the engine
be needed solely for cabin heat. In my case (UK) the difference in gas
mileage between winter and summer is about 5 mp(UK)g I'm prepared to
tolerate this for a bit of comfort!
Cheers
Chas
Tomes - 23 Mar 2008 14:44 GMT
"Chas Gill" ...
> "Tomes" ...
>> "Shawn Hirn" ...
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> gas mileage between winter and summer is about 5 mp(UK)g I'm prepared to
> tolerate this for a bit of comfort!
Hi Chas,
My wife just drives it and that is all fine. I find myself being tuned in
to the little things. It is all good. Between us I find that I will get a
couple of MPG higher (by this I mean that I generally push the tank's MPG
average up a bit and she generally brings it down a bit to over-generalize).
I do find that the engine does indeed start up when I would expect it to be
of, solely due to the call for cabin heat. There will be times when I do
the foot trick to get it to stealth on a flat road and it just will not turn
the engine off. Turning off the heat at that moment fixes that problem I
have found.
Over the last 4 thankfulls we (together) have been getting 53 MPG average
here in NJ.
Tomes
Shawn Hirn - 23 Mar 2008 03:20 GMT
> Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
> understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
> this morning (a humid) morning, I pulled up besides a Prius at a stop
> light and exhaust gases were obviously pouring out of the tail pipe.
> How can this be? Assuming a Prius buyer is not do dumb as to be
> sitting at a light revving the engine.
The car's battery was probably low, which can happen as a result of
inefficient driving.
Elmo P. Shagnasty - 23 Mar 2008 04:08 GMT
> > Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
> > understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> The car's battery was probably low, which can happen as a result of
> inefficient driving.
Actually, it WILL happen as a result of ANY driving.
Tomes - 23 Mar 2008 14:00 GMT
"Shawn Hirn" ...
> kaplan3jiim@example.com :
>
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
> The car's battery was probably low, which can happen as a result of
> inefficient driving.
Could be, but at this time of year (and not knowing where the OP is) I would
bet on it needing heat for the cabin.
Just a guess.
Tomes
Bob & Holly Wilson - 25 Mar 2008 10:27 GMT
> . . . I pulled up besides a Prius at a stop
> light and exhaust gases were obviously pouring out of the tail pipe.
> How can this be? . . .
Several things can cause this:
1) initial warm-up - the engine runs until the catalytic converter and
engine coolant are warm enough. The earlier, 2001-03 Prius can take over
5 minutes to get the coolant warm enough. Although the 2004-current
Prius has a thermos, if it was sitting unused over a long weekend, the
hot coolant could have chilled and warm-up would take longer.
2) other loads - depending upon the cabin controls, the engine may run
to sustain coolant warmth or handle battery management. Defrost is
notorious for causing the engine to run longer.
3) warm-up phases - there are some distinct warm-up phases that might
not have been passed through.
Bob Wilson
David Kelly - 25 Mar 2008 13:16 GMT
> Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
> understanding is that the gasoline engine is not running at idle, but
> this morning (a humid) morning, I pulled up besides a Prius at a stop
> light and exhaust gases were obviously pouring out of the tail pipe.
> How can this be? Assuming a Prius buyer is not do dumb as to be
> sitting at a light revving the engine.
A Prius engine runs when a Prius engine needs to run.
If you *saw* exhaust vapors then the engine and exhaust pipe were still
cold and burning off moisture in the exhaust pipe.
Heater doesn't have to be on high for the engine to run, but the higher
its set the more the engine will run when stopped. The defroster runs
the A/C, and when sitting the engine will run about 1 minute out of 10
when the A/C depletes the battery.
Tomes - 26 Mar 2008 01:47 GMT
"David Kelly" ...
> kaplan3jiim@example.com:
>> Not an owner, but considering a Prius and have test driven one. My
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> A/C, and when sitting the engine will run about 1 minute out of 10 when
> the A/C depletes the battery.
...and if the defroster is running calling for heat the engine has an
additional demand to run at the same time.
Tomes