Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
HomeAnnouncements
Discussion Groups
By Brand
BMWChevroletDodgeFordGMHondaLexusMercedes-BenzNissanPeugeotToyotaVolkswagenOther Brands
By Topic
4x4 CarsRVsDrivingMaintenance & RepairCar AudioCollectible Cars
Country Specific
Australian ForumsUK Forums
ArticlesAuto InsuranceBuyingCars & TechnologyMaintenanceMiscellaneousSafety
DMV Resources
Related Topics
MotorcyclesBoatsMore Topics ...

Car Forum / Toyota / Toyota Cars / March 2007

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

LED bulb replacements?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Big Mama Bear - 11 Mar 2007 06:09 GMT
Given that I'd like to cut down the electrical usage in my car, because of
a marginal alternator for the power I'd like to be using, what about
replacing some of the incandescent lamps with LED's nowdays? Like tail
lights and turn signals, running lights etc? Do they have viable LED
replacements for them now, that use less current and put out as bright a
light?

Signature

- Mama Bear

Hachiroku ハチロク - 11 Mar 2007 13:57 GMT
> Given that I'd like to cut down the electrical usage in my car, because of
> a marginal alternator for the power I'd like to be using, what about
> replacing some of the incandescent lamps with LED's nowdays? Like tail
> lights and turn signals, running lights etc? Do they have viable LED
> replacements for them now, that use less current and put out as bright a
> light?

Yes, they do. You can get them at AutoZone.
Stewart DIBBS - 11 Mar 2007 15:42 GMT
> Given that I'd like to cut down the electrical usage in my car, because of
> a marginal alternator for the power I'd like to be using,

I assume you want to power a big stereo or similar thats exceeding the
alternator rating. Lets suppose that this item wants to draw 800W, or about
70A. Stop light bulbs are maybe 30W, tail lights are say 14W. Replacing
these with LED units that draw maybe 15/5W won't solve the problem.

You cannot replace headlight bulbs with an LED array replacement unit
because the reflector is designed for an incandescent point source. A
headlamp has to be designed for a LED array source.

Your only viable solution is install a higher rated alternator.

SD
Jeff Strickland - 11 Mar 2007 16:55 GMT
> Given that I'd like to cut down the electrical usage in my car, because of
> a marginal alternator for the power I'd like to be using, what about
> replacing some of the incandescent lamps with LED's nowdays? Like tail
> lights and turn signals, running lights etc? Do they have viable LED
> replacements for them now, that use less current and put out as bright a
> light?

I _think_ it would be cheaper to get a larger alternator than to swap out
the lighting system for LEDs. Don't get me wrong, I like LED lighting,
especially for turn indicators and brake lights. I just think that replacing
existing lighting assemblies with the LED-style is a costly matter. More
costly than buying a high output alternator.
Big Mama Bear - 12 Mar 2007 07:21 GMT
"Jeff Strickland" <crwlr@verizon.net>  wrote :

>> Given that I'd like to cut down the electrical usage in my car,
>> because of a marginal alternator for the power I'd like to be using,
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> think that replacing existing lighting assemblies with the LED-style
> is a costly matter. More costly than buying a high output alternator.

But some of you guys here have already told me that this engine wouldn't
keep up with a larger alternator, that I'd need a larger engine, less
gas mileage etc.

Signature

- Mama Bear

Jeff Strickland - 12 Mar 2007 16:06 GMT
> "Jeff Strickland" <crwlr@verizon.net>  wrote :
>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> keep up with a larger alternator, that I'd need a larger engine, less
> gas mileage etc.

If your ENGINE can't keep up with a larger alternator, how do you expect it
to keep up with the load you want that exceeds the capacity of the
alternator you already have?

If you plan an electric load that is larger than the alternator, then you
have to either enlarge the alternator or reduce the load. You are not going
to reduce the load by changing the lights. The lights (headlamps excluded)
only draw a few amps. Divide the total wattage of the lamps you will be
changing by 12 to determine that amps you will save.

What load are you planning to add that will cause you to exceed the
alternator's capacity?

This is one of those things where you have to decide between fuel mileage
and comfort -- assuming the new load is a comfort-based load.
Ray O - 11 Mar 2007 22:00 GMT
> Given that I'd like to cut down the electrical usage in my car, because of
> a marginal alternator for the power I'd like to be using, what about
> replacing some of the incandescent lamps with LED's nowdays? Like tail
> lights and turn signals, running lights etc? Do they have viable LED
> replacements for them now, that use less current and put out as bright a
> light?

As Stewart correctly points out, substituting LED bulbs for the tail lights,
brake lights, and turn signal indicator lights won't reduce the draw enough
to solve the problem.  It may be more cost-effective to find an air purifier
designed to run on 12 volt systems than it is to modify the car.  Depending
on what type of system you have, the only component that actually needs 120
volts is the fan, while an internal transformer drops the voltage for the
actual filter/purifier.

For example, you may be able to find a 12 volt air purifier made by whoever
made the purifier in your car.

A friend sells Living Air purifiers, which have both 120 and 12 volt
systems. http://www.thelivingairpurifier.com/order_freshtogo.htm
While the 12 volt system in not cheap at $397, it may be less expensive than
getting a custom built alternator or having a machine shop rig a custom
bracket and tensioner for a larger alternator or swapping out all of the
incandescent bulbs in the car with LED bulbs.

The Sharper Image has a 12 volt version of their Ionic Breeze purifier for
$29.95 but it looks too small to be effective.

As a gadget geek, I'm always looking for cost effective solutions to my
wants.

Signature

Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)

Big Mama Bear - 12 Mar 2007 07:27 GMT
"Ray O" <rokigawaATtristarassociatesDOTcom>  wrote :

> As Stewart correctly points out, substituting LED bulbs for the tail
> lights, brake lights, and turn signal indicator lights won't reduce
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
> For example, you may be able to find a 12 volt air purifier made by
> whoever made the purifier in your car.

Not yet, that I know of. I've suggested it to Austin Air though.

But they make air cleaners that not only have HEPA filters, but pounds
of charcoal, instead of the grams of charcoal impregnanted mats that
most air cleaners have.

> A friend sells Living Air purifiers, which have both 120 and 12 volt
> systems. http://www.thelivingairpurifier.com/order_freshtogo.htm
> While the 12 volt system in not cheap at $397, it may be less
> expensive than getting a custom built alternator or having a machine
> shop rig a custom bracket and tensioner for a larger alternator or
> swapping out all of the incandescent bulbs in the car with LED bulbs.

Ask them how many pounds of charcoal they have in them and how many CFM
they move.

The Austin Air HM200 I have in the back seat, has about 7 LBS of
charcoal and other gas adsorbing media in it.

> The Sharper Image has a 12 volt version of their Ionic Breeze
> purifier for $29.95 but it looks too small to be effective.

I think most car air cleaners are little more than overprices placebos.
And IMO Sharper Image are scum for selling those poisonous ozone
machines.

> As a gadget geek, I'm always looking for cost effective solutions to
> my wants.

Just make sure they're based on science and not just slick TV ads. :)

Signature

- Mama Bear

Bruce L. Bergman - 12 Mar 2007 09:19 GMT
>"Ray O" <rokigawaATtristarassociatesDOTcom>  wrote :

>> As Stewart correctly points out, substituting LED bulbs for the tail
>> lights, brake lights, and turn signal indicator lights won't reduce
>> the draw enough to solve the problem.

 And you'll spend a small fortune doing it - some of those LED
conversion lamps are north of %50 each.  The payback will take forever
- they're only practical for high-vibration uses like unsprung utility
trailers where regular lightbulbs get bounced to death.

 Adding a larger alternator of the same type you have now is easy -
they use the same frame size for anything from a 60A to a 90A or 100A
unit, and the wiring will plug in just the same.  The only hard part
is putting in a larger charge wire from the alternator output stud
back to the battery, to handle all the extra amps you are making.

 Go find a good local Auto Electric rebuilding shop - they can look
at what you have, tell you what it puts out now, and what they can fit
in that puts out a lot more.

 The EFI Computer can easily bump the idle speed up to cope with
spinning a bigger alternator.

 Another stop-gap trick is to get a smaller pulley for the alternator
- you overdrive it so it spins faster and puts out more power at idle.
But be warned, if you change the pulley and you like taking the car up
to redline regularly you can overspeed the alternator and make lots of
shrapnel out of it...

>> It may be more cost-effective
>> to find an air purifier designed to run on 12 volt systems than it is
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>of charcoal, instead of the grams of charcoal impregnanted mats that
>most air cleaners have.

 If this is a simple HEPA and Carbon Filter, there is just a fan
motor pushing the air through, and that's your main power sucker.  You
can get a 12-volt motor to run the fan directly, the hard part is the
mounting and shaft length and diameter to mount the right fan blade.
Or you take the factory fan out and use a small 12V radiator fan
motor.

 If it has an electrostatic capture grid, there is a high voltage low
current power supply to get 10KV - 25KV DC at a few milliamps.  For
that, you go find a power supply that will go straight from 12VDC to
25KVDC, and save the losses in the 120VAC conversion step.

>> The Sharper Image has a 12 volt version of their Ionic Breeze
>> purifier for $29.95 but it looks too small to be effective.
>
>I think most car air cleaners are little more than overprices placebos.
>And IMO Sharper Image are scum for selling those poisonous ozone
>machines.

 Ozone generators are just a High Voltage Power Supply and a set of
static transfer spikes to charge the air.  They don't do much, and
Ozone is rather corrosive in any great quantity.

   --<< Bruce >>--
Ray O - 12 Mar 2007 17:56 GMT
> "Ray O" <rokigawaATtristarassociatesDOTcom>  wrote :
>
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> of charcoal, instead of the grams of charcoal impregnanted mats that
> most air cleaners have.

>> A friend sells Living Air purifiers, which have both 120 and 12 volt
>> systems. http://www.thelivingairpurifier.com/order_freshtogo.htm
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> The Austin Air HM200 I have in the back seat, has about 7 LBS of
> charcoal and other gas adsorbing media in it.

The Austin Air HM200 is recommended for areas up to 700 SF and has a
capacity of 200 CFM.  If the 700 SF room has 8 foot high ceilings, the room
has 5600 cubic feet.  At 200 CFM, it theoretically takes 28 minutes for a
complete air change in the room.

A Corolla wagon has interior volume in the neighborhood of 120 to 150 Cu.
Ft.  At 200 CFM, your purifier can do a complete air change in less than a
minute, which sounds like overkill to me.

Assuming 150 Cu. Ft. of air in the Corolla, a 10 CFM fan would change the
air every 15 minutes, still faster than the Austin Air HM200 is designed
for.

Does your filter use electricity only to circulate air past the filter
media?  If it does, perhaps you can fabricate a shroud that fits over the
filter's air intake with a 12V fan that moves air into the shroud, kind of
like a kitchen oven's hood that moves air in reverse.  The shroud would
avoid messing with the filter itself and potentially ruining it, and being
able to move air through the filter would give you the advantages of the
nice filter without the big power draw.

>> The Sharper Image has a 12 volt version of their Ionic Breeze
>> purifier for $29.95 but it looks too small to be effective.
>
> I think most car air cleaners are little more than overprices placebos.
> And IMO Sharper Image are scum for selling those poisonous ozone
> machines.

ozone is also bad for the plastic and rubber in the car.

>> As a gadget geek, I'm always looking for cost effective solutions to
>> my wants.
>
> Just make sure they're based on science and not just slick TV ads. :)

I like to buy stuff that I can see and touch firsthand, not just on a
screen.  If I could, I would take the gadget apart and put it back together
before buying it.   ;-)
Signature


Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)

 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.