Car Forum / UK Car Forums / Driving (UK group) / November 2009
Residents parking permits, how are they enforced?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Kiteflyer - 29 Oct 2009 09:30 GMT I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. There's no room in our road because of other peoples cars, and we don't have driveways. We have asked about permits for residents, but who would enforce this? There is no way the police would. They never come out for crime. There aren't any traffic wardens in my road, so who would remove offending vehicles with no permit?
Adrian - 29 Oct 2009 10:06 GMT Kiteflyer <ann_marie050268@yahoo.co.uk> gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:
> We have asked about permits for residents, but who would enforce this? > There is no way the police would. They never come out for crime. There > aren't any traffic wardens in my road, so who would remove offending > vehicles with no permit? We have resident permits in our road, due to a commuter station in easy walking distance.
They cover one hour, mid-morning on weekdays - and are enforced by privatised "traffic wardens".
Cars without a permit aren't "removed" - they're just ticketed.
Dave Plowman - 29 Oct 2009 11:16 GMT > Kiteflyer <ann_marie050268@yahoo.co.uk> gurgled happily, sounding much > like they were saying:
> > We have asked about permits for residents, but who would enforce this? > > There is no way the police would. They never come out for crime. There > > aren't any traffic wardens in my road, so who would remove offending > > vehicles with no permit?
> We have resident permits in our road, due to a commuter station in easy > walking distance.
> They cover one hour, mid-morning on weekdays - and are enforced by > privatised "traffic wardens".
> Cars without a permit aren't "removed" - they're just ticketed. Same as here. Although before the scheme we didn't have problems with commuter parking. Wandsworth council did 'ballot' each area before introducing the scheme - but were very careful in how they grouped an area for each ballot. Had it been on a street by street basis the results would have been different. So it was really about raising revenue. I also wonder about the cost of policing it. During the hour something like 4 'wardens' will check the street. Two on scooters (dangerous) and two on foot.
 Signature *How do they get the deer to cross at that yellow road sign?
Dave Plowman dave@davesound.co.uk London SW 12
DC - 29 Oct 2009 18:12 GMT >> Kiteflyer <ann_marie050268@yahoo.co.uk> gurgled happily, sounding much >> like they were saying: [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] >commuter parking. Wandsworth council did 'ballot' each area before >introducing the scheme They do - in Wandsworth (were I live) My car was lifted last year, at 09:02.
Th truck was waiting 'rond the corner. I had overslept. :O(
 Signature The End
NM - 29 Oct 2009 19:01 GMT > >In article <7kt481F3aoir...@mid.individual.net>, > >> Kiteflyer <ann_marie050...@yahoo.co.uk> gurgled happily, sounding much [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] > -- > The End My car was lifted for no tax, the MOT had expired whilst I was abroad, I returned from Europe in the late evening, at about 0900 the next morning the car was lifted, I had to go to a pound and prove I had a legitimate booking at an MOT test station, the car was released on payment of a fine and the collection charges, I kept the MOT appointment passed and taxed the car, by lunchtime. Between 0800 and 0830 next morning the car went missing, strangely that morning it had just started to rain, there was a dry patch where the car had been with no trace of track marks showing it had been driven away leading me to believe it had been lifted on to a truck. The independent owners of the only local lift equipment who coincidentally had contracted to the council for RFL enforcement just happened to be based in a local council provided camp for Gypsies. Never saw the car again.
Dave Plowman - 29 Oct 2009 20:50 GMT > > We have resident permits in our road, due to a commuter station in > > easy [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > >commuter parking. Wandsworth council did 'ballot' each area before > >introducing the scheme
> They do - in Wandsworth (were I live) My car was lifted last year, at > 09:02.
> Th truck was waiting 'rond the corner. I had overslept. :O( Was this from a resident's parking bay - or on a yellow line? Only time I've seen a vehicle removed from a resident's bay here was after collecting several tickets - all still on the screen.
 Signature *Bills travel through the mail at twice the speed of cheques *
Dave Plowman dave@davesound.co.uk London SW 12
DC - 30 Oct 2009 20:21 GMT >> > We have resident permits in our road, due to a commuter station in >> > easy [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] >I've seen a vehicle removed from a resident's bay here was after >collecting several tickets - all still on the screen. No, Not a residents only bay, a prohibited 09:30 - 16:30 bay.
Hang on, 09:30 - 16:30.... and no yellow lines. dum, dum, DUMMMMMM
 Signature The End
Dave Plowman - 29 Oct 2009 10:50 GMT In article <5125793c-b4d2-470b-93f5-286c507c97b3@v36g2000yqv.googlegroups.com>,
> I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > There aren't any traffic wardens in my road, so who would remove > offending vehicles with no permit? If it's a public road it will have to be set up by the council. And they usually use contractors to do the enforcing. Expect to pay around 100 quid a year for this - plus the cost of any visitor or tradesman daily passes.
If a private estate you'll need a resident's committee to sort things out.
 Signature *If I throw a stick, will you leave?
Dave Plowman dave@davesound.co.uk London SW 12
JNugent - 29 Oct 2009 11:33 GMT > I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. > There's no room in our road because of other peoples cars, and we > don't have driveways. They are as entitled to park there as anyone else - including, I'm afraid, you. Your property is your house, not the road. That said, no-one is allowed to park so as to obstruct legitimate access (eg, to a drive or garage).
> We have asked about permits for residents, but who would enforce this? Local authorities decide on whether to introduce a residents' parking scheme (RPS) amd on whether and how to enforce it (it's done by traffic wardens, who are nowadays called "parking attandants").
> There is no way the police would. They never come out for crime. > There aren't any traffic wardens in my road, so who would remove > offending vehicles with no permit? If there were an offence being committed (as you describe it, there currently isn't), traffic wardens/parking attendants would enforce it. But be careful what you wish for. When RPSs are installed, the amount of parking is almost always reduced compared with before, and any parking outside the scheme (eg, parking slightly outside the marked bays or without the RPS permit being properly displayed) will attract a ticket, no matter who owns the car. It won't only be visitors who fall foul of it. It could be you.
Whether you can get a RPS will depend on the attitude of your local council to such things, as well as to the needs of other people with legitimate reason to visit the area for wiork, shopping, etc. That will CERTAINLY include sounding out the views of the workers and visitors at the hospital. If there would be nowhere else for them to go, it will militate against a RPS, which are the work of the devil in any case.
The best advice you could be given is that if reserved parking is important to you, buy a property that has it.
Kiteflyer - 29 Oct 2009 19:57 GMT > > I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > > and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. [quoted text clipped - 32 lines] > The best advice you could be given is that if reserved parking is important > to you, buy a property that has it. We are completely unable to park in our OWN ROAD sometimes, so we need to do something. Never mind people can park where they like.
I'm not moving house. I've been here 30 years. The problem has got worse since the greedy hospital put up parking charges.
JNugent - 30 Oct 2009 01:25 GMT >>> I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road >>> and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees.
>>> There's no room in our road because of other peoples cars, and we >>> don't have driveways.
>> They are as entitled to park there as anyone else - including, I'm afraid, >> you. Your property is your house, not the road. That said, no-one is allowed >> to park so as to obstruct legitimate access (eg, to a drive or garage).
>>> We have asked about permits for residents, but who would enforce this? >> Local authorities decide on whether to introduce a residents' parking scheme >> (RPS) amd on whether and how to enforce it (it's done by traffic wardens, who >> are nowadays called "parking attandants").
>>> There is no way the police would. They never come out for crime. >>> There aren't any traffic wardens in my road, so who would remove >>> offending vehicles with no permit?
>> If there were an offence being committed (as you describe it, there currently >> isn't), traffic wardens/parking attendants would enforce it. But be careful [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] >> The best advice you could be given is that if reserved parking is important >> to you, buy a property that has it.
> We are completely unable to park in our OWN ROAD sometimes, so we need > to do something. Never mind people can park where they like. With respect, "your own road" belongs to everyone and is paid for by everyone, not just you.
Yes, in terms of everyday language, we all say "my road", but that does not denote possession.
> I'm not moving house. I've been here 30 years. The problem has got > worse since the greedy hospital put up parking charges. They sound like the culprits, then.
Remember that you only want to park on the street because alternatives would cost you money. Don't blame others for behaving in essentially the same way as you. They haven't got "mug" written through them like a stick of rock any more than you do.
Kiteflyer - 30 Oct 2009 09:29 GMT > >>> I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > >>> and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. [quoted text clipped - 45 lines] > > - Show quoted text - I have NO-WHERE to park. Nothing to do with it costing money. There are no garages around and I don't want one anyway. I want to be able to park in the ROAD I LIVE IN. Not two streets away. As a lone female it can be unsafe to do this very late at night, and impossible to get heavy items to my house.
How am I behaving like them? I don't leave my car for hours every day in a small cul de sac so residents can't get anywhere near their own house.
NM - 30 Oct 2009 16:43 GMT > > >>> I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > > >>> and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. [quoted text clipped - 56 lines] > in a small cul de sac so residents can't get anywhere near their own > house. Sadly unless you want to pay for private parking of some sort you are f.cked. Everyone owns all the streets, unless you reside in a private road unadopted by the council then tough, anyone can park in your road unless there are specific regulations that prevent it or they are causing an obstruction.
I visited a hospital on wednesday where there was little parking, probably for the last time before the patient expires, I did exactly what you hate, parked in the side street, my mindset was on the hospital visit, you occasionally having to carry heavy parcels never even entered my thoughts. That would probably be typical for most of the people whose parking pisses you off.
Harry Bloomfield - 31 Oct 2009 15:35 GMT After serious thinking NM wrote :
> I visited a hospital on wednesday where there was little parking, > probably for the last time before the patient expires, I did exactly > what you hate, parked in the side street, my mindset was on the > hospital visit, you occasionally having to carry heavy parcels never > even entered my thoughts. That would probably be typical for most of > the people whose parking pisses you off. Here there is not a problem, but half a mile away there is a station with it own very large free car park for commuters. The car park does fill up, but long after the streets around the station have been filled. The road is slightly less distance to walk than the car park. The cars are left for the entire day, blocking drives, parked across the pavement, on bends and the fire brigade or ambulance would have not chance of getting through. The parking is not just inconsiderate, it is life threatening and I sypathise with those residents.
Most of these commuters have driven the half mile from home to the station, rather than walk. No one has the right to leave their vehicle parked on the road and especially not on the pacvvement, it is obstruction and should be tackled.
 Signature Regards, Harry (M1BYT) (L) http://www.ukradioamateur.co.uk
NM - 31 Oct 2009 19:29 GMT On 31 Oct, 14:35, Harry Bloomfield <harry.m1...@NOSPAM.tiscali.co.uk> wrote:
> After serious thinking NM wrote : > [quoted text clipped - 22 lines] > Regards, > Harry (M1BYT) (L)http://www.ukradioamateur.co.uk Totally wrong, everyone can leave their vehicle wherever they likevb g on the public road provided there is no obstruction caused or local traffic laws/rules contravened. AIUI technically one cannot even stop on the Queens highway without causing the offence of obstruction but I doubt if you would get any action from the authourities if you tried enforcing this. IMO what you are saying falls under the heading 'Tough sh.t'. You are right about parking on the pavement, the police / council should react to these complaints.
Dave Plowman - 01 Nov 2009 00:00 GMT > Most of these commuters have driven the half mile from home to the > station, rather than walk. No one has the right to leave their vehicle > parked on the road and especially not on the pacvvement, it is > obstruction and should be tackled. Many of the parking bays round here are marked half on the pavement. It's true no one has the right to park on the street - and that equally applies to the bit outside your house. You have no more rights to that than anyone else. But if you have a proper pavement crossing as access to off street parking you could take action against anyone obstructing that.
 Signature *It was recently discovered that research causes cancer in rats*
Dave Plowman dave@davesound.co.uk London SW 12
Dave Plowman - 30 Oct 2009 18:34 GMT In article <d9860a1f-86bf-4b8b-9479-6269673febd9@p35g2000yqh.googlegroups.com>,
> I have NO-WHERE to park. Nothing to do with it costing money. There are > no garages around and I don't want one anyway. I want to be able to park > in the ROAD I LIVE IN. Not two streets away. As a lone female it can be > unsafe to do this very late at night, and impossible to get heavy items > to my house.
> How am I behaving like them? I don't leave my car for hours every day > in a small cul de sac so residents can't get anywhere near their own > house. Probably had an effect on the house price - so you won in that way when you bought it. When I bought this house cheap there was an A&E hospital entrance just across the road. When the hospital closed the values of the surrounding properties shot up. I'm afraid it's a fact that everyone wants hospitals - but NIMBY.
 Signature *Letting a cat out of the bag is easier than putting it back in *
Dave Plowman dave@davesound.co.uk London SW 12
JNugent - 04 Nov 2009 00:07 GMT >>>>> I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road >>>>> and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. >>>>> There's no room in our road because of other peoples cars, and we >>>>> don't have driveways.
>>>> They are as entitled to park there as anyone else - including, I'm afraid, >>>> you. Your property is your house, not the road. That said, no-one is allowed >>>> to park so as to obstruct legitimate access (eg, to a drive or garage).. [ ... ]
>>>> If there were an offence being committed (as you describe it, there currently >>>> isn't), traffic wardens/parking attendants would enforce it. But be careful [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] >>>> properly displayed) will attract a ticket, no matter who owns the car. It >>>> won't only be visitors who fall foul of it. It could be you. [ ... ]
>>>> The best advice you could be given is that if reserved parking is important >>>> to you, buy a property that has it.
>>> We are completely unable to park in our OWN ROAD sometimes, so we need >>> to do something. Never mind people can park where they like.
>> With respect, "your own road" belongs to everyone and is paid for by >> everyone, not just you. >> Yes, in terms of everyday language, we all say "my road", but that does not >> denote possession.
>>> I'm not moving house. I've been here 30 years. The problem has got >>> worse since the greedy hospital put up parking charges.
>> They sound like the culprits, then. >> Remember that you only want to park on the street because alternatives would >> cost you money. Don't blame others for behaving in essentially the same way >> as you. They haven't got "mug" written through them like a stick of rock any >> more than you do. > I have NO-WHERE to park. Nothing to do with it costing money. Oh well, if money is no object, then why not park in a pay-space inside the hospital? If it is true that these terrible people are only parking in "your road" because they don't want to pay to park on the hospital grounds, there must be vacant spaces there. And if your complaint is nothing to do with it costing money to arrange your own parking, there's the problem sorted.
tim.... - 29 Oct 2009 11:48 GMT >I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > There aren't any traffic wardens in my road, so who would remove > offending vehicles with no permit? Presumably, there aren't any wardens because there aren't any parking restrictions to enforce.
Create the restrictions and the wardens will come.
tim
Adrian C - 29 Oct 2009 13:24 GMT > I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. > There's no room in our road because of other peoples cars, and we > don't have driveways. Run this idea past your neighbours.
Stick up fake A3 sized corrigated plastic notices on a few lamp posts, similar to the type used by private clamping firms. Steal some of their text (conditions that can't be enforced but what the hell - have fun!) and make up a great sounding firm name, and mention £300 towing costs.
Have a few of the neighbours feature a fake (or real - theft measure) wheel clamp on their cars for a few days at a time, together with prank stuck on "penalty notices" on the window - get those from eBay.
As long as local residents keep quiet about the fact it's not a real parking control scheme, the street should soon be clear of the villians.
Don't approach the council about making an offical scheme. You will end up having to pay for parking outside your own home, and also paying for visitors.
 Signature Adrian C
NM - 29 Oct 2009 18:45 GMT > > I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > > and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > -- > Adrian C I wonder was he there first or the the hospital. If it was the hospital then his conveyencing lawyers may be liable if they failed to make the correct searches, if they searched correctly and advised the findings then there is little he can do.
Kiteflyer - 29 Oct 2009 19:59 GMT > > I live near a hospital and people are dumping their cars in my road > > and buggering off to the hospital all day, to avoid parking fees. [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > -- > Adrian C Oh I like that. Lol!
|
|
|