When it comes down to it though do you really want a diesel?
They are noisy (and someone is bound to point out the modern ones are much
better now and agreed they are, but still not as good as a modern petrol
engine), they are poluting (again the new ones are significantly better but
still worse for the most harmful pollutants - particulates, sulphur by
products and NOx emmsions - the only thing they are better at is the CO2
emmisions) and they aren't nearly as much fun to drive. On top of all that
the fuel is a carcinogen and can be absorbed directly through the skin...
not nice!
Add to the mix the masses of torque and the way that can be hard to control
on snowy roads and I'll stick to my more expensive to run petrol car (and
convert it to LPG to get the lower running costs that diesels have)...
It seems to me the big push to diesels in Europe is a function of the Kyoto
protocol to reduce green house gasses and since the diesel has much lower
CO2 emmisions it is very popular with governments... pity they don't look at
the wider issues though.
>> I am unable to answer the question here, I think we would need to know
>> engine size (cc's), HP and configuration (sohc, dohc, ohv) and fuel
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> better
> than a gasoline one, in some cases it gets worse mileage.
Rob Guenther - 10 Sep 2004 19:45 GMT
On the comment on snowy roads - with a diesel you can easily start in 2nd
and in 3rd gear as needed... I drove a 5-speed Jetta for work thru the
winter last year and never had a problem, on ice put it into 3rd, on snow
used 2nd gear.... I have an automatic (4-spd) TDI Golf and even with poor
quality all season tires (got rid of them this spring) I never had an issue
with grip.... It's better in snow then our 960, that's for sure.
> When it comes down to it though do you really want a diesel?
> They are noisy (and someone is bound to point out the modern ones are much
[quoted text clipped - 41 lines]
>> better
>> than a gasoline one, in some cases it gets worse mileage.
James Sweet - 11 Sep 2004 03:26 GMT
> When it comes down to it though do you really want a diesel?
> They are noisy (and someone is bound to point out the modern ones are much
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> CO2 emmisions it is very popular with governments... pity they don't look at
> the wider issues though.
I rather like decent Diesels, if I could get a nice modern one in a Volvo
I'd certainly have some interest. I love my gasoline turbo but with fuel
getting pricey (yeah I know, it's cheap here in comparison) other options
are beginning to look more attractive. Those silly new hybrids will get 50+
mpg, but I find it hard to be impressed, my parents had a diesel Topaz (same
as a Ford Tempo) back in the early 80's that while the interior was
obviously cheaply made, still managed almost 60 mpg, drove nicely, and even
more remarkably, the interior remained intact in a 40 mph rollover accident.
Not to mention diesel engines lend themselves nicely to alternative fuels.