In an earlier contribution to this discussion,
> Seems like it would be a much better idea to chip the ECU than to muck
> around with inserting stuff in between it and the engine.
Thanks for your comments. What do you see as the pros and cons of chipping
the ECU vs the injector pump? [The claimed advantages of the 'chocolate box'
are DIY installation and the ability to remove it without trace - useful if
the car is still under warranty].
> Anything you do is a compromise though, from the factory the cars are
> tuned quite well already for the average driver, you can move the
> torque curve around or increase power at the expense of torque at
> other RPM's, increased fuel consumption and decreased engine life,
> there's no free lunch.
It's pretty obvious that if it delivers more torque, it uses more fuel doing
so. However, the claim is that this is offset by being able to operate in a
higher gear in a lot of cases. I would be interested to hear from users of
the device as to how this works out in reality.
The engine in my 1999 (2000MY) V70 2.5D has a flat spot at around 1200-1400
RPM - particularly when pulling away from a junction in 3rd gear. Once its
staggers above 1500 RPM, the acceleration dramatically increases. It can be
improved slightly by tweaking the injector timing, but this doesn't seem to
last long. My principal motivation for chipping is in trying to get rid of
the flat spot. Again, I would welcome comments from people with first-hand
experience.

Signature
Cheers,
Bonnet Lock
______
Please reply to newsgroup. Reply address is invalid.
James Sweet - 03 Feb 2005 03:59 GMT
> Thanks for your comments. What do you see as the pros and cons of chipping
> the ECU vs the injector pump? [The claimed advantages of the 'chocolate box'
> are DIY installation and the ability to remove it without trace - useful if
> the car is still under warranty].
It really depends on the specific ECU and what chips are available for it.
Warranty is a good point as well, for that case the external box may well be
your best route. Perhaps you could borrow one from someone for a test drive
and see how it feels? Or you could buy one and try it out for a while, if
you don't like it sell it on ebay.