Car Forum / Volkswagen / Water Cooled Volkswagen Cars / March 2007
Major coolant freak-out RIP VW Beetle 2000!??!
|
|
Thread rating:  |
JGW - 24 Feb 2007 16:10 GMT I had a total coolant leak last night (around mid-night) on the way home. I managed to find a garage a fill it back up - hoping I would be able to make it home. (Big mistake) As I was in the middle of know where and it was dark and freezing outside I decided to continue. Little did I know that I was burning big time oil. When I returned home i thought the thing was going to catch fire. Luckily it didn't ! The last mile I could hear the rattling of pistons.
Im guessing finding the coolant leak and topping it back up with oil is beyond the repair I need here !
Could my car be dead - forever !
The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on your own sucka !")
samstone@aol.com - 24 Feb 2007 16:36 GMT >I had a total coolant leak last night (around mid-night) on the way >home. I managed to find a garage a fill it back up - hoping I would [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] >The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on >your own sucka !") Ouch , getting them that hot puts strain on lots of things,, did your low oil indicator even come on ( is there any oil left )? ? Odds are not good you didn't cause damage , but -- maybe -- . Good Luck , ( i'd give it the oil it needs and just see what happens - if you're lucky it might run and sound ok - then after just a couple minutes of run time go ahead and repair the leak and replace the anti-freeze and see.) just my opinion ,but wait and see what others say
Matt B. - 24 Feb 2007 17:55 GMT >I had a total coolant leak last night (around mid-night) on the way > home. I managed to find a garage a fill it back up - hoping I would [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on > your own sucka !") How did you know you were burning lot of oil too? Blue smoke?
You can put in oil and water just to see if it starts up again and if it does, consider yourself lucky and then just get the coolant leak fixed.
JGW - 24 Feb 2007 19:18 GMT > How did you know you were burning lot of oil too? Blue smoke? > > You can put in oil and water just to see if it starts up again and if it > does, consider yourself lucky and then just get the coolant leak fixed. As I was close to home we drove past some street lights. All you could see coming out of the back was big thick white smoke ! Then the oil light came on !
Matt B. - 25 Feb 2007 02:26 GMT >> How did you know you were burning lot of oil too? Blue smoke? >> [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > could see coming out of the back was big thick white smoke ! Then the > oil light came on ! White smoke is water/steam and not oil. However if the oil light did come on you probably have a blown head gasket and oil got into the water (and lost oil pressure). Probably weren't actually burning oil but you probably lost it into the coolant.
Nate Nagel - 24 Feb 2007 19:55 GMT > I had a total coolant leak last night (around mid-night) on the way > home. I managed to find a garage a fill it back up - hoping I would [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on > your own sucka !") It may start up and run again, but you definitely did some damage. Might have cracked a head/blown a head gasket, also when you get engines that hot sometimes the rings lose their temper and don't seal right again.
I guess my advice would be to fix the leak, change the oil, see what happens. Just don't be surprised if a) you end up having to tear it down due to oil/coolant trying to occupy the same space or b) it runs OK but turns into a smoking oil burner.
nate
 Signature replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel
none2u - 24 Feb 2007 21:17 GMT Huge white smoke means head gasket not oil, Oil smoke is blue , It sounds like you blew a head gasket, And you had bad spark knocks , not piston knocking. Because it was getting severely hot. However it doesn't change anything else, until you fix it and see. I,m still hopeful at this point. Unless you know for sure the difference between oil and water smoke .And spark knocks and piston noise. You still need to fix it and try it, VWs are wound tight, Its hard to tell how bad its going to be . It may not smoke at all , or it may be a smoker now. Its about how much heat it could take, How you drove it, babying it or getting on it. and what was really going on. Good Luck.
>> I had a total coolant leak last night (around mid-night) on the way >> home. I managed to find a garage a fill it back up - hoping I would [quoted text clipped - 22 lines] > > nate Lost In Space/Woodchuck - 24 Feb 2007 23:57 GMT VW uses a steel layered headgasket and take a bunch of heat. I have seen the plastic water outlets melted off the head and the engine was still ok. You need to find out why
1- it overheated 2- why didn't you call a tow truck which is a bunch cheaper for the tow then the mess you have now!
>I had a total coolant leak last night (around mid-night) on the way > home. I managed to find a garage a fill it back up - hoping I would [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on > your own sucka !") dave AKA vwdoc1 - 25 Feb 2007 03:04 GMT Everyone would like to get to a safe place, after the vehicle has problems.
Probably should hold a class on what to do when things go awry/astray/amiss/wrong. Also things to keep in the car for emergencies like duct tape & zipties, extra coolant & drinking water, simple tools, flashlight & batteries, cell phone and/or CB radio, blanket, small properly rated fire extinguisher, flares and maybe some more things too.
Engine Idling at 5,000+ rpms = DON'T DRIVE and turn off engine immediately Major oil leak or no pressure = DON'T DRIVE and turn off engine immediately Major or minor fuel leak = DON'T DRIVE and turn off engine immediately Major coolant leak or temperature rising too high = DON'T DRIVE! But you may be able to patch things after you determine what is wrong. No Clutch Pedal = You can start it up in gear and drive it. Tire Flat = DON'T DRIVE (you can if it is an emergency but you may need a new tire and rim) until you change the tire If you drive it too fast that tire could shred and damage the fuel filler pipes besides the fact you could also lose control of the vehicle. Isn't there a recall on some models for this? I am not fond of those Fix-A-Flat cans which might be flammible.
Now with some common sense or understanding of the systems of your vehicle you can sometimes safely drive the vehicle further. Gauges can be your best friend at times if you pay attention to them along with using all of your senses including common sense. ;-)
On The Road Repairs for coolant leaks: It is best to seal or slow any coolant leaks which can be done with some simple items. Fingernail polish can seal some holes in a radiator hose along with duct tape slowing larger holes/splits. Even cutting the hose and inserting a pipe with some clamps can temporarily "fix" a leak. Running the heater FULL blast will help cool down the cooling system although you may burn up. lol Loss of hot air in the heater can be an indication of either low coolant level or coolant that is not circulating. If the V-Belt is gone you could use some stockings/pantyhose in place of it. Nowadays it is a Serpentine belt so I don't know if this trick works or not.
So it is best to have someone that keeps fingernail polish and stockings handy! lol
If you drive at least 30 mph the radiator fan is not generally needed. Turning the A/C might turn on the radiator fan and it might keep the a/c compressor off. Leaving the radiator/bottle cap slightly loose will allow the pressure not to build up in the system so hopefully the coolant will not be forced out as quick if you have a leak.
JMHO later, dave (One out of many daves)
> VW uses a steel layered headgasket and take a bunch of heat. I have seen > the plastic water outlets melted off the head and the engine was still ok. [quoted text clipped - 19 lines] >> The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on >> your own sucka !") Nate Nagel - 25 Feb 2007 13:47 GMT Just to sort-of defend the original poster... I did the exact same thing as he once... for some reason I decided to drive my '62 Stude to work one morning instead of the VW I then had as a daily driver. I left at 0-dark-hundred (probably really about 5:30, but still) and took off out of my nighborhood. Unbeknownst to me, apparently the first time I revved the engine, I blew out a freeze plug. Since there were no streetlights in my neighborhood, I never saw the steam/smoke (all the coolant had already left before I passed under any lights,) so by the time I got on the highway, everything appeared normal. The engine sound was just unusual enough that I pulled off at the first exit to check it out; as soon as I slowed down below highway speed the temp. gauge pegged (it was normal while I was cruising,) and before I could get into a parking lot (only two blocks!) the "death rattle" had started.
However, it turns out that no permanent damage occurred; I had it towed home and replaced the freeze plug, added coolant, and changed the oil, and it apparently continues to burn tires for its current owner today.
nate
> Everyone would like to get to a safe place, after the vehicle has problems. > [quoted text clipped - 72 lines] >>>The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on >>>your own sucka !")
 Signature replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel
dave AKA vwdoc1 - 25 Feb 2007 15:10 GMT Ahhh see you used your senses even the common sense! ;-) I think a lot of us have to deal with emergency situations and each one of us will decide our next course of action. Fear can make you do strange things but I am glad you decided to tow your vehicle home. ;-) And you were lucky Nate!
I hope the OP fares well too!
> Just to sort-of defend the original poster... I did the exact same thing > as he once... for some reason I decided to drive my '62 Stude to work one [quoted text clipped - 97 lines] >>>>The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on >>>>your own sucka !") Nate Nagel - 25 Feb 2007 15:17 GMT There's a lot to be said for driving a car whose whirly bits are rediculously overbuilt. IMHO that's true for both Studebakers and VWs... you can abuse the snot out of them and they generally are still repairable...
Of course, a Studebaker V-8 weighs over 600 lbs... there are tradeoffs...
nate
> Ahhh see you used your senses even the common sense! ;-) > I think a lot of us have to deal with emergency situations and each one of [quoted text clipped - 105 lines] >>>>>The garage cant look at it until Thursday (might be code for: "Your on >>>>>your own sucka !")
 Signature replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel
JGW - 25 Feb 2007 19:41 GMT UPDATE !!!
So, after inspecting the car in daylight hours I found 2 major leaks. By the time I had filled up the coolant system, put the cap back on, it was empty again !! Im going to try and temporary repair them tomorrow, and hope there aren't any more.
I also topped up the oil which was low and started up the beast. She doesn't sound too bad ! We do have a new small rattle but nothing as bad as what it was !
I couldn't see any other leaks, or parting of gaskets.
Before I unleash the beast to the garage is there anything else I could replace/check ? Should I even drive it there? (4 miles away.)
I will give you all another update after I have fixed the coolant system !
PS: In my weak defence of finding myself in this position. It was minus 20 outside, pitch black, and clever me was wearing a crap t- shirt, (and I had no phone). The headlines the next day: "Stupid VW owner now half man half ice"....... Thanks again.
PeterD - 25 Feb 2007 21:50 GMT >UPDATE !!! > [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] >owner now half man half ice"....... >Thanks again. Fix your leaks. Fill the coolant. Pray to whatever god or gods you believe in, and hope all is well.
If (big IF) after a few weeks all seems relatively normal, then you are one *lucky* guy!
Next time, take a phone and wear a jacket. Also carry a blanket in your car in the winter...
samstone@aol.com - 26 Feb 2007 11:09 GMT >>UPDATE !!! >> >>So, after inspecting the car in daylight hours I found 2 major leaks. >>By the time I had filled up the coolant system, put the cap back on, >>it was empty again !! Im going to try and temporary repair them >>tomorrow, and hope there aren't any more. That's why i suggeted to put the oil in first and see if it would start/run, before adding coolant.
>>I also topped up the oil which was low and started up the beast. She >>doesn't sound too bad ! We do have a new small rattle but nothing as [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] >>I will give you all another update after I have fixed the coolant >>system ! Yes, fix the leaks and let us know what they were. Then test things in your drive. Insure the brakes are still fine and you've got drive/ reverse , test all your systems , wipers /washer, lights horn, heater/blower, any and everything you can test. Let it run 10 minutes after it's up to normal then shut it off drain the oil, replace the filter and ( oil plug, :-) ) then add new oil. The new noise you hear maybe nothing new at all, just something you're hearing be because you're looking. But see if you can't locate it while it's running for ten minutes. Papertowel rolls or really long screwdrives sometimes help here. After the new oil/filter and you're sure you have the leaks fixed take it around the block bring it back and look for things like drips in the drive , oil in the water / water in the oil , mass amounts of oil smoke from the tail pipe. If all looks good, take it out for a long test drive. (rinse n repeat) . I'll most likely get ( flack ) from other posters about not draining the oil first but because it's winter, even heated garages only bring the oil temps up some, I don't think draining it cold does much . The garage has no magic wand that sees everything so the more you tell /give them the beter they can do their job.
>>PS: In my weak defence of finding myself in this position. It was >>minus 20 outside, pitch black, and clever me was wearing a crap t- [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] >Next time, take a phone and wear a jacket. Also carry a blanket in >your car in the winter... JGW - 26 Feb 2007 21:24 GMT The major leak came from a part (don't know the name of) which 2 senors are plugged into. As you look at the motor from the front its connected to the right of the engine. It has 3 pipes coming out of it, and like i said 2 sensors plugged into it. Bit of a poor explanation but it's also to the left of the air filter, about mid way up. I tried to see if a local repair shop had the spare part and they said they couldn't get any VW parts period ! Going to have to take it to a VW dealer :(
If anyone knows of any online pages I will happily point out the part.
Nate Nagel - 27 Feb 2007 00:14 GMT > The major leak came from a part (don't know the name of) which 2 > senors are plugged into. As you look at the motor from the front its [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > > If anyone knows of any online pages I will happily point out the part. hmmm... I think I know what you're talking about, although I can't envision it on a crossflow engine. I know the earlier engines could be backdated to a metal part but I think in your case you're stuck with getting a plastic replacement from the dealer. I think it's just called a "cooling hose flange" or something like that.
nate
 Signature replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel
Matt B. - 28 Feb 2007 05:01 GMT > hmmm... I think I know what you're talking about, although I can't > envision it on a crossflow engine. I know the earlier engines could be > backdated to a metal part but I think in your case you're stuck with > getting a plastic replacement from the dealer. I think it's just called a > "cooling hose flange" or something like that. That's probably is and FWIW it's plastic on my '91 Mk2 GTI too, so the plastic dates back quite a bit.
samstone@aol.com - 27 Feb 2007 02:28 GMT >The major leak came from a part (don't know the name of) which 2 >senors are plugged into. As you look at the motor from the front its [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > >If anyone knows of any online pages I will happily point out the part. The manifold you're talking about , would not be sold at 'part houses' just the vw dealer.>>>> OR the local junkyard. <<< The gasket or seal between the manifold and block can come from the dealer. Did this manifold crack? break? ,the leak wouldn't be the hose / connection would it?
dave AKA vwdoc1 - 27 Feb 2007 12:39 GMT Those cheap plastic coolant flange pieces just can't take the hot/cold cycles too long and they deform and disintegrate losing their sealing ability. The hole starts out circular and end up oval shaped and sometimes crack. UGLY!
You might be able to buy it online from some good VW parts houses. Although I find that the dealer, sometimes, will sell those types of coolant flanges less expensively. http://www.performance-cafe.com/index.php?cPath=6_158
So do your homework and shop around! ;-)
later, dave (One out of many daves)
>>The major leak came from a part (don't know the name of) which 2 >>senors are plugged into. As you look at the motor from the front its [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > manifold > crack? break? ,the leak wouldn't be the hose / connection would it? Lost In Space/Woodchuck - 27 Feb 2007 22:59 GMT and they melt too when there's no coolant in the block.
> Those cheap plastic coolant flange pieces just can't take the hot/cold > cycles too long and they deform and disintegrate losing their sealing [quoted text clipped - 27 lines] >> manifold >> crack? break? ,the leak wouldn't be the hose / connection would it? JGW - 28 Feb 2007 03:56 GMT On Feb 27, 5:59 pm, "Lost In Space/Woodchuck" <newsgroupma...@wildblue.net> wrote:
> and they melt too when there's no coolant in the block. They also leak pretty good when they have holes in them !
;)
Mr.JGW - 06 Mar 2007 21:50 GMT Heres what the doctor said !
Water pump - RIP
Coolant parts - RIP
Bill for the above $700 Ouch !
Now for the other thing. Either the head gasket or the head is cracked (white smoke coming out of the exhaust). To replace the gasket = $1000. To replace the head = $3000.
Christmas is cancelled !
Anybody ever tried this stuff below ?
http://www.rxauto.com/
Lost In Space/Woodchuck - 06 Mar 2007 23:58 GMT $1000 to replace the headgasket is over priced not unless you live in a BIG metro area. Labor for the head should be around 5 hours time. Consider a used head maybe...
> Heres what the doctor said ! > [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > > http://www.rxauto.com/ Mr.JGW - 07 Mar 2007 20:48 GMT On Mar 6, 6:58 pm, "Lost In Space/Woodchuck" <newsgroupma...@wildblue.net> wrote:
> $1000 to replace the headgasket is over priced not unless you live in a BIG > metro area. Labor for the head should be around 5 hours time. Consider a > used head maybe... Thanks thats what I thought too.
Have been ringing around to the smaller dealers seeing if I can get the cylinder head and gasket replaced for under $3000.
Also good idea using a used head - thanks.
JW
Nate Nagel - 29 Mar 2007 02:38 GMT This poor guy couldn't be lucky enough that this is the same part as a VR6, shouldn't Gruven have their metal replacement ready any day now?
nate
> and they melt too when there's no coolant in the block. > [quoted text clipped - 30 lines] >>>manifold >>>crack? break? ,the leak wouldn't be the hose / connection would it?
 Signature replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply. http://members.cox.net/njnagel
-- Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com
dave AKA vwdoc1 - 26 Feb 2007 05:48 GMT We wish you luck!
Where were the coolant leaks? Hoses?
> UPDATE !!! > [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] > owner now half man half ice"....... > Thanks again.
|
|
|